Potential Output and Recessions: Are We Fooling Ourselves?, Accessible Data

Accessible version of figures

Figure 1

Panel 1: US Real GDP

date US dollars, trillions
Red Black solid black dashed black solid
2000q1-2014q4 Actual GDP HP-filtered GDP Extension of HP-Filtered GDP (using the 2007q4 growth rate) parrallel to black dashed line, but shifted down so that 2009q2=actual data 2009q2
0:01 12.36 12.2 ND ND
0:02 12.59 12.29 ND ND
0:03 12.61 12.39 ND ND
0:04 12.68 12.48 ND ND
1:01 12.64 12.57 ND ND
1:02 12.71 12.65 ND ND
1:03 12.67 12.74 ND ND
1:04 12.71 12.83 ND ND
2:01 12.82 12.91 ND ND
2:02 12.89 13 ND ND
2:03 12.96 13.09 ND ND
2:04 12.96 13.17 ND ND
3:01 13.03 13.26 ND ND
3:02 13.15 13.35 ND ND
3:03 13.37 13.45 ND ND
3:04 13.53 13.54 ND ND
4:01 13.61 13.63 ND ND
4:02 13.71 13.73 ND ND
4:03 13.83 13.83 ND ND
4:04 13.95 13.92 ND ND
5:01 14.1 14.02 ND ND
5:02 14.17 14.12 ND ND
5:03 14.29 14.21 ND ND
5:04 14.37 14.31 ND ND
6:01 14.55 14.4 ND ND
6:02 14.59 14.5 ND ND
6:03 14.6 14.59 ND ND
6:04 14.72 14.69 ND ND
7:01 14.73 14.78 ND ND
7:02 14.84 14.87 ND ND
7:03 14.94 14.97 ND ND
7:04 14.99 15.06 15.06 ND
8:01 14.89 ND 15.16 ND
8:02 14.96 ND 15.25 ND
8:03 14.89 ND 15.35 ND
8:04 14.58 ND 15.44 ND
9:01 14.38 ND 15.54 ND
9:02 14.36 ND 15.63 14.36
9:03 14.4 ND 15.73 14.45
9:04 14.54 ND 15.83 14.54
10:01 14.6 ND 15.93 14.63
10:02 14.75 ND 16.03 14.72
10:03 14.85 ND 16.13 14.81
10:04 14.94 ND 16.23 14.9
11:01 14.88 ND 16.33 14.99
11:02 14.99 ND 16.43 15.09
11:03 15.02 ND 16.53 15.18
11:04 15.19 ND 16.64 15.28
12:01 15.28 ND 16.74 15.37
12:02 15.34 ND 16.85 15.47
12:03 15.43 ND 16.95 15.56
12:04 15.43 ND 17.06 15.66
13:01 15.54 ND 17.16 15.76
13:02 15.61 ND 17.27 15.86
13:03 15.78 ND 17.38 15.96
13:04 15.92 ND 17.49 16.06
14:01 15.83 ND 17.6 16.16
14:02 16.01 ND 17.7 16.26
14:03 16.15 ND 17.82 16.36
14:04 ND ND 17.93 16.46

