The Federal Reserve Board eagle logo links to home page

Meeting of the Federal Open Market Committee
June 24-25, 2008 Presentation Materials -- Text Version

Presentation Materials (PDF)

Pages 197 to 253 of the Transcript

Appendix 1: Materials used by Mr. Dudley

Class II FOMC - Restricted FR

Page 1

Top panel
(1)

Title: U.S. Equity Indices
Series: S&P 500 index, Nasdaq index, and S&P 500 financials index
Horizon: August 1, 2007 - June 20, 2008
Description: U.S. equity indices stabilize. Financials continue to underperform relative to broad indices.

Source: Bloomberg

Middle panel
(2)

Title: Corporate Credit Spreads and Yields
Series: Investment grade and high-yield corporate debt option-adjusted spreads and yields
Horizon: January 1, 2007 - June 20, 2008
Description: Investment grade and high-yield corporate debt option-adjusted spreads and yields stabilize.

Source: Bloomberg

Bottom panel
(3)

Title: Global Credit Default Swap Spreads
Series: iTraxx Crossover Series 7 and Baa CDS spread
Horizon: May 1, 2007 - June 20, 2008
Description: iTraxx Crossover and Baa CDS spreads widen during the intermeeting period.

Source: Bloomberg, Lehman Brothers


Page 2

Top panel
(4)

Title: Investment Bank Equity Prices
Series: Equity prices for Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs, Lehman Brothers, and Merrill Lynch
Horizon: January 1, 2008 - June 20, 2008
Description: Equity prices for Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs, Lehman Brothers, and Merrill Lynch decline; the share price of Lehman Brothers significantly underperformed.

Source: Bloomberg

Middle panel
(5)

Title: Investment Bank CDS Spreads
Series: Credit default swap spreads for Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs, Lehman Brothers, and Merrill Lynch
Horizon: January 1, 2008 - June 20, 2008
Description: Credit default swap spreads for Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs, Lehman Brothers, and Merrill Lynch widen since the April FOMC meeting.

Source: Markit

Bottom panel
(6)

Title: Investment Bank Financial Leverage Ratios
Series: Financial leverage ratios for Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs, Lehman Brothers, and Merrill Lynch
Horizon: January 1, 2004 - May 31, 2008
Description: Financial leverage ratios for Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs, and Lehman Brothers decline sharply in the second quarter of 2008.

Source: Bloomberg


Page 3

Top panel
(7)

Title: Financial Guarantor Equity Prices
Series: Equity prices for Ambac, MBIA, XL-Cap, and AGO
Horizon: January 1, 2008 - June 20, 2008
Description: Equity prices for Ambac, MBIA, XL-Cap, and AGO decline.

Source: Bloomberg

Middle panel
(8)

Title: Financial Guarantor CDS Spreads
Series: Credit default swap spreads for Ambac, MBIA, XL-Cap, AGO, and FGIC
Horizon: January 1, 2008 - June 20, 2008
Description: Credit default swap spreads for Ambac, MBIA, XL-Cap, AGO, and FGIC widen.

Source: Markit

Bottom panel
(9)

Title: Ten- and Thirty-Year AAA-Rated Municipals
Series: Ratio of the 10-Year AAA-rated municipal yields to the 10-Year Treasury yield and the ratio of the 30-Year AAA-rated municipal yield to the 30-Year Treasury yield
Horizon: January 1, 2007 - June 20, 2008
Description: The ratios of 10- and 30-year AAA-rated municipal debt yields to Treasury yields continue to decline from levels observed in March.

Source: Bloomberg


Page 4

Top panel
(10)

Title: One-Month Libor-OIS Spreads
Series: Spreads between one-month Libor rates and one-month overnight index swap rates for U.S., U.K., and Euro Area
Horizon: August 14, 2007 - June 20, 2008
Description: The spreads between one-month Libor rates and one-month overnight index swap rates for the U.S., U.K., and Euro area stabilize at elevated levels.

Source: Bloomberg

Middle panel
(11)

Title: Three-Month Libor-OIS Spreads
Series: Spreads between three-month Libor rate and three-month overnight index swap rates for U.S., U.K., and Euro Area
Horizon: August 14, 2007 - June 20, 2008
Description: The spreads between three-month Libor rates and three-month overnight index swap rates for the U.S., U.K., and Euro area stabilize at elevated levels.

Source: Bloomberg


Page 5

Top panel
(12)

Title: Federal Reserve Term Auction Facility Results
Series: TAF auction size and spread between the TAF stop-out and minimum bid rates
Horizon: December 20, 2007 - June 19, 2008
Description: The spread between the TAF stop-out and the minimum bid rates declines since the April FOMC meeting, and the size of the TAF auctions was increased.

Source: Federal Reserve Board

Middle panel
(13)

Title: Central Bank Term Funding Facilities' Bid-to-Cover Ratios
Series: Bid-to-cover ratios for the Federal Reserve Term Auction Facility, the European Central Bank foreign exchange swap line, and Swiss National Bank foreign exchange swap line
Horizon: December 20, 2007 - June 19, 2008
Description: Bid-to-cover ratios in the European Central Bank and Swiss National Bank U.S. dollar auctions have recently been higher than the bid-to-cover ratio in the Federal Reserve TAF auctions.

Source: Federal Reserve Board, European Central Bank, Swiss National Bank


Page 6

Top panel
(14)

Title: Commodity Prices
Series: GSCI spot, energy, agriculture, and industrial metals indices
Horizon: January 1, 2008 - June 20, 2008
Description: The rise in commodity prices during the intermeeting period was largely concentrated in the energy and the agriculture sectors.

Source: Bloomberg

Middle panel
(15)

Title: Dollar Stabilizes
Series: Yen-USD, Euro-USD, and broad trade-weighted dollar
Horizon: January 1, 2008 - June 20, 2008
Description: Since the April FOMC meeting, the U.S. dollar has appreciated against the Japanese yen and stabilized against the euro. The broad trade-weighted dollar has been stable since March.

Source: Bloomberg and Federal Reserve Board

Bottom panel
(16)

Title: Correlation Between Weekly Changes in Spot WTI Crude Oil and the Trade-Weighted Dollar
Series: Six-month rolling correlation of percent changes in the weekly average of daily closing prices of the WTI spot crude oil price and the Federal Reserve Board's nominal trade-weighted dollar index, and the one-year moving average of this correlation
Horizon: January 1, 1987 - June 2, 2008
Description: The correlation between the spot WTI crude oil price and the nominal trade-weighted dollar has been increasing since the beginning of 2005, though has moderated over recent months.

** One-year rolling correlation of percentage changes in the weekly average of daily closing prices of the WTI spot crude oil price and the Federal Reserve Board's nominal trade-weighted dollar index (vis-à-vis major currencies).

Source: Federal Reserve Board, CEIC


Page 7

Top panel
(17)

Title: University of Michigan Inflation Expectations
Series: One- and Five-Year University of Michigan Survey Inflation Expectations
Horizon: June 1, 1980 - June 20, 2008
Description: 1- and 5-year University of Michigan Survey inflation expectations increase in recent months. The 1-year measure is at its highest level in over 25 years, while the 5-year measure has risen only modestly.

Source: Bloomberg

Middle panel
(18)

Title: TIPS Implied Average Rate of Inflation: 5-10 Year Horizon
Series: Federal Reserve Board's 5-10 Year horizon TIPS inflation compensation and Barclays' 5-10 Year horizon TIPS inflation compensation
Horizon: August 1, 2007 - June 20, 2008
Description: TIPS inflation compensation over a 5-10 year horizon was relatively unchanged since the April FOMC meeting as measured by both the Federal Reserve Board and Barclays.

Source: Federal Reserve Board, Barclays Capital


Page 8

Top panel
(19)

Title: Fed Funds Futures Curves
Series: Fed funds futures curve as of 3/17/2008, 4/29/2008, and 6/20/2008
Horizon: March 17, 2008 - June 20, 2008
Description: The fed funds futures curve steepens since the April FOMC meeting.

Source: Bloomberg

Middle panel
(20)

Title: Eurodollar Futures Curves
Series: Eurodollar futures curve as of 3/17/2008, 4/29/2008, and 6/20/2008
Horizon: March 17, 2008 - June 20, 2008
Description: The Eurodollar futures curve has shifted higher since the April FOMC meeting.

Source: Bloomberg


Page 9

Top panel
(21)

Title: Distribution of Expected Policy Target Rate Among Primary Dealers Prior to June 25 FOMC Meeting
Series: Dealer expectations for policy target rate by quarter, average forecast for policy target by quarter, and market rate for policy expectation by quarter as of 6/16/2008
Horizon: 2008:Q2 - 2009:Q4
Description: On average, primary dealers expect lower policy rates than what is currently priced into Eurodollar futures for 2008.

Source: Dealer Policy Survey

Middle panel
(22)

Title: Distribution of Expected Policy Target Rate Among Primary Dealers Prior to April 29-30 FOMC Meeting
Series: Dealer expectations for policy target rate by quarter, average forecast for policy target by quarter, and market rate for policy expectation by quarter as of 4/21/2008
Horizon: 2008:Q2 - 2009:Q4
Description: On average, primary dealers expect lower policy rates than what was priced into Eurodollar futures at the time of the April FOMC meeting.

Source: Dealer Policy Survey


Page 10

Top panel
(23)

Title: Probabilities for Policy Rate Outcomes for June FOMC Meeting
Series: Probabilities for a 1.50, 1.75, 2.00, or 2.25 percent target rate at the June FOMC meeting
Horizon: April 1, 2008 - June 20, 2008
Description: At the time of the June 25 FOMC meeting, options on fed funds futures suggested a 2.00 percent target rate was the most likely outcome following the meeting.

Source: Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland

Middle panel
(24)

Title: Probabilities for Policy Rate Outcomes for August FOMC Meeting
Series: Probabilities for a 1.75, 2.00, 2.25, or 2.50 percent target rate at the August FOMC meeting
Horizon: May 9, 2008 - June 20, 2008
Description: At the time of the June 25 FOMC meeting, options on fed funds futures suggested a 2.00 percent target rate was the most likely outcome following the August 5 FOMC meeting.

Source: Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland

Bottom panel
(25)

Title: Considerable Tightening Expected Over the Next Year
Series: Spread between the fourth Eurodollar futures contract and the fed funds target rate adjusted based on forward Libor-fed funds basis swap spreads for the 9/4/1992, 1/31/1996, 11/17/1998, 6/25/2003, and 4/30/2008 FOMC meetings
Horizon: September 4, 1992 - April 30, 2008
Description: The magnitude of policy rate increases anticipated over the next year is greater than that which was priced in over a similar time horizon at the conclusion of the last 3 policy easing cycles, in 2003, 1998, and 1996.

Note: Dates represent last interest rate cut of previous cycles and assumes 4/30/08 is the last interest rate cut of the current cycle.