Panel 2: UK Real GDP

date UK pounds, trillions
Red Black solid black dashed black solid
2000q1-2014q4 Actual GDP HP-filtered GDP Extension of HP-Filtered GDP (using the 2007q4 growth rate) parrallel to black dashed line, but shifted down so that 2009q2=actual data 2009q2
0:01 1.33 1.32 ND ND
0:02 1.34 1.33 ND ND
0:03 1.34 1.34 ND ND
0:04 1.35 1.35 ND ND
1:01 1.36 1.36 ND ND
1:02 1.37 1.37 ND ND
1:03 1.38 1.38 ND ND
1:04 1.39 1.39 ND ND
2:01 1.39 1.4 ND ND
2:02 1.4 1.41 ND ND
2:03 1.42 1.42 ND ND
2:04 1.43 1.44 ND ND
3:01 1.44 1.45 ND ND
3:02 1.46 1.46 ND ND
3:03 1.48 1.47 ND ND
3:04 1.5 1.48 ND ND
4:01 1.5 1.49 ND ND
4:02 1.51 1.5 ND ND
4:03 1.51 1.51 ND ND
4:04 1.51 1.52 ND ND
5:01 1.52 1.53 ND ND
5:02 1.54 1.55 ND ND
5:03 1.56 1.56 ND ND
5:04 1.58 1.57 ND ND
6:01 1.59 1.58 ND ND
6:02 1.59 1.59 ND ND
6:03 1.6 1.6 ND ND
6:04 1.61 1.61 ND ND
7:01 1.62 1.62 ND ND
7:02 1.63 1.63 ND ND
7:03 1.64 1.64 ND ND
7:04 1.65 1.65 1.65 ND
8:01 1.66 ND 1.67 ND
8:02 1.65 ND 1.68 ND
8:03 1.63 ND 1.69 ND
8:04 1.59 ND 1.7 ND
9:01 1.56 ND 1.71 ND
9:02 1.56 ND 1.72 1.56
9:03 1.56 ND 1.73 1.57
9:04 1.57 ND 1.74 1.58
10:01 1.57 ND 1.76 1.59
10:02 1.59 ND 1.77 1.6
10:03 1.6 ND 1.78 1.61
10:04 1.6 ND 1.79 1.62
11:01 1.61 ND 1.8 1.63
11:02 1.61 ND 1.81 1.64
11:03 1.62 ND 1.83 1.65
11:04 1.62 ND 1.84 1.66
12:01 1.63 ND 1.85 1.67
12:02 1.62 ND 1.86 1.69
12:03 1.64 ND 1.88 1.7
12:04 1.63 ND 1.89 1.71
13:01 1.64 ND 1.9 1.72
13:02 1.65 ND 1.91 1.73
13:03 1.66 ND 1.93 1.74
13:04 1.67 ND 1.94 1.75
14:01 1.69 ND 1.95 1.77
14:02 1.7 ND 1.96 1.78
14:03 1.71 ND 1.98 1.79
14:04 ND ND 1.99 1.8

Panel 3: Euro-Area Real GDP

date Euros, trillions
Red Black solid black dashed black solid
2000q1-2014q4 Actual GDP HP-filtered GDP Extension of HP-Filtered GDP (using the 2007q4 growth rate) parrallel to black dashed line, but shifted down so that 2009q2=actual data 2009q2
0:01 8.39 8.29 ND ND
0:02 8.46 8.34 ND ND
0:03 8.5 8.39 ND ND
0:04 8.57 8.44 ND ND
1:01 8.64 8.49 ND ND
1:02 8.65 8.53 ND ND
1:03 8.66 8.57 ND ND
1:04 8.67 8.61 ND ND
2:01 8.69 8.65 ND ND
2:02 8.73 8.69 ND ND
2:03 8.76 8.73 ND ND
2:04 8.77 8.77 ND ND
3:01 8.75 8.8 ND ND
3:02 8.76 8.84 ND ND
3:03 8.8 8.88 ND ND
3:04 8.87 8.92 ND ND
4:01 8.91 8.96 ND ND
4:02 8.96 9.01 ND ND
4:03 8.99 9.05 ND ND
4:04 9.02 9.1 ND ND
5:01 9.03 9.14 ND ND
5:02 9.1 9.19 ND ND
5:03 9.16 9.24 ND ND
5:04 9.22 9.29 ND ND
6:01 9.3 9.35 ND ND
6:02 9.41 9.4 ND ND
6:03 9.47 9.46 ND ND
6:04 9.57 9.51 ND ND
7:01 9.64 9.57 ND ND
7:02 9.7 9.63 ND ND
7:03 9.75 9.68 ND ND
7:04 9.79 9.74 ND ND
8:01 9.86 9.8 ND ND
8:02 9.82 9.85 9.85 ND
8:03 9.76 ND 9.91 ND
8:04 9.59 ND 9.97 ND
9:01 9.31 ND 10.03 ND
9:02 9.29 ND 10.08 9.29
9:03 9.32 ND 10.14 9.34
9:04 9.36 ND 10.2 9.4
10:01 9.41 ND 10.26 9.45
10:02 9.5 ND 10.32 9.51
10:03 9.53 ND 10.38 9.56
10:04 9.58 ND 10.44 9.62
11:01 9.67 ND 10.5 9.67
11:02 9.67 ND 10.56 9.73
11:03 9.67 ND 10.62 9.79
11:04 9.64 ND 10.68 9.84
12:01 9.63 ND 10.75 9.9
12:02 9.61 ND 10.81 9.96
12:03 9.6 ND 10.87 10.01
12:04 9.55 ND 10.93 10.07
13:01 9.52 ND 11 10.13
13:02 9.55 ND 11.06 10.19
13:03 9.57 ND 11.13 10.25
13:04 9.59 ND 11.19 10.31
14:01 9.62 ND 11.26 10.37
14:02 9.63 ND 11.32 10.43
14:03 ND ND 11.39 10.49
14:04 ND ND 11.45 10.55

Panel 4: Canadian Real GDP

date Canadian dollars, trillions
Red Black solid black dashed black solid
2000q1-2014q4 Actual GDP HP-filtered GDP Extension of HP-Filtered GDP (using the 2007q4 growth rate) parrallel to black dashed line, but shifted down so that 2009q2=actual data 2009q2
0:01 1.3 1.28 ND ND
0:02 1.32 1.29 ND ND
0:03 1.33 1.3 ND ND
0:04 1.33 1.31 ND ND
1:01 1.34 1.32 ND ND
1:02 1.34 1.33 ND ND
1:03 1.34 1.34 ND ND
1:04 1.35 1.35 ND ND
2:01 1.36 1.36 ND ND
2:02 1.37 1.37 ND ND
2:03 1.39 1.38 ND ND
2:04 1.39 1.39 ND ND
3:01 1.4 1.4 ND ND
3:02 1.4 1.41 ND ND
3:03 1.41 1.42 ND ND
3:04 1.42 1.43 ND ND
4:01 1.43 1.44 ND ND
4:02 1.44 1.45 ND ND
4:03 1.46 1.46 ND ND
4:04 1.47 1.47 ND ND
5:01 1.48 1.48 ND ND
5:02 1.49 1.49 ND ND
5:03 1.5 1.5 ND ND
5:04 1.52 1.51 ND ND
6:01 1.53 1.52 ND ND
6:02 1.53 1.52 ND ND
6:03 1.54 1.53 ND ND
6:04 1.54 1.54 ND ND
7:01 1.55 1.55 ND ND
7:02 1.56 1.56 ND ND
7:03 1.57 1.57 ND ND
7:04 1.58 1.58 ND ND
8:01 1.58 1.59 ND ND
8:02 1.59 1.59 ND ND
8:03 1.6 1.6 1.6 ND
8:04 1.58 ND 1.61 ND
9:01 1.54 ND 1.62 ND
9:02 1.53 ND 1.63 1.53
9:03 1.54 ND 1.64 1.54
9:04 1.56 ND 1.65 1.55
10:01 1.58 ND 1.66 1.55
10:02 1.59 ND 1.66 1.56
10:03 1.6 ND 1.67 1.57
10:04 1.61 ND 1.68 1.58
11:01 1.63 ND 1.69 1.59
11:02 1.62 ND 1.7 1.6
11:03 1.65 ND 1.71 1.6
11:04 1.66 ND 1.72 1.61
12:01 1.66 ND 1.73 1.62
12:02 1.67 ND 1.74 1.63
12:03 1.67 ND 1.75 1.64
12:04 1.68 ND 1.76 1.65
13:01 1.69 ND 1.77 1.66
13:02 1.7 ND 1.77 1.67
13:03 1.71 ND 1.78 1.67
13:04 1.72 ND 1.79 1.68
14:01 1.73 ND 1.8 1.69
14:02 1.74 ND 1.81 1.7
14:03 ND ND 1.82 1.71
14:04 ND ND 1.83 1.72

Return to text.