Source: Bloomberg


APPENDIX: Reference Exhibits

Page 11

Top panel
(26) Federal Reserve Term Auction Facility Results
December 20, 2007 - June 19, 2008
Auction
Settlement
Term Amount Minimum
Bid Rate
Stop-out
Rate
Propositions Bid/Cover Bidders
12/20/2007 28 Days $20 b 4.17% 4.65% $61.6 b 3.08 93
12/27/2007 35 Days $20 b 4.15% 4.67% $57.7 b 2.88 73
1/17/2008 28 Days $30 b 3.88% 3.95% $55.5 b 1.85 56
1/31/2008 28 Days $30 b 3.10% 3.12% $37.5 b 1.25 52
2/14/2008 28 Days $30 b 2.86% 3.01% $58.4 b 1.95 66
2/28/2008 28 Days $30 b 2.81% 3.08% $68.0 b 2.27 72
3/13/2008 28 Days $50 b 2.39% 2.80% $92.6 b 1.85 82
3/27/2008 28 Days $50 b 2.19% 2.62% $88.9 b 1.78 88
4/10/2008 28 Days $50 b 2.11% 2.82% $91.6 b 1.83 79
4/24/2008 28 Days $50 b 2.05% 2.87% $88.9 b 1.77 89
5/8/2008 28 Days $75 b 2.00% 2.22% $96.8 b 1.29 71
5/22/2008 28 Days $75 b 1.99% 2.10% $84.4 b 1.13 75
6/5/2008 28 Days $75 b 2.00% 2.26% $95.9 b 1.28 73
6/19/2008 28 Days $75 b 2.05% 2.36% $89.4 b 1.19 76

Source: Federal Reserve Board


Page 12

Top panel
(27) Term Securities Lending Facility Auction Results
Auction
Settlement
Term Collateral Amount Minimum
Fee Rate
Stop-out
Rate
Propositions Bid/Cover
3/28/2008 28 Days Schedule 2 $75 b 0.25% 0.33% $86.1 b 1.15
4/4/2008 28 Days Schedule 1 $25 b 0.10% 0.16% $46.9 b 1.88
4/11/2008 28 Days Schedule 2 $50 b 0.25% 0.25% $40.0 b 0.68
4/18/2008 28 Days Schedule 1 $25 b 0.10% 0.10% $35.1 b 1.40
4/25/2008 28 Days Schedule 2 $75 b 0.25% 0.25% $59.5 b 0.79
5/2/2008 28 Days Schedule 1 $25 b 0.10% 0.10% $24.1 b 0.96
5/9/2008 28 Days Schedule 2 $50 b 0.25% 0.25% $28.7 b 0.58
5/16/2008 28 Days Schedule 1 $25 b 0.10% 0.10% $7.2 b 0.29
5/23/2008 28 Days Schedule 2 $75 b 0.25% 0.25% $46.1 b 0.62
5/30/2008 28 Days Schedule 1 $25 b 0.10% 0.10% $16.4 b 0.66
6/6/2008 28 Days Schedule 2 $50 b 0.25% 0.25% $26.9 b 0.54
6/13/2008 28 Days Schedule 1 $25 b 0.10% 0.10% $27.2 b 1.09
6/20/2008 28 Days Schedule 2 $75 b 0.25% 0.25% $36.8 b 0.49

Source: Federal Reserve Bank of New York


Page 13

Top panel
(28)

Title: Spread Between Nominal and Inflation Protected Treasury Yields
Series: Five- and ten-year spreads between nominal and inflation protected Treasury yields
Horizon: January 1, 2007 - June 20, 2008
Description: The spreads between 5- and 10-year nominal and inflation-protected Treasury yields increased since the April FOMC meeting.

Source: Bloomberg

Middle panel
(29)

Title: Treasury Yield Curve
Series: Constant maturity Treasury yield curve as of 3/17/2008, 4/29/2008, and 6/20/2008
Horizon: March 17, 2008 - June 20, 2008
Description: The Treasury yield curve has shifted higher since the April FOMC meeting.

Source: Bloomberg

Bottom panel
(30)

Title: Implied Volatility Across Markets
Series: VIX index, MOVE index, 1-month Euro-Dollar volatility index, and 1-month Dollar-Yen volatility index
Horizon: January 1, 2007 - June 20, 2008
Description: Implied volatility in equity and Treasury markets increased since the April FOMC meeting, while implied volatility in currency markets stabilized.

Source: Bloomberg



Appendix 2: Materials used by Messrs. Sheets, Slifman, and Wascher

Material for Staff Presentation on the Economic Outlook
June 24, 2008

CLASS II FOMC - Restricted (FR)

Exhibit 1
Outlook for Foreign Growth

Top panel
Real GDP Projections*

Percent change, annual rate**
2007 2008 2009p
Q1-Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2p H2p
1. Total Foreign 4.5 3.0 2.9 2.2 2.6 3.4
2. Advanced Foreign 2.9 1.4 1.5 1.0 1.2 2.1
3. Canada 3.4 0.8 -0.3 1.0 1.2 2.2
4. Japan 0.9 2.9 4.0 0.6 1.0 1.6
5. Euro Area 2.4 1.3 3.2 0.7 1.1 2.1
6. United Kingdom 3.0 2.5 1.6 1.0 0.7 1.7
7. Emerging Markets 6.7 5.1 4.8 3.8 4.5 5.1
8. Mexico 4.2 3.3 2.1 1.2 2.7 3.6
9. China 11.6 10.6 11.7 8.7 8.8 9.6

* Aggregates weighted by U.S. merchandise export shares.  Return to text

** Year is Q4/Q4; half year is Q4/Q2; Q1-Q3 is Q3/Q4.  Return to table

Middle-left panel
Japan

A line chart shows Japanese manufacturing output and the ratio of job openings to applicants for the period of 2006-2008. Japanese manufacturing output increased eight percent between 2006 and early 2008, but in recent months it has fallen slightly. Meanwhile, the ratio of Japanese job openings to applicants fell below 1.00 in late 2007, reaching a low of around 0.93 at the time of this briefing.

Middle-right panel
Euro Area

A line chart for the Euro Area shows the 12-month percent change for retail sales and the total purchasing managers' index for the period of 2006-2008. The 12-month percent change for Euro Area retail sales has been mostly negative since the last quarter of 2007, falling to a value of -2 percent at the end of 2008:Q1. Similarly, the purchasing managers' index has also been falling, and the June 2008 flash estimate is slightly contractionary at less than 50.

Bottom panel
Real GDP Growth

A line chart shows the Q4/Q4 percent change of GDP aggregates weighted by U.S. merchandise export shares for the United States, advanced foreign economies, and emerging market economies from 1970 through 2009. It indicates U.S. recessions*, and it forecasts the period from 2008-2009. U.S. GDP growth falls to zero or negative for every recession, and these periods also see a drop in both advanced and emerging market economies' GDP growth as well. In the recession in 2001, all three fell to less than 2%, with emerging market economies experiencing a slightly negative GDP growth at that time. In the forecast period, growth for the U.S. and advanced foreign economies is expected to hover around 2%, while GDP growth for emerging market economies is forecasted to fall from 6% in 2007 to almost 4% in 2008, then recover slightly to 5% by 2009.

* Shaded bars indicate periods of business recession as defined by the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER): 1969:Q4-1970:Q4, 1973:Q4-1975:Q1, 1980:Q1-1980:Q3, 1981:Q3-1982:Q4, 1990:Q3-1991:Q1, and 2001:Q1-2001:Q4.  Return to text


Exhibit 2
Oil Market

Top-left panel
West Texas Intermediate

A line chart shows the monthly spot price and far-dated futures price of West Texas Intermediate from 2005, including the forecast of the spot price from mid-2008 through 2009. The forecast from the January chart show is included for comparison. While spot and futures prices hovered between 50-80 dollars per barrel between 2005 and 2007, in late 2007 they began to rise rapidly and the spot price of WTI closed yesterday at $136 per barrel. The far-dated futures price climbed in the same manner and is now at about the same level. Prices are forecasted to remain at this elevated level through the forecast period, which is about $50 higher than was forecasted in January.

Top-right panel
OECD Private Inventories of Oil and Products

A line chart shows the OECD Private Inventories of Oil and Products from 2005-2008, along with the five-year average level historical range of ± 1 standard deviation. This includes both crude oil and petroleum products and excludes official inventories. In the past few years, inventories have been at the upper end of their historical range, but since mid-2007 they have been falling from around 2700 million barrels to a current level of about 2550 million barrels, which is towards the center of their historical range.

Source: International Energy Agency.

Middle panel
World Oil Balance

Millions of barrels per day
2005 2006 2007 2008p % change
05-08
1. Consumption 83.8 84.9 86.0 86.8 3.6
2. Advanced Economies 45.4 45.2 44.8 44.4 -2.2
3. United States 21.2 21.0 21.2 20.6 -2.8
4. Emerging Markets 38.4 39.7 41.1 42.4 10.4
5. China 6.7 7.2 7.5 8.0 19.4
6. Middle East 6.0 6.2 6.5 6.8 13.3
7. Production 84.6 85.4 85.5 87.0 2.8
8. OPEC 34.3 34.4 33.9 35.1 2.3
9. Non-OPEC 50.3 51.0 51.6 51.9 3.2
10. Implied Stockbuild and Discrepancy 0.8 0.5 -0.5 0.2 --

Source: International Energy Agency and staff estimates. Non-OPEC production includes Angola and Ecuador.

Bottom-left panel
World Oil Production and GDP

A line chart shows oil production, indexed to 2002:Q1, and world GDP weighted by oil consumption shares. While world GDP has increased 30% since 2002, oil production has remained flat at only 10% higher than the 2002 level. Oil production is forecasted to increase slightly in 2008 to about 15% higher than the 2002 level.

Bottom-right panel
Proved Oil Reserves

A stacked bar chart shows proven oil reserves from 1995 through 2006. Reserves in this period have been steady, continuously forecasted to contain 40 remaining years of reserves*. Since 1999, the availability of Canadian oil sands** adds about 5 additional years to these figures.

* Proved reserves/current oil production.  Return to text

** Data unavailable before 1999.  Return to text

Source: BP Statistical Review of World Energy.


Exhibit 3

Non-fuel Commodities

Top-left panel
Non-fuel Commodity Prices

A line chart shows non-fuel commodity prices as an index from 2005 through the forecast period to the end of 2009. Prices rose 50% above their 2005 level by the end of 2007, and in the first half of 2008 prices have risen to 70% above their 2005 level. This is in contrast to the January forecast, which predicted prices to remain at the 2007 level.

Middle-left panel
Inventories of Selected Commodities

A line chart shows the inventories (weeks of consumption*) of wheat, corn, zinc, and copper from 2002 to 2008. All four have seen declining inventories. Wheat fell from about 14 weeks of consumption to 9 by 2007, then ticked up to 11 weeks of consumption by the middle of 2008. Corn has fallen from 10 to 7 weeks of consumption, and copper from 7 to 2 weeks of consumption. Zinc inventories fell from a level of 8 weeks of consumption in 2002 to 4 by mid-2006, and have remained at that level in the intervening period.

* Period-end stocks/annual consumption. For grains, 2008 is USDA estimate. For metals, 2008 is stock at end of March over 2007 usage.  Return to text

Bottom-left panel
Prices of Selected Commodities

A line chart shows the price of copper, wheat, corn, and zinc from 2005-2008 on a weekly basis. Wheat has risen from $3.6 per bushel in 2005 to $14 per bushel by the beginning of 2008, and has since fallen slightly and is now about $11 per bushel. Corn has risen from $2.5 per bushel to about $6.5 per bushel at the time of this briefing. Copper increased from $1.8 per pound in 2005 to $4.4 by early 2006, and has remained around that level through mid-2008. Zinc rose from $0.5 per pound in 2005 to about $2 per pound by late 2006, but has since fallen and is now at about $1 per pound.

Other Explanations for Recent Moves in Commodity Prices

Top-right panel
Role of Speculators?
Middle-right panel
Correlations: Commodity Prices and the Dollar

A line chart shows the 60-day moving correlation of WTI oil price and non-fuel commodity prices** with the broad nominal dollar index from 2004 to 2008.

The correlation of WTI oil price with the dollar began at -0.5 in early 2004. It rose to 0.1 by the middle of that year, and continued to fluctuate between about 0.1 and -0.3 through mid-2006, reaching a high of 0.2 in 2005 and a low of -0.5 in 2006. Since late 2005 the correlation has remained negative, with a value of -0.4 at the time of this briefing.

The correlation of non-fuel commodity prices with the dollar has shown a similar trend, starting at -0.2 in 2004, rising to almost 0 by the end of 2004, then falling to nearly -0.7 in early 2005. Since then, the correlation has fluctuated between -0.6 and 0.1, with a current value of about -0.3.

** Commodity Research Bureau index.  Return to text

Bottom-right panel
Correlations: Commodity Prices and Interest Rates

A line chart shows the 60-day moving correlation of WTI oil price and non-fuel commodity prices** with the three-month Treasury bill interest rate from 2004 to 2008. Both series fluctuate greatly around zero.

The oil price correlation starts at -0.1 in 2004, falls to -0.4 by the end of that year, then continues to fluctuate between -0.3 and 0.2, ending at the time of this briefing at -0.2.

The correlation of non-fuel commodity prices also starts at -0.1 in 2004, similarly rises to 0.3 by early 2005, and fluctuates in a similar manner, reaching a low of -0.4 and a high of 0.4 in the period from 2004-2008. At the time of this briefing, the correlation of non-fuel commodity prices is also about -0.2.

** Commodity Research Bureau index.  Return to text


Exhibit 4
Outlook for Foreign Inflation

Top-left panel
Outlook for Inflation

A line chart shows the inflation outlook for emerging and advanced foreign economies from 2006 through the forecast of 2009. The inflation outlook for emerging markets rose from 3% in 2006 to 7% by the second half of 2007. Although our January Greenbook forecasted inflation for EMEs falling to 3.5% by early 2008, inflation has remained around 7%. However, our current forecast anticipates inflation gradually falling to that level of 3.5 % by late-2009. AFE inflation began 2006 at about 2%, and fell to 0.5% in late 2006, but has been generally increasing to its current level of about 3%. The January Greenbook forecasted AFE inflation falling to just under 2% by 2008:Q1. Our current forecast expects it to remain around 3% until later this year, when we anticipate it falling to 2% by the end of the year.

Top-right panels
Inflation Compensation

Two line charts. The top chart shows Euro area* and far-dated euro area** compensation from 2006-2008. These have both fluctuated slightly between an initial level of 2.1% and 2.4%, and in the past quarter have risen to 2.6%. The bottom chart shows Canada*** compensation from 2006-2008. The inflation compensation for Canada hovered around 2.7% in early 2006, then slowly declined to 2% by late 2007, but has since risen sharply to 2.6% at the time of this briefing.

* Next ten years, break-even inflation.  Return to text

** Five-to-ten years ahead, derived from inflation swaps.  Return to text

*** Next 15 years, break-even inflation.  Return to text

Bottom-left panel
Policy Interest Rates

A line chart shows policy interest rates for the Bank of England, Bank of Canada, and European Central Bank from 2005 through the forecast period to the end of 2009. Bank of England's rate was 4.75% in the beginning of 2005, stepped down to 4.5% by the middle of that year through mid-2006, then stepped up to 5.75% by late 2007. Since then it has been stepping down to a current rate of 5%. Though our April forecast anticipated a slight continuation of this loosening, current forecast estimates anticipate an increase in the policy rate to 5.5% in coming months and rates remaining at this level until late 2009. The Bank of Canada maintained a rate of 2.5% through most of 2005, when it began stepping up tightening, reaching a rate of 4.25% from mid-2006 to mid-2007, then a rate of 4.5% for the second half of 2007. In the beginning of 2008 the Bank of Canada began loosening policy to a current rate of 3%. Our April forecast anticipated a continued loosening to a rate of 2.5%, but our current forecast anticipates rates remaining at 3% through the forecast period. The ECB maintained a rate of 2% through 2005, at which point it began stepping up rates to a level of 4%, which it maintained from mid-2007 to present. Our April Greenbook forecasted a loosening of the ECB rate to 3.5%, but our current forecasts anticipates a slight tightening to 4.25% in coming months.

Bottom-right panel
Consumer Prices in Selected Emerging Markets

A line chart shows the 12-month percent change of Chinese and Mexican core* and headline inflation from 2005 to 2008. Chinese headline inflation started at 2% in the beginning of 2005, briefly spiked to 4%, then fell to about 1.5% through the end of 2006. In late 2006, Chinese headline inflation began rising rapidly, reaching a peak of nearly 9% at the beginning of 2008. It has since declined slightly to about 7.5% in mid-2008. Chinese core inflation has been much steadier, remaining around 1% over the sample period. Mexican headline inflation remained roughly around 4% from 2005-2008, but in the past few month it has risen to 5%. Mexican core inflation stayed about 3% from 2005-2007, but since the beginning of this year it too has slightly trended up to 3.5%.

* Excluding food and energy prices.  Return to text


Exhibit 5
U.S. External Sector

Top-left panel
Broad Real Dollar

A line chart shows the broad real dollar from 2006 through the projection period to 2009. It is currently about 13% lower than its January 2006 level, which is slightly lower than was projected in the January 2008 Greenbook, and it is now projected to depreciate at a 3% rate throughout the forecast period.

Top-right panel
Core Import Prices

A line chart shows core import prices from 2005 through the projection period to 2009. Core import prices inflation fluctuated at a 2-3% annual rate from 2005 through the end of 2007, and the January Greenbook forecasted import price inflation to fall to about 1% in the second quarter of 2008 and remain there through the forecast period. However, in the last few months core import prices have surged at a 10½% annual rate. Our current forecast expects this to fall in the near future and return to an annual rate of 1-2% by the end of this year.

Bottom panel
U.S. Trade Outlook

2007 2008 2009p
H1 H2 Q1e Q2p H2p
Growth rates (percent, annual rate*)
1. Real exports 4.3 12.6 5.6 7.2 7.2 7.5
2. Real imports 0.5 1.4 -0.5 -6.7 1.0 2.8
Contribution to U.S. real GDP growth (percentage points, annual rate*)
3. Real net exports 0.4 1.2 0.8 2.1 0.7 0.5
Memo:
4. Current account balance (percent of GDP) -5.7 -4.9 -5.0 -5.1 -5.4 -4.6
5. Non-oil trade balance (percent of GDP) -3.1 -2.3 -1.8 -1.7 -1.3 -0.8

* Year is Q4/Q4; half years are Q2/Q4 or Q4/Q2.  Return to table


Exhibit 6
Recent Indicators

Top-left panel
Consumer Sentiment Index

Index, 1966 = 100
Period Reuters/Michigan
January 2000 112.0
February 2000 111.3
March 2000 107.1
April 2000 109.2
May 2000 110.7
June 2000 106.4
July 2000 108.3
August 2000 107.3
September 2000 106.8
October 2000 105.8
November 2000 107.6
December 2000 98.4
January 2001 94.7
February 2001 90.6
March 2001 91.5
April 2001 88.4
May 2001 92.0
June 2001 92.6
July 2001 92.4
August 2001 91.5
September 2001 81.8
October 2001 82.7
November 2001 83.9
December 2001 88.8
January 2002 93.0
February 2002 90.7
March 2002 95.7
April 2002 93.0
May 2002 96.9
June 2002 92.4
July 2002 88.1
August 2002 87.6
September 2002 86.1
October 2002 80.6
November 2002 84.2
December 2002 86.7
January 2003 82.4
February 2003 79.9
March 2003 77.6
April 2003 86.0
May 2003 92.1
June 2003 89.7
July 2003 90.9
August 2003 89.3
September 2003 87.7
October 2003 89.6
November 2003 93.7
December 2003 92.6
January 2004 103.8
February 2004 94.4
March 2004 95.8
April 2004 94.2
May 2004 90.2
June 2004 95.6
July 2004 96.7
August 2004 95.9
September 2004 94.2
October 2004 91.7
November 2004 92.8
December 2004 97.1
January 2005 95.5
February 2005 94.1
March 2005 92.6
April 2005 87.7
May 2005 86.9
June 2005 96.0
July 2005 96.5
August 2005 89.1
September 2005 76.9
October 2005 74.2
November 2005 81.6
December 2005 91.5
January 2006 91.2
February 2006 86.7
March 2006 88.9
April 2006 87.4
May 2006 79.1
June 2006 84.9
July 2006 84.7
August 2006 82.0
September 2006 85.4
October 2006 93.6
November 2006 92.1
December 2006 91.7
January 2007 96.9
February 2007 91.3
March 2007 88.4
April 2007 87.1
May 2007 88.3
June 2007 85.3
July 2007 90.4
August 2007 83.4
September 2007 83.4
October 2007 80.9
November 2007 76.1
December 2007 75.5
January 2008 78.4
February 2008 70.8
March 2008 69.5
April 2008 62.6
May 2008 59.8
June 2008 (p) 56.7

Note: Gray shading represents NBER recession dates (March 2001-November 2001).

p - Preliminary  Return to table

Top-right panel
Business Sentiment

Diffusion index
Period Empire index* Philadelphia index*
January 2002 48.97 52.41
February 2002 53.06 53.16
March 2002 48.79 53.66
April 2002 54.12 53.81
May 2002 50.28 52.76
June 2002 50.90 57.81
July 2002 44.66 50.66
August 2002 49.22 47.26
September 2002 49.47 50.06
October 2002 42.52 44.11
November 2002 48.11 51.41
December 2002 48.78 51.66
January 2003 52.12 49.46
February 2003 44.18 46.86
March 2003 45.29 45.51
April 2003 37.28 44.01
May 2003 51.89 47.41
June 2003 58.89 49.51
July 2003 55.24 51.51
August 2003 53.20 58.46
September 2003 56.14 58.31
October 2003 63.90 62.11
November 2003 62.73 61.21
December 2003 60.98 61.51
January 2004 63.94 64.41
February 2004 64.10 61.66
March 2004 58.73 62.16
April 2004 64.29 63.21
May 2004 62.82 62.21
June 2004 59.34 63.01
July 2004 63.03 64.96
August 2004 53.51 61.36
September 2004 60.09 57.66
October 2004 57.82 61.66
November 2004 53.24 57.51
December 2004 57.67 61.41
January 2005 55.28 52.51
February 2005 53.49 58.06
March 2005 55.03 54.56
April 2005 49.70 59.31
May 2005 42.46 52.26
June 2005 49.29 47.11
July 2005 57.37 51.76
August 2005 57.84 55.26
September 2005 54.66 51.46
October 2005 51.72 50.66
November 2005 54.41 53.01
December 2005 58.11 55.31
January 2006 55.83 48.51
February 2006 54.87 54.41
March 2006 60.12 54.01
April 2006 55.53 53.26
May 2006 54.54 54.41
June 2006 58.44 53.61
July 2006 53.57 49.81
August 2006 52.64 56.61
September 2006 53.74 47.96
October 2006 55.38 49.41
November 2006 56.55 50.16
December 2006 56.44 48.36
January 2007 50.64 49.46
February 2007 56.17 47.81
March 2007 48.83 47.76
April 2007 49.02 47.26
May 2007 50.57 49.71
June 2007 57.26 56.51
July 2007 58.38 51.11
August 2007 58.11 50.51
September 2007 53.46 52.26
October 2007 59.18 51.86
November 2007 57.54 51.41
December 2007 50.42 46.86
January 2008 50.03 37.21
February 2008 39.66 35.66
March 2008 34.40 38.96
April 2008 45.83 35.21
May 2008 43.90 39.86
June 2008 41.18 39.11