Figure 2: Recoveries in the Advanced Economies

percent of pre-recession trend
years (pre or post recession peak); 2000 = peak year Black line Red line Blue line
-6 years to +8 years or 1994-2008 All recessions Severe Recessions Mild recessions
94:01:00 100.33 100.19 100.16
94:02:00 100.2 100.18 99.85
94:03:00 100.13 99.59 99.86
94:04:00 100.07 99.41 99.74
95:01:00 99.81 99.88 99.85
95:02:00 99.95 99.73 100.08
95:03:00 100.08 99.46 100.24
95:04:00 100.3 99.63 100.34
96:01:00 100.27 100.18 100.57
96:02:00 100.53 100.51 100.83
96:03:00 100.37 99.73 100.84
96:04:00 100.48 100 101.04
97:01:00 100.5 100.51 101.08
97:02:00 100.35 99.82 101
97:03:00 100.4 100.08 100.99
97:04:00 100.58 100.32 100.54
98:01:00 100 100 100
98:02:00 100.04 99.64 99.61
98:03:00 100 99.19 99.17
98:04:00 100.12 100.37 99.34
99:01:00 100.15 100.22 99.43
99:02:00 100.25 100.1 99.63
99:03:00 100.06 99.91 99.53
99:04:00 100.09 100.41 99.64
0:01 100.69 100.95 99.3
0:02 98.78 98.71 98.25
0:03 97.42 97.09 97.36
0:04 97.11 95.59 97.23
1:01 96.42 93.51 97.1
1:02 96.22 91.15 96.98
1:03 96.12 90.61 97.07
1:04 95.78 89.89 96.8
2:01 95.59 90.23 96.43
2:02 95.76 90.14 96.51
2:03 95.6 89.52 96.52
2:04 95.34 89.47 96.44
3:01 95.22 89.47 96.22
3:02 95 89.18 95.94
3:03 94.69 88.81 95.92
3:04 94.99 88.86 95.65
4:01 94.84 88.93 95.06
4:02 94.61 88.68 94.53
4:03 94.52 88.52 94.23
4:04 94.28 88.14 93.53
5:01 94.21 88.3 93.43
5:02 94.25 88.25 93.33
5:03 94.26 88.35 92.99
5:04 94.16 89.12 92.92
6:01 93.91 88.61 92.93
6:02 93.68 88.54 92.81
6:03 93.4 88.18 92.56
6:04 93.32 88.26 92.46
7:01 92.95 87.54 92.58
7:02 92.92 87.76 92.38
7:03 92.79 87.38 92.5
7:04 92.68 87.59 92.24
8:01 92.57 87.72 91.91
8:02 92.33 87.09 91.63
8:03 92.16 86.98 91.33
8:04 92.04 87.26 91.24

GDP trend calculated as exponential function growing at the four-year average two years prior to the peak

Severe recessions are in the top 25th percent of recessions as measured by both depth and duration. Similarly, mild recessions are in the bottom 25th percentile of each category.

Return to text.


Figure 3: Real US GDP and HP Filtered GDP

Indexed, 2005 = 100-output gap Indexed, 2005 = 100
Dates OECD data & forecast. HP filtered vinages.
brown brown - dotted light brown light brown - dotted orange orange - dotted yellow yellow-dotted blue black
2005-2013 2005 vintage 2005 extended, using growth rate of the last data point of 2005 vintage 2006 vintage 2006 extended, using growth rate of the last data point of 2005 vintage 2007 vintage 2007 extended, using growth rate of the last data point of 2005 vintage 2009 vintage 2009 extended, using growth rate of the last data point of 2005 vintage 2013 vintage Real US GDP
2005 99.86 ND 99.83 ND 99.75 ND 99.68 ND 99.33 100
2006 103.19 ND 102.76 ND 102.36 ND 101.74 ND 101.22 102.67
2007 106.57 106.57 105.69 ND 104.88 ND 103.31 ND 102.5 104.49
2008 ND 110.06 108.61 108.61 107.33 ND 104.39 ND 103.24 104.19
2009 ND 113.66 ND 111.6 109.74 109.74 105.22 ND 103.84 101.3
2010 ND 117.38 ND 114.69 ND 112.21 106.19 ND 104.84 103.86
2011 ND 121.22 ND 117.85 ND 114.74 107.31 107.31 106.38 105.52
2012 ND 125.19 ND 121.11 ND 117.32 ND 108.45 108.44 107.97
2013 ND 129.29 ND 124.45 ND 119.96 ND 109.59 110.89 110.37

Source: OECD Economic Outlook, various vintages of actual and projected. Trends are calculated by applying an HP-filter to vintages of OECD GDP series. The trend is then extrapolated toward using the growth rate impled by the last year of HP-filtered data. The level of actual GDP is indexed to 100 in 2005.

Return to text.


Figure 4: Potential GDP Forecasts (various vintages)

years (pre or post recession trough); 2000 = trough year y/y percent change
Various Vintages of OECD GDP data
light blue line blue line black line
-8 years to +4 years or 1992-2004 1-yr pre trough trough 3-yrs post trough
1992 2.3 2.22 2.24
1993 2.29 2.3 2.32
1994 2.27 2.09 2.36
1995 2.39 2.16 2.25
1996 2.17 2.2 2.22
1997 2.28 2.39 2.09
1998 2.28 2.38 2.02
1999 2.3 2.21 1.9
2000 2.28 1.78 1.51
2001 2.26 1.68 1.53
2002 ND 1.82 1.76
2003 ND ND 1.74
2004 ND ND 1.89

Source: OECD Economic Outlook. Data are for 23 countries covering 62 recessions from 1989-2009. Lines represent the median growth rates, forecast and history, of each country/recession pair for the period closest to the pre-recession peak, recession trough, and 2 years past-trough.

Return to text.