* Index means are normalized.  Return to table

Middle-left panel
Change in Private Payroll Employment

Period Thousands of employees April GB
January 2000 241.00 ND
February 2000 187.00 ND
March 2000 216.33 ND
April 2000 216.00 ND
May 2000 145.00 ND
June 2000 103.67 ND
July 2000 92.33 ND
August 2000 143.33 ND
September 2000 146.67 ND
October 2000 79.33 ND
November 2000 139.67 ND
December 2000 96.33 ND
January 2001 87.00 ND
February 2001 12.33 ND
March 2001 -42.00 ND
April 2001 -135.67 ND
May 2001 -159.33 ND
June 2001 -215.00 ND
July 2001 -163.33 ND
August 2001 -200.67 ND
September 2001 -211.33 ND
October 2001 -273.00 ND
November 2001 -323.00 ND
December 2001 -302.67 ND
January 2002 -234.67 ND
February 2002 -173.67 ND
March 2002 -126.33 ND
April 2002 -107.33 ND
May 2002 -80.00 ND
June 2002 -55.00 ND
July 2002 -53.33 ND
August 2002 -47.67 ND
September 2002 -55.00 ND
October 2002 13.33 ND
November 2002 29.00 ND
December 2002 -21.33 ND
January 2003 -44.00 ND
February 2003 -91.33 ND
March 2003 -103.00 ND
April 2003 -129.33 ND
May 2003 -70.00 ND
June 2003 -17.67 ND
July 2003 -7.00 ND
August 2003 -2.67 ND
September 2003 62.67 ND
October 2003 113.00 ND
November 2003 115.00 ND
December 2003 101.00 ND
January 2004 103.00 ND
February 2004 95.67 ND
March 2004 155.00 ND
April 2004 184.67 ND
May 2004 277.00 ND
June 2004 217.00 ND
July 2004 152.33 ND
August 2004 81.33 ND
September 2004 101.33 ND
October 2004 192.00 ND
November 2004 177.67 ND
December 2004 164.33 ND
January 2005 88.67 ND
February 2005 145.00 ND
March 2005 143.00 ND
April 2005 213.33 ND
May 2005 199.00 ND
June 2005 250.00 ND
July 2005 239.00 ND
August 2005 251.33 ND
September 2005 200.67 ND
October 2005 150.67 ND
November 2005 190.67 ND
December 2005 192.67 ND
January 2006 240.67 ND
February 2006 215.67 ND
March 2006 250.67 ND
April 2006 206.33 ND
May 2006 129.00 ND
June 2006 82.67 ND
July 2006 99.33 ND
August 2006 151.67 ND
September 2006 158.67 ND
October 2006 119.67 ND
November 2006 119.00 ND
December 2006 142.33 ND
January 2007 155.33 ND
February 2007 98.67 ND
March 2007 89.33 ND
April 2007 63.33 ND
May 2007 108.67 ND
June 2007 85.33 ND
July 2007 105.67 ND
August 2007 70.67 ND
September 2007 62.33 ND
October 2007 67.67 ND
November 2007 71.67 ND
December 2007 45.00 ND
January 2008 -16.33 ND
February 2008 -67.33 ND
March 2008 -97.00 ND
April 2008 -84.00 ND
May 2008 -69.67 -143.00

Note: Three-month moving average. Gray shading represents NBER recession dates (March 2001-November 2001).

ND No data  Return to table

Middle-right panel
Real Goods PCE, Excluding Motor Vehicles

Billions of chained 2000 dollars
Period Current April GB
October 2007 3242.2 ND
November 2007 3243.8 ND
December 2007 3224.7 3224.7
January 2008 3231.5 3224.8
February 2008 3228.3 3222.9
March 2008 3250.4 3225.2
April 2008 3269.2 3212.9
May 2008 3284.1 3219.9
Percent change, a.r.
Current April GB
2008:Q1 0.0 -1.5
2008:Q2 5.8 -0.6
2008:Q3 3.2 0.0

Bottom-left panel
Business Spending Indicators

(Percent change from previous month; monthly rate)
2008
Feb. March April
Shipments* -1.3 0.8 0.2
Orders* -0.9 -1.0 4.0
Nonresidential construction put in place 1.1 1.2 1.6

* Nondefense capital goods, excluding aircraft.  Return to table

Bottom-right panel
Sales of Light Vehicles

Millions of units, annual rate
Period Sales
January 2006 17.51
February 2006 16.51
March 2006 16.52
April 2006 16.63
May 2006 16.24
June 2006 16.21
July 2006 16.87
August 2006 16.10
September 2006 16.54
October 2006 16.24
November 2006 16.09
December 2006 16.91
January 2007 16.30
February 2007 16.50
March 2007 16.20
April 2007 16.21
May 2007 16.27
June 2007 15.62
July 2007 15.22
August 2007 16.22
September 2007 16.17
October 2007 16.02
November 2007 16.14
December 2007 16.17
January 2008 15.26
February 2008 15.31
March 2008 15.05
April 2008 14.40
May 2008 14.25

As shown in the figure, the range of industry forecasts for June 2008 is approximately 13.2-14.2 million units (annual rate).


Exhibit 7
Key Background Factors and Medium-Term Outlook

Top panel
Factors Affecting GDP Forecast

Middle-left panel
Oil Price

Dollars per barrel
Period Oil Price April GB Forecast
2005:Q1 49.68 ND ND
2005:Q2 53.09 ND ND
2005:Q3 63.08 ND ND
2005:Q4 60.03 ND ND
2006:Q1 63.34 ND ND
2006:Q2 70.53 ND ND
2006:Q3 70.44 ND ND
2006:Q4 60.04 ND ND
2007:Q1 58.02 ND ND
2007:Q2 64.97 ND ND
2007:Q3 75.48 ND ND
2007:Q4 90.75 ND ND
2008:Q1 97.91 97.91 ND
2008:Q2 ND 116.63 123.65
2008:Q3 ND 116.54 135.28
2008:Q4 ND 114.76 136.42
2009:Q1 ND 113.18 136.64
2009:Q2 ND 111.84 136.39
2009:Q3 ND 110.71 136.00
2009:Q4 ND 109.81 135.70

Note: West Texas intermediate spot price.

Effect of Oil Price Surprise Since
Apr. GB on Q4/Q4 GDP Growth
2008 -0.2 p.p.
2009 -0.3 p.p.

Middle-right panel
Federal Funds Rate

Percent
Period Target Federal Funds Rate April GB Forecast
14 December 2004 2.25 ND ND
2 February 2005 2.50 ND ND
22 March 2005 2.75 ND ND
3 May 2005 3.00 ND ND
30 June 2005 3.25 ND ND
9 August 2005 3.50 ND ND
20 September 2005 3.75 ND ND
1 November 2005 4.00 ND ND
13 December 2005 4.25 ND ND
31 January 2006 4.50 ND ND
28 March 2006 4.75 ND ND
10 May 2006 5.00 ND ND
29 June 2006 5.25 ND ND
8 August 2006 5.25 ND ND
20 September 2006 5.25 ND ND
25 October 2006 5.25 ND ND
12 December 2006 5.25 ND ND
31 January 2007 5.25 ND ND
21 March 2007 5.25 ND ND
9 May 2007 5.25 ND ND
28 June 2007 5.25 ND ND
7 August 2007 5.25 ND ND
18 September 2007 4.75 ND ND
31 October 2007 4.50 ND ND
11 December 2007 4.25 ND ND
22 January 2008 3.50 ND ND
30 January 2008 3.00 ND ND
18 March 2008 2.25 ND ND
30 April 2008 2.00 ND ND
2008:Q2 ND 2.00 2.00
2008:Q3 ND 1.75 2.00
2008:Q4 ND 1.75 2.00
2009:Q1 ND 1.75 2.20
2009:Q2 ND 1.75 2.50
2009:Q3 ND 1.75 2.75
2009:Q4 ND 1.75 2.75

[Note: Except 22 January 2008, the dates are those of regularly scheduled Federal Open Market Committee meetings.]

Bottom-left panel
Real GDP Forecast

(Percent change; annual rate)
Current April GB
2008:Q1 1.1 0.4
2008:Q2 1.7 -1.4
2008:H2 0.7 0.9
2009 2.4 2.8

Note: Half year figure is Q4/Q2; annual figure is Q4/Q4.

Bottom-right panel
GDP Gap

Percent
Period GDP Gap April GB Forecast
2005:Q1 -0.41 ND ND
2005:Q2 -0.29 ND ND
2005:Q3 0.23 ND ND
2005:Q4 -0.05 ND ND
2006:Q1 0.53 ND ND
2006:Q2 0.53 ND ND
2006:Q3 0.20 ND ND
2006:Q4 0.12 ND ND
2007:Q1 -0.36 ND ND
2007:Q2 -0.04 ND ND
2007:Q3 0.53 ND ND
2007:Q4 0.06 ND ND
2008:Q1 -0.28 -0.32 ND
2008:Q2 ND -1.24 -0.47
2008:Q3 ND -1.50 -0.87
2008:Q4 ND -1.89 -1.37
2009:Q1 ND -2.03 -1.65
2009:Q2 ND -1.81 -1.60
2009:Q3 ND -1.57 -1.53
2009:Q4 ND -1.33 -1.45

Note: Percent difference between actual and potential. A negative number indicates that the economy is operating below potential.


Exhibit 8
Housing

Top-left panel
Vacancy Rate: Single-family Homes*

Quarterly
Percent
Period Vacancy Rate
1980:Q1 1.2
1980:Q2 1.2
1980:Q3 1.2
1980:Q4 1.1
1981:Q1 1.1
1981:Q2 1.0
1981:Q3 1.2
1981:Q4 1.1
1982:Q1 1.1
1982:Q2 1.2
1982:Q3 1.3
1982:Q4 1.3
1983:Q1 1.1
1983:Q2 1.2
1983:Q3 1.4
1983:Q4 1.4
1984:Q1 1.3
1984:Q2 1.3
1984:Q3 1.5
1984:Q4 1.4
1985:Q1 1.4
1985:Q2 1.5
1985:Q3 1.4
1985:Q4 1.3
1986:Q1 1.3
1986:Q2 1.4
1986:Q3 1.4
1986:Q4 1.3
1987:Q1 1.4
1987:Q2 1.4
1987:Q3 1.4
1987:Q4 1.3
1988:Q1 1.3
1988:Q2 1.3
1988:Q3 1.3
1988:Q4 1.3
1989:Q1 1.4
1989:Q2 1.4
1989:Q3 1.6
1989:Q4 1.5
1990:Q1 1.4
1990:Q2 1.3
1990:Q3 1.4
1990:Q4 1.4
1991:Q1 1.3
1991:Q2 1.4
1991:Q3 1.5
1991:Q4 1.3
1992:Q1 1.3
1992:Q2 1.3
1992:Q3 1.3
1992:Q4 1.2
1993:Q1 1.2
1993:Q2 1.1
1993:Q3 1.1
1993:Q4 1.2
1994:Q1 1.2
1994:Q2 1.2
1994:Q3 1.2
1994:Q4 1.4
1995:Q1 1.3
1995:Q2 1.4
1995:Q3 1.4
1995:Q4 1.4
1996:Q1 1.4
1996:Q2 1.3
1996:Q3 1.4
1996:Q4 1.4
1997:Q1 1.5
1997:Q2 1.5
1997:Q3 1.4
1997:Q4 1.5
1998:Q1 1.6
1998:Q2 1.5
1998:Q3 1.6
1998:Q4 1.6
1999:Q1 1.6
1999:Q2 1.5
1999:Q3 1.5
1999:Q4 1.5
2000:Q1 1.5
2000:Q2 1.3
2000:Q3 1.4
2000:Q4 1.4
2001:Q1 1.4
2001:Q2 1.5
2001:Q3 1.6
2001:Q4 1.7
2002:Q1 1.5
2002:Q2 1.5
2002:Q3 1.5
2002:Q4 1.6
2003:Q1 1.6
2003:Q2 1.5
2003:Q3 1.7
2003:Q4 1.6
2004:Q1 1.5
2004:Q2 1.5
2004:Q3 1.6
2004:Q4 1.6
2005:Q1 1.6
2005:Q2 1.6
2005:Q3 1.8
2005:Q4 1.8
2006:Q1 1.8
2006:Q2 1.9
2006:Q3 2.1
2006:Q4 2.2
2007:Q1 2.5
2007:Q2 2.3
2007:Q3 2.4
2007:Q4 2.5
2008:Q1 2.6

* Vacant units for sale relative to all units (vacant plus occupied).  Return to text

Top-right panel
House Prices

Quarterly
Percent change, annual rate
Period House Prices Forecast
2000:Q1 7.23 ND
2000:Q2 6.88 ND
2000:Q3 6.50 ND
2000:Q4 6.90 ND
2001:Q1 7.54 ND
2001:Q2 6.80 ND
2001:Q3 6.43 ND
2001:Q4 6.30 ND
2002:Q1 6.75 ND
2002:Q2 7.45 ND
2002:Q3 8.11 ND
2002:Q4 8.03 ND
2003:Q1 6.92 ND
2003:Q2 6.61 ND
2003:Q3 8.33 ND
2003:Q4 8.47 ND
2004:Q1 8.82 ND
2004:Q2 8.75 ND
2004:Q3 9.90 ND
2004:Q4 9.86 ND
2005:Q1 9.06 ND
2005:Q2 9.95 ND
2005:Q3 10.03 ND
2005:Q4 8.92 ND
2006:Q1 6.90 ND
2006:Q2 3.92 ND
2006:Q3 1.82 ND
2006:Q4 3.21 ND
2007:Q1 3.76 ND
2007:Q2 2.06 ND
2007:Q3 -1.88 ND
2007:Q4 -5.47 ND
2008:Q1 -6.74 ND
2008:Q2 ND -7.21
2008:Q3 ND -7.39
2008:Q4 ND -7.46
2009:Q1 ND -7.49
2009:Q2 ND -6.21
2009:Q3 ND -4.50
2009:Q4 ND -2.70

Source: OFHEO purchase-only index.

Middle-left panel
Perception of Falling House Prices

Percent of homeowners reporting decline in their house price
Percent of respondents
Period Past 12 months Next 12 months
January 2004 6 ND
February 2004 5 ND
March 2004 2 ND
April 2004 3 ND
May 2004 3 ND
June 2004 5 ND
July 2004 6 ND
August 2004 3 ND
September 2004 7 ND
October 2004 4 ND
November 2004 4 ND
December 2004 3 ND
January 2005 4 ND
February 2005 3 ND
March 2005 5 ND
April 2005 3 ND
May 2005 4 ND
June 2005 4 ND
July 2005 4 ND
August 2005 3 ND
September 2005 5 ND
October 2005 3 ND
November 2005 4 ND
December 2005 6 ND
January 2006 3 ND
February 2006 3 ND
March 2006 5 ND
April 2006 5 ND
May 2006 6 ND
June 2006 5 ND
July 2006 7 ND
August 2006 10 ND
September 2006 12 ND
October 2006 16 ND
November 2006 17 ND
December 2006 14 ND
January 2007 13 ND
February 2007 16 ND
March 2007 18 12
April 2007 20 13
May 2007 14 13
June 2007 18 16
July 2007 17 14
August 2007 22 17
September 2007 24 20
October 2007 28 22
November 2007 27 20
December 2007 31 23
January 2008 31 21
February 2008 35 26
March 2008 36 22
April 2008 44 26
May 2008 42 27
June 2008 36 23

Middle-right panel
House Price Overvaluation and Renters' Homebuying Attitudes

House Price Overvaluation
Percent
Period Estimated overvaluation Forecast
2001:Q1 2.50 ND
2001:Q2 3.03 ND
2001:Q3 3.18 ND
2001:Q4 3.10 ND
2002:Q1 3.74 ND
2002:Q2 4.63 ND
2002:Q3 5.30 ND
2002:Q4 6.10 ND
2003:Q1 6.68 ND
2003:Q2 7.29 ND
2003:Q3 8.98 ND
2003:Q4 10.17 ND
2004:Q1 11.18 ND
2004:Q2 12.94 ND
2004:Q3 14.12 ND
2004:Q4 15.50 ND
2005:Q1 16.80 ND
2005:Q2 18.26 ND
2005:Q3 19.79 ND
2005:Q4 21.31 ND
2006:Q1 22.09 ND
2006:Q2 22.30 ND
2006:Q3 21.45 ND
2006:Q4 20.59 ND
2007:Q1 20.16 ND
2007:Q2 19.86 ND
2007:Q3 18.53 ND
2007:Q4 15.54 ND
2008:Q1 12.32 ND
2008:Q2 ND 9.74
2008:Q3 ND 7.13
2008:Q4 ND 4.23
2009:Q1 ND 1.29
2009:Q2 ND -1.27
2009:Q3 ND -3.42
2009:Q4 ND -5.06

Source: Staff estimate from model of price-rent ratio.

Renters' Homebuying Attitudes
Percent
Period Renters saying bad time to buy
2001 22.9
2002 22.1
2003 22.7
2004 29.8
2005 39.9
2006 48.8
2007 47.6
2008:H1 47.7

Source: Reuters/Michigan Survey microdata files.

Bottom-left panel
Sales of Single-family Homes

Millions
Period New Homes Existing Homes New Homes
Forecast
Existing Homes
Forecast
January 1999 0.88 4.68 ND ND
February 1999 0.85 4.56 ND ND
March 1999 0.86 4.60 ND ND
April 1999 0.92 4.56 ND ND
May 1999 0.89 4.66 ND ND
June 1999 0.92 4.87 ND ND
July 1999 0.90 4.72 ND ND
August 1999 0.89 4.72 ND ND
September 1999 0.83 4.60 ND ND
October 1999 0.87 4.58 ND ND
November 1999 0.86 4.53 ND ND
December 1999 0.87 4.55 ND ND
January 2000 0.87 4.64 ND ND
February 2000 0.86 4.57 ND ND
March 2000 0.90 4.64 ND ND
April 2000 0.84 4.63 ND ND
May 2000 0.86 4.57 ND ND
June 2000 0.79 4.57 ND ND
July 2000 0.89 4.55 ND ND
August 2000 0.85 4.60 ND ND
September 2000 0.91 4.69 ND ND
October 2000 0.93 4.65 ND ND
November 2000 0.88 4.74 ND ND
December 2000 0.98 4.52 ND ND
January 2001 0.94 4.55 ND ND
February 2001 0.96 4.66 ND ND
March 2001 0.94 4.83 ND ND
April 2001 0.91 4.73 ND ND
May 2001 0.89 4.68 ND ND
June 2001 0.88 4.82 ND ND
July 2001 0.88 4.81 ND ND
August 2001 0.87 4.85 ND ND
September 2001 0.85 4.63 ND ND
October 2001 0.87 4.65 ND ND
November 2001 0.92 4.65 ND ND
December 2001 0.98 4.86 ND ND
January 2002 0.88 5.22 ND ND
February 2002 0.95 5.20 ND ND
March 2002 0.92 4.98 ND ND
April 2002 0.94 5.00 ND ND
May 2002 0.98 4.97 ND ND
June 2002 0.96 4.86 ND ND
July 2002 0.96 4.78 ND ND
August 2002 1.01 4.73 ND ND
September 2002 1.04 4.87 ND ND
October 2002 1.01 5.02 ND ND
November 2002 1.02 5.06 ND ND
December 2002 1.05 5.28 ND ND
January 2003 1.00 5.33 ND ND
February 2003 0.94 5.29 ND ND
March 2003 1.00 5.17 ND ND
April 2003 1.01 5.15 ND ND
May 2003 1.08 5.24 ND ND
June 2003 1.19 5.24 ND ND
July 2003 1.17 5.53 ND ND
August 2003 1.21 5.76 ND ND
September 2003 1.13 5.80 ND ND
October 2003 1.14 5.63 ND ND
November 2003 1.09 5.48 ND ND
December 2003 1.13 5.70 ND ND
January 2004 1.17 5.51 ND ND
February 2004 1.16 5.63 ND ND
March 2004 1.28 5.86 ND ND
April 2004 1.19 5.92 ND ND
May 2004 1.24 6.03 ND ND
June 2004 1.18 6.09 ND ND
July 2004 1.09 6.00 ND ND
August 2004 1.18 5.87 ND ND
September 2004 1.21 5.88 ND ND
October 2004 1.31 6.02 ND ND
November 2004 1.18 6.11 ND ND
December 2004 1.24 6.05 ND ND
January 2005 1.20 6.20 ND ND
February 2005 1.32 6.02 ND ND
March 2005 1.33 6.10 ND ND
April 2005 1.26 6.23 ND ND
May 2005 1.29 6.18 ND ND
June 2005 1.27 6.25 ND ND
July 2005 1.39 6.24 ND ND
August 2005 1.26 6.31 ND ND
September 2005 1.24 6.34 ND ND
October 2005 1.34 6.21 ND ND
November 2005 1.21 6.14 ND ND
December 2005 1.24 5.95 ND ND
January 2006 1.17 5.87 ND ND
February 2006 1.06 6.02 ND ND
March 2006 1.12 6.01 ND ND
April 2006 1.12 5.87 ND ND
May 2006 1.09 5.78 ND ND
June 2006 1.07 5.68 ND ND
July 2006 0.97 5.55 ND ND
August 2006 1.04 5.55 ND ND
September 2006 1.02 5.51 ND ND
October 2006 0.94 5.56 ND ND
November 2006 1.00 5.51 ND ND
December 2006 1.00 5.53 ND ND
January 2007 0.87 5.59 ND ND
February 2007 0.82 5.80 ND ND
March 2007 0.82 5.33 ND ND
April 2007 0.91 5.17 ND ND
May 2007 0.86 5.16 ND ND
June 2007 0.79 5.01 ND ND
July 2007 0.80 5.01 ND ND
August 2007 0.70 4.81 ND ND
September 2007 0.69 4.45 ND ND
October 2007 0.72 4.43 ND ND
November 2007 0.63 4.41 ND ND
December 2007 0.60 4.32 ND ND
January 2008 0.60 4.35 ND ND
February 2008 0.57 4.47 ND ND
March 2008 0.51 4.36 ND ND
April 2008 0.53 4.34 ND ND
May 2008 ND ND 0.52 4.39
June 2008 ND ND 0.51 4.50
July 2008 ND ND ND 4.50
August 2008 ND ND ND 4.47
September 2008 ND ND ND 4.40
2008:Q3 ND ND 0.49 ND
2008:Q4 ND ND 0.48 4.40
2009:Q1 ND ND 0.49 4.40
2009:Q2 ND ND 0.52 4.43
2009:Q3 ND ND 0.55 4.51
2009:Q4 ND ND 0.58 4.64

Bottom-right panel
Single-family Housing Starts

Millions of units, annual rate
Period Starts Forecast
1999:Q1 1.34 ND
1999:Q2 1.27 ND
1999:Q3 1.29 ND
1999:Q4 1.34 ND
2000:Q1 1.28 ND
2000:Q2 1.24 ND
2000:Q3 1.19 ND
2000:Q4 1.22 ND
2001:Q1 1.26 ND
2001:Q2 1.30 ND
2001:Q3 1.28 ND
2001:Q4 1.26 ND
2002:Q1 1.36 ND
2002:Q2 1.34 ND
2002:Q3 1.34 ND
2002:Q4 1.41 ND
2003:Q1 1.41 ND
2003:Q2 1.43 ND
2003:Q3 1.53 ND
2003:Q4 1.66 ND
2004:Q1 1.56 ND
2004:Q2 1.61 ND
2004:Q3 1.64 ND
2004:Q4 1.61 ND
2005:Q1 1.71 ND
2005:Q2 1.70 ND
2005:Q3 1.75 ND
2005:Q4 1.73 ND
2006:Q1 1.74 ND
2006:Q2 1.51 ND
2006:Q3 1.39 ND
2006:Q4 1.25 ND
2007:Q1 1.16 ND
2007:Q2 1.16 ND
2007:Q3 0.99 ND
2007:Q4 0.83 ND
2008:Q1 0.73 ND
2008:Q2 ND 0.66
2008:Q3 ND 0.58
2008:Q4 ND 0.51
2009:Q1 ND 0.52
2009:Q2 ND 0.55
2009:Q3 ND 0.58
2009:Q4 ND 0.61

Exhibit 9
Consumption and Investment

Top-left panel
Factors Affecting PCE Forecast

Top-right panel
Real PCE

Percent change, Q4/Q4
Period Real PCE Forecast
2005 2.77 ND
2006 3.36 ND
2007 2.55 ND
2008 ND 0.49
2009 ND 1.52

Middle-left panel
Factors Affecting E&S Forecast

Middle-right panel
E&S Spending Excluding Transportation

Percent change, Q4/Q4
Period High-tech
(contribution*)
Other
(contribution*)
High-tech
Forecast
Other
Forecast
2005 4.47 4.08 ND ND
2006 2.67 -0.26 ND ND
2007 6.07 0.67 ND ND
2008 ND ND 1.55 -2.16
2009 ND ND 1.85 -1.04

* Contribution to E&S growth rate.  Return to table

Bottom-left panel
Factors Affecting NRS Forecast

Bottom-right panel
Nonresidential Structures

Percent change, Q4/Q4
Period Drilling and Mining
(contribution*)
Buildings
(contribution*)
Drilling and Mining
Forecast
Buildings
Forecast
2005 0.70 -0.97 ND ND
2006 4.31 8.06 ND ND
2007 4.48 10.87 ND ND
2008 ND ND 2.43 -0.45
2009 ND ND 4.68 -4.22

* Contribution to NRS growth rate.  Return to table


Exhibit 10
Aggregate Supply and the Labor Market

Top panel
Staff Assumptions

(Percent change)
2007 2008 2009
1. Potential output 2.5 2.5 2.5
2. (April GB) (2.4) (2.3) (2.2)
3. Structural productivity 2.1 2.0 2.0
4. (April GB) (2.1) (1.9) (1.8)
5. Trend hours 1.0 0.9 0.9
6. (April GB) (0.9) (0.8) (0.8)
7. Technical factors -0.5 -0.4 -0.4

Middle-left panel
Labor Productivity: Nonfarm Business Sector

Four-quarter percent change
Period Actual Simulation
2006:Q1 1.40 ND
2006:Q2 1.61 ND
2006:Q3 0.10 ND
2006:Q4 0.85 0.85
2007:Q1 0.62 0.67
2007:Q2 0.95 1.42
2007:Q3 2.85 2.93
2007:Q4 2.94 2.59
2008:Q1 3.33 2.59
2008:Q2 3.23 1.96
Kalman Filter Estimates
Apr. GB 2.1
Jun. GB 2.3

Middle-right panel
Labor Force Participation Rate

Percent
Period Actual Simulation
2006:Q1 65.98 ND
2006:Q2 66.09 66.07
2006:Q3 66.11 66.05
2006:Q4 66.22 66.02
2007:Q1 66.16 66.00
2007:Q2 65.95 65.98
2007:Q3 65.91 65.95
2007:Q4 65.91 65.91
2008:Q1 66.00 65.86
2008:Q2 66.08 65.81

Note: Adjusted for changes in population controls.

Bottom-left panel
Payroll Employment

Average monthly change
Thousands
Period Payroll Employment Trend Payroll Employment
Forecast
Trend
Forecast
2000:Q1 260.33 145.13 ND ND
2000:Q2 258.56 145.99 ND ND
2000:Q3 83.33 146.27 ND ND
2000:Q4 90.44 146.57 ND ND
2001:Q1 61.22 144.52 ND ND
2001:Q2 -117.56 144.13 ND ND
2001:Q3 -137.67 143.68 ND ND
2001:Q4 -265.00 142.82 ND ND
2002:Q1 -151.33 121.55 ND ND
2002:Q2 -46.56 121.42 ND ND
2002:Q3 -32.78 121.32 ND ND
2002:Q4 12.44 121.36 ND ND
2003:Q1 -64.78 114.06 ND ND
2003:Q2 -82.56 113.85 ND ND
2003:Q3 9.33 113.87 ND ND
2003:Q4 103.67 114.14 ND ND
2004:Q1 120.00 106.84 ND ND
2004:Q2 239.78 107.43 ND ND
2004:Q3 126.44 107.74 ND ND
2004:Q4 198.00 108.23 ND ND
2005:Q1 140.33 114.67 ND ND
2005:Q2 228.67 115.27 ND ND
2005:Q3 259.89 115.94 ND ND
2005:Q4 180.22 116.41 ND ND
2006:Q1 240.67 112.06 ND ND
2006:Q2 152.22 112.44 ND ND
2006:Q3 171.44 112.86 ND ND
2006:Q4 144.78 113.22 ND ND
2007:Q1 131.67 117.07 ND ND
2007:Q2 105.33 117.34 ND ND
2007:Q3 86.22 117.56 ND ND
2007:Q4 90.78 117.80 ND ND
2008:Q1 -37.78 112.04 ND ND
2008:Q2 ND ND -49.89 111.92
2008:Q3 ND ND -32.56 111.81
2008:Q4 ND ND -39.75 111.65
2009:Q1 ND ND 65.21 107.75
2009:Q2 ND ND 98.04 107.98
2009:Q3 ND ND 103.89 108.27
2009:Q4 ND ND 135.74 108.56

Bottom-right panel
Unemployment Rate

Percent
Period Actual Forecast
2000:Q1 4.05 ND
2000:Q2 3.95 ND
2000:Q3 4.03 ND
2000:Q4 3.92 ND
2001:Q1 4.23 ND
2001:Q2 4.41 ND
2001:Q3 4.82 ND
2001:Q4 5.54 ND
2002:Q1 5.70 ND
2002:Q2 5.84 ND
2002:Q3 5.73 ND
2002:Q4 5.85 ND
2003:Q1 5.87 ND
2003:Q2 6.15 ND
2003:Q3 6.10 ND
2003:Q4 5.82 ND
2004:Q1 5.68 ND
2004:Q2 5.59 ND
2004:Q3 5.44 ND
2004:Q4 5.39 ND
2005:Q1 5.27 ND
2005:Q2 5.11 ND
2005:Q3 4.98 ND
2005:Q4 4.94 ND
2006:Q1 4.71 ND
2006:Q2 4.67 ND
2006:Q3 4.66 ND
2006:Q4 4.44 ND
2007:Q1 4.50 ND
2007:Q2 4.51 ND
2007:Q3 4.68 ND
2007:Q4 4.80 ND
2008:Q1 4.94 ND
2008:Q2 ND 5.26
2008:Q3 ND 5.50
2008:Q4 ND 5.61
2009:Q1 ND 5.66
2009:Q2 ND 5.67
2009:Q3 ND 5.69
2009:Q4 ND 5.64
Apr. 5.0
May 5.5
Jun.p 5.3

Exhibit 11
Inflation

Top-left panel
Recent Price Data

(Percent change)
2008
Q1e Q2p Aprile Maye
1. Total PCE 3.6 4.1 0.2 0.5
2. (April GB) (3.5) (4.3) (0.3) (0.6)
3. Core PCE 2.2 2.0 0.1 0.2
4. (April GB) (2.1) (2.3) (0.2) (0.2)

Note: Quarterly figures are at annual rates.

Top-right panel
Total and Core PCE Prices

12-month percent change
Period Total PCE Core PCE Total PCE
Forecast
Core PCE
Forecast
January 2004 2.11 1.65 ND ND
February 2004 2.00 1.77 ND ND
March 2004 1.90 1.89 ND ND
April 2004 2.35 2.05 ND ND
May 2004 2.93 2.09 ND ND
June 2004 3.11 2.21 ND ND
July 2004 2.92 2.12 ND ND
August 2004 2.66 2.06 ND ND
September 2004 2.49 2.12 ND ND
October 2004 2.99 2.15 ND ND
November 2004 3.26 2.31 ND ND
December 2004 3.01 2.24 ND ND
January 2005 2.76 2.29 ND ND
February 2005 2.70 2.26 ND ND
March 2005 2.80 2.27 ND ND
April 2005 2.98 2.13 ND ND
May 2005 2.59 2.19 ND ND
June 2005 2.35 2.07 ND ND
July 2005 2.72 2.08 ND ND
August 2005 3.06 2.11 ND ND
September 2005 3.88 2.16 ND ND
October 2005 3.60 2.18 ND ND
November 2005 2.97 2.16 ND ND
December 2005 2.93 2.19 ND ND
January 2006 3.26 2.06 ND ND
February 2006 3.02 2.02 ND ND
March 2006 2.89 2.04 ND ND
April 2006 3.00 2.20 ND ND
May 2006 3.33 2.17 ND ND
June 2006 3.50 2.34 ND ND
July 2006 3.38 2.32 ND ND
August 2006 3.22 2.45 ND ND
September 2006 1.98 2.44 ND ND
October 2006 1.51 2.38 ND ND
November 2006 1.92 2.23 ND ND
December 2006 2.31 2.26 ND ND
January 2007 2.14 2.44 ND ND
February 2007 2.34 2.46 ND ND
March 2007 2.53 2.26 ND ND
April 2007 2.32 2.09 ND ND
May 2007 2.37 2.01 ND ND
June 2007 2.31 1.91 ND ND
July 2007 2.12 1.95 ND ND
August 2007 1.85 1.88 ND ND
September 2007 2.45 1.94 ND ND
October 2007 2.97 1.98 ND ND
November 2007 3.60 2.11 ND ND
December 2007 3.53 2.15 ND ND
January 2008 3.51 1.99 ND ND
February 2008 3.36 1.94 ND ND
March 2008 3.22 2.06 ND ND
April 2008 ND ND 3.16 2.09
May 2008 ND ND 3.15 2.14
June 2008 ND ND 3.62 2.19
July 2008 ND ND 4.11 2.25
August 2008 ND ND 4.48 2.29
September 2008 ND ND 4.46 2.24

Middle-left panel
Gasoline and Natural Gas Prices

Period Retail Gasoline
($/Gallon, ratio scale)
Natural Gas spot
($/Million BTUs, ratio scale)
12 January 2004 1.56 4.68
19 January 2004 1.60 4.75
26 January 2004 1.62 4.73
2 February 2004 1.62 4.65
9 February 2004 1.64 4.72
16 February 2004 1.65 4.75
23 February 2004 1.69 4.73
1 March 2004 1.72 4.91
8 March 2004 1.74 4.86
15 March 2004 1.72 4.86
22 March 2004 1.74 4.79
29 March 2004 1.76 4.69
5 April 2004 1.78 4.73
12 April 2004 1.79 4.74
19 April 2004 1.81 4.77
26 April 2004 1.81 4.81
3 May 2004 1.84 4.86
10 May 2004 1.94 4.93
17 May 2004 2.02 5.06
24 May 2004 2.06 5.10
31 May 2004 2.05 4.96
7 June 2004 2.03 4.90
14 June 2004 1.99 4.80
21 June 2004 1.94 4.80
28 June 2004 1.92 4.77
5 July 2004 1.90 4.69
12 July 2004 1.92 4.75
19 July 2004 1.93 4.83
26 July 2004 1.91 4.86
2 August 2004 1.89 4.97
9 August 2004 1.88 5.20
16 August 2004 1.88 5.18
23 August 2004 1.88 5.14
30 August 2004 1.87 5.15
6 September 2004 1.85 5.17
13 September 2004 1.85 5.22
20 September 2004 1.87 5.21
27 September 2004 1.92 5.29
4 October 2004 1.94 5.28
11 October 2004 1.99 5.24
18 October 2004 2.04 5.26
25 October 2004 2.03 5.56
1 November 2004 2.03 5.79
8 November 2004 2.00 5.69
15 November 2004 1.97 5.48
22 November 2004 1.95 5.48
29 November 2004 1.95 5.57
6 December 2004 1.91 5.32
13 December 2004 1.85 5.33
20 December 2004 1.82 5.39
27 December 2004 1.79 5.40
3 January 2005 1.78 5.26
10 January 2005 1.79 5.32
17 January 2005 1.82 5.35
24 January 2005 1.85 5.35
31 January 2005 1.91 5.41
7 February 2005 1.91 5.42
14 February 2005 1.90 5.42
21 February 2005 1.91 5.42
28 February 2005 1.93 5.60
7 March 2005 2.00 5.71
14 March 2005 2.06 5.70
21 March 2005 2.11 5.93
28 March 2005 2.15 5.95
4 April 2005 2.22 6.05
11 April 2005 2.28 6.15
18 April 2005 2.24 6.00
25 April 2005 2.24 6.19
2 May 2005 2.24 6.07
9 May 2005 2.19 6.11
16 May 2005 2.16 6.23
23 May 2005 2.13 6.33
30 May 2005 2.10 6.43
6 June 2005 2.12 6.55
13 June 2005 2.13 6.57
20 June 2005 2.16 6.70
27 June 2005 2.22 6.67
4 July 2005 2.23 6.99
11 July 2005 2.33 7.23
18 July 2005 2.32 7.06
25 July 2005 2.29 7.05
1 August 2005 2.29 7.17
8 August 2005 2.37 7.28
15 August 2005 2.55 7.39
22 August 2005 2.61 7.45
29 August 2005 2.61 7.68
5 September 2005 3.07 7.86
12 September 2005 2.96 7.83
19 September 2005 2.79 7.68
26 September 2005 2.80 7.83
3 October 2005 2.93 7.63
10 October 2005 2.85 7.47
17 October 2005 2.73 7.52
24 October 2005 2.60 7.52
31 October 2005 2.48 7.46
7 November 2005 2.38 7.45
14 November 2005 2.30 7.44
21 November 2005 2.20 7.63
28 November 2005 2.15 7.70
5 December 2005 2.15 7.32
12 December 2005 2.19 7.30
19 December 2005 2.21 7.45
26 December 2005 2.20 7.68
2 January 2006 2.24 7.83
9 January 2006 2.33 8.31
16 January 2006 2.32 8.55
23 January 2006 2.34 8.87
30 January 2006 2.36 8.70
6 February 2006 2.34 8.39
13 February 2006 2.28 8.37
20 February 2006 2.24 8.06
27 February 2006 2.25 7.88
6 March 2006 2.33 7.81
13 March 2006 2.37 8.02
20 March 2006 2.50 7.96
27 March 2006 2.50 8.02
3 April 2006 2.59 7.79
10 April 2006 2.68 7.85
17 April 2006 2.78 7.95
24 April 2006 2.91 8.01
1 May 2006 2.92 8.38
8 May 2006 2.91 8.40
15 May 2006 2.95 8.51
22 May 2006 2.89 8.44
29 May 2006 2.87 8.33
5 June 2006 2.89 8.56
12 June 2006 2.91 8.45
19 June 2006 2.87 8.44
26 June 2006 2.87 8.33
3 July 2006 2.93 8.54
10 July 2006 2.97 8.63
17 July 2006 2.99 8.87
24 July 2006 3.00 8.96
31 July 2006 3.00 8.72
7 August 2006 3.04 8.59
14 August 2006 3.00 8.48
21 August 2006 2.92 8.36
28 August 2006 2.85 8.44
4 September 2006 2.73 8.37
11 September 2006 2.62 8.36
18 September 2006 2.50 8.28
25 September 2006 2.38 8.07
2 October 2006 2.31 7.86
9 October 2006 2.26 7.76
16 October 2006 2.23 7.71
23 October 2006 2.21 7.65
30 October 2006 2.22 7.35
6 November 2006 2.20 7.34
13 November 2006 2.23 7.46
20 November 2006 2.24 7.52
27 November 2006 2.25 7.52
4 December 2006 2.30 7.23
11 December 2006 2.29 7.15
18 December 2006 2.32 7.11
25 December 2006 2.34 7.02
1 January 2007 2.33 6.99
8 January 2007 2.31 7.13
15 January 2007 2.23 7.44
22 January 2007 2.17 7.46
29 January 2007 2.17 7.41
5 February 2007 2.19 7.50
12 February 2007 2.24 7.73
19 February 2007 2.30 7.85
26 February 2007 2.38 7.79
5 March 2007 2.51 7.94
12 March 2007 2.56 7.94
19 March 2007 2.58 7.86
26 March 2007 2.61 7.94
2 April 2007 2.71 8.05
9 April 2007 2.80 8.04
16 April 2007 2.88 8.16
23 April 2007 2.87 8.17
30 April 2007 2.97 8.35
7 May 2007 3.05 8.33
14 May 2007 3.10 8.38
21 May 2007 3.22 8.33
28 May 2007 3.21 8.35
4 June 2007 3.16 8.37
11 June 2007 3.08 8.22
18 June 2007 3.01 8.33
25 June 2007 2.98 8.35
2 July 2007 2.96 8.33
9 July 2007 2.98 8.19
16 July 2007 3.05 8.02
23 July 2007 2.96 8.06
30 July 2007 2.88 8.14
6 August 2007 2.84 8.18
13 August 2007 2.77 8.20
20 August 2007 2.79 8.05
27 August 2007 2.75 7.94
3 September 2007 2.80 7.99
10 September 2007 2.82 8.08
17 September 2007 2.79 8.06
24 September 2007 2.81 8.02
1 October 2007 2.79 7.98
8 October 2007 2.77 7.94
15 October 2007 2.76 7.96
22 October 2007 2.82 8.18
29 October 2007 2.87 8.27
5 November 2007 3.01 8.33
12 November 2007 3.11 8.30
19 November 2007 3.10 8.31
26 November 2007 3.10 8.37
3 December 2007 3.06 8.36
10 December 2007 3.00 8.38
17 December 2007 3.00 8.49
24 December 2007 2.98 8.59
31 December 2007 3.05 8.72
7 January 2008 3.11 8.53
14 January 2008 3.07 8.48
21 January 2008 3.02 8.58
28 January 2008 2.98 8.35
4 February 2008 2.98 8.39
11 February 2008 2.96 8.58
18 February 2008 3.04 8.78
25 February 2008 3.13 9.15
3 March 2008 3.16 9.77
10 March 2008 3.23 10.39
17 March 2008 3.28 10.82
24 March 2008 3.26 10.85
31 March 2008 3.29 10.84
7 April 2008 3.33 10.64
14 April 2008 3.39 10.61
21 April 2008 3.51 10.36
28 April 2008 3.60 10.56
5 May 2008 3.61 10.42
12 May 2008 3.72 10.46
19 May 2008 3.79 10.59
26 May 2008 3.94 11.76
2 June 2008 3.98 11.85
9 June 2008 4.04 12.30
16 June 2008 4.08 12.86
23 June 2008 4.08 13.04

Middle-right panel
Spot and Futures Prices for Food Commodities

Index, 1987:Q4 = 100, ratio scale
Period Livestock Livestock
April GB
Livestock
Forecast
Crops Crops
April GB
Crops
Forecast
2004:Q1 117.96 ND ND 138.19 ND ND
2004:Q2 134.78 ND ND 145.83 ND ND
2004:Q3 130.28 ND ND 121.40 ND ND
2004:Q4 129.29 ND ND 104.68 ND ND
2005:Q1 131.31 ND ND 100.19 ND ND
2005:Q2 128.96 ND ND 105.38 ND ND
2005:Q3 120.68 ND ND 111.05 ND ND
2005:Q4 126.99 ND ND 105.22 ND ND
2006:Q1 124.69 ND ND 109.25 ND ND
2006:Q2 113.39 ND ND 112.01 ND ND
2006:Q3 116.53 ND ND 114.79 ND ND
2006:Q4 123.43 ND ND 142.38 ND ND
2007:Q1 128.56 ND ND 159.92 ND ND
2007:Q2 140.52 ND ND 153.56 ND ND
2007:Q3 147.11 ND ND 164.62 ND ND
2007:Q4 144.06 ND ND 192.44 ND ND
2008:Q1 138.69 138.57 ND 254.55 254.89 ND
2008:Q2 ND 140.46 143.14 ND 258.13 270.15
2008:Q3 ND 149.05 157.97 ND 261.22 304.85
2008:Q4 ND 153.62 167.07 ND 261.95 312.67
2009:Q1 ND 155.66 170.64 ND 260.34 312.97
2009:Q2 ND 155.97 173.18 ND ND 314.07
2009:Q3 ND ND 172.70 ND ND 313.23
2009:Q4 ND ND 173.92 ND ND 299.66

Bottom-left panel
PCE Energy Prices

Four-quarter percent change
Period PCE Energy Prices April GB Forecast
2004:Q1 3.53 ND ND
2004:Q2 13.08 ND ND
2004:Q3 11.02 ND ND
2004:Q4 18.27 ND ND
2005:Q1 11.48 ND ND
2005:Q2 11.51 ND ND
2005:Q3 23.83 ND ND
2005:Q4 21.12 ND ND
2006:Q1 20.29 ND ND
2006:Q2 22.09 ND ND
2006:Q3 10.23 ND ND
2006:Q4 -4.03 ND ND
2007:Q1 0.49 ND ND
2007:Q2 4.00 ND ND
2007:Q3 0.94 ND ND
2007:Q4 19.58 ND ND
2008:Q1 20.22 20.25 ND
2008:Q2 ND 17.02 15.17
2008:Q3 ND 22.99 32.15
2008:Q4 ND 16.17 28.04
2009:Q1 ND 11.11 23.77
2009:Q2 ND 2.38 16.49
2009:Q3 ND -1.31 3.18
2009:Q4 ND -1.40 0.80

Bottom-right panel
PCE Food Prices

Four-quarter percent change
Period PCE Food Prices April GB Forecast
2004:Q1 2.94 ND ND
2004:Q2 3.31 ND ND
2004:Q3 3.26 ND ND
2004:Q4 2.87 ND ND
2005:Q1 2.42 ND ND
2005:Q2 2.40 ND ND
2005:Q3 2.15 ND ND
2005:Q4 2.23 ND ND
2006:Q1 2.57 ND ND
2006:Q2 1.99 ND ND
2006:Q3 2.39 ND ND
2006:Q4 2.28 ND ND
2007:Q1 2.88 ND ND
2007:Q2 3.66 ND ND
2007:Q3 4.09 ND ND
2007:Q4 4.53 ND ND
2008:Q1 4.56 4.54 ND
2008:Q2 ND 3.98 5.03
2008:Q3 ND 3.35 4.57
2008:Q4 ND 3.05 4.29
2009:Q1 ND 2.44 3.69
2009:Q2 ND 2.37 2.64
2009:Q3 ND 2.30 2.45
2009:Q4 ND 2.16 2.34

Exhibit 12
Indicators of Input Costs

Top-left panel
Intermediate Materials Prices

Period Core PPI
(12-month percent change)
ISM prices paid*
(Diffusion index)
January 2002 -1.82 34.67
February 2002 -1.97 38.33
March 2002 -1.82 44.67
April 2002 -1.46 51.67
May 2002 -1.46 59.50
June 2002 -1.02 64.67
July 2002 -0.37 66.33
August 2002 0.22 65.67
September 2002 0.52 65.17
October 2002 0.96 62.50
November 2002 1.26 59.17
December 2002 1.49 55.83
January 2003 1.86 55.17
February 2003 2.60 59.33
March 2003 2.74 64.33
April 2003 2.22 66.33
May 2003 2.29 61.67
June 2003 1.99 57.17
July 2003 1.69 53.67
August 2003 1.62 54.17
September 2003 1.61 54.00
October 2003 1.76 55.83
November 2003 1.83 59.50
December 2003 2.12 62.83
January 2004 2.41 68.50
February 2004 2.61 74.33
March 2004 3.03 81.00
April 2004 4.48 85.17
May 2004 5.20 86.67
June 2004 5.64 85.00
July 2004 6.15 81.33
August 2004 7.15 79.83
September 2004 7.79 78.17
October 2004 7.99 78.67
November 2004 8.19 76.17
December 2004 8.32 74.83
January 2005 8.48 71.67
February 2005 8.05 68.83
March 2005 7.63 69.17
April 2005 6.43 69.83
May 2005 5.35 67.33
June 2005 4.86 59.83
July 2005 4.56 52.33
August 2005 3.37 53.83
September 2005 3.61 63.00
October 2005 4.66 74.83
November 2005 4.71 78.67
December 2005 4.77 73.67
January 2006 4.86 67.33
February 2006 4.70 63.50
March 2006 4.68 64.67
April 2006 5.26 66.83
May 2006 6.64 71.67
June 2006 7.44 75.00
July 2006 7.88 77.33
August 2006 8.41 76.00
September 2006 7.23 70.83
October 2006 5.67 60.33
November 2006 4.82 53.83
December 2006 4.49 49.33
January 2007 3.63 51.33
February 2007 3.24 53.17
March 2007 3.23 59.17
April 2007 3.52 65.83
May 2007 2.99 69.83
June 2007 2.61 70.67
July 2007 2.42 68.00
August 2007 1.56 65.33
September 2007 1.69 62.33
October 2007 2.11 61.67
November 2007 3.33 63.17
December 2007 3.33 66.17
January 2008 4.23 70.50
February 2008 4.83 73.17
March 2008 5.48 78.33
April 2008 5.84 81.17
May 2008 7.35 85.00

* Three-month moving average; manufacturing firms.  Return to table

Top-right panel
Core Nonfuel Import Prices

Four-quarter percent change
Period Core Nonfuel Import Prices April GB Forecast
2002:Q1 -2.71 ND ND
2002:Q2 -1.95 ND ND
2002:Q3 -0.67 ND ND
2002:Q4 0.11 ND ND
2003:Q1 1.19 ND ND
2003:Q2 1.22 ND ND
2003:Q3 1.16 ND ND
2003:Q4 1.61 ND ND
2004:Q1 2.36 ND ND
2004:Q2 3.16 ND ND
2004:Q3 3.40 ND ND
2004:Q4 3.58 ND ND
2005:Q1 3.49 ND ND
2005:Q2 2.87 ND ND
2005:Q3 2.24 ND ND
2005:Q4 2.22 ND ND
2006:Q1 1.29 ND ND
2006:Q2 1.69 ND ND
2006:Q3 2.75 ND ND
2006:Q4 2.40 ND ND
2007:Q1 2.77 ND ND
2007:Q2 2.85 ND ND
2007:Q3 2.65 ND ND
2007:Q4 3.30 3.30 ND
2008:Q1 4.69 4.50 ND
2008:Q2 ND 5.11 6.40
2008:Q3 ND 5.09 6.28
2008:Q4 ND 4.60 5.78
2009:Q1 ND 3.10 4.10
2009:Q2 ND 1.93 1.89
2009:Q3 ND 1.47 1.58
2009:Q4 ND 1.27 1.40

Middle-left panel
Transportation Costs

12-month percent change
Period Rail transport Trucking
January 2002 2.21 0.73
February 2002 2.41 0.65
March 2002 2.21 0.57
April 2002 2.51 0.81
May 2002 2.60 0.89
June 2002 2.50 0.97
July 2002 2.59 0.89
August 2002 2.30 1.21
September 2002 1.04 1.13
October 2002 0.95 1.53
November 2002 1.32 2.02
December 2002 1.23 2.27
January 2003 1.04 2.67
February 2003 1.13 2.83
March 2003 1.88 3.23
April 2003 2.63 2.98
May 2003 2.07 2.81
June 2003 2.44 2.57
July 2003 2.25 3.13
August 2003 2.35 2.79
September 2003 2.44 2.95
October 2003 2.43 2.54
November 2003 2.15 2.38
December 2003 2.33 2.38
January 2004 2.98 2.30
February 2004 2.98 2.69
March 2004 2.95 2.49
April 2004 2.47 2.79
May 2004 3.31 3.42
June 2004 3.11 4.13
July 2004 3.75 3.96
August 2004 4.03 4.02
September 2004 4.94 4.58
October 2004 5.67 5.16
November 2004 6.40 5.60
December 2004 7.30 5.50
January 2005 7.06 5.58
February 2005 6.96 4.95
March 2005 7.53 5.53
April 2005 8.32 5.91
May 2005 10.69 5.67
June 2005 10.83 5.53
July 2005 10.24 5.51
August 2005 11.19 5.50
September 2005 11.42 5.93
October 2005 12.98 6.76
November 2005 14.26 5.97
December 2005 13.18 5.40
January 2006 11.50 5.00
February 2006 10.81 4.81
March 2006 10.93 4.49
April 2006 10.07 4.37
May 2006 8.53 5.00
June 2006 10.02 4.69
July 2006 11.21 4.49
August 2006 10.22 4.84
September 2006 9.15 3.52
October 2006 6.74 1.52
November 2006 2.86 1.43
December 2006 1.80 2.07
January 2007 3.18 2.25
February 2007 4.27 2.07
March 2007 1.88 2.06
April 2007 2.55 2.40
May 2007 2.37 1.67
June 2007 2.69 1.49
July 2007 1.44 1.14
August 2007 2.52 0.70
September 2007 3.30 0.79
October 2007 3.80 2.02
November 2007 7.09 3.17
December 2007 9.23 3.79
January 2008 11.76 4.57
February 2008 11.33 4.67
March 2008 12.92 5.09
April 2008 12.58 6.17
May 2008 13.25 7.80

Note: Producer price indexes.

Middle-right panel
Direct Effects of Commodity and Import Prices on Core Inflation

Percentage points
Period Energy Imports and Other Commodities Energy
Forecast
Imports and Other Commodities
Forecast
2005 0.25 0.05 ND ND
2006 0.20 0.05 ND ND
2007 0.10 0.10 ND ND
2008 ND ND 0.30 0.35
2009 ND ND 0.25 0.00

Bottom-left panel
Labor Compensation

Percent change from year earlier
Period NFB Compensation Per Hour Employment Cost Index Average Hourly Earnings NFB Compensation Per Hour
Forecast
Employment Cost Index
Forecast
Average Hourly Earnings
Forecast
2002:Q1 3.50 3.80 2.97 ND ND ND
2002:Q2 4.00 4.00 2.67 ND ND ND
2002:Q3 3.90 3.50 2.90 ND ND ND
2002:Q4 3.20 3.10 3.06 ND ND ND
2003:Q1 3.00 3.60 3.22 ND ND ND
2003:Q2 3.50 3.50 2.96 ND ND ND
2003:Q3 4.40 3.90 2.60 ND ND ND
2003:Q4 5.30 4.00 1.98 ND ND ND
2004:Q1 3.80 3.80 1.79 ND ND ND
2004:Q2 3.40 3.90 2.02 ND ND ND
2004:Q3 3.40 3.80 2.18 ND ND ND
2004:Q4 3.90 3.80 2.50 ND ND ND
2005:Q1 4.80 3.50 2.57 ND ND ND
2005:Q2 3.90 3.10 2.64 ND ND ND
2005:Q3 4.00 2.90 2.71 ND ND ND
2005:Q4 3.40 2.90 3.03 ND ND ND
2006:Q1 4.20 2.60 3.45 ND ND ND
2006:Q2 3.80 2.80 3.93 ND ND ND
2006:Q3 2.70 3.00 4.06 ND ND ND
2006:Q4 5.00 3.20 4.14 ND ND ND
2007:Q1 4.90 3.20 4.16 ND ND ND
2007:Q2 5.30 3.10 4.00 ND ND ND
2007:Q3 5.80 3.10 4.06 ND ND ND
2007:Q4 4.38 3.00 3.76 ND ND ND
2008:Q1 4.01 3.20 3.69 ND ND ND
2008:Q2 ND ND ND 4.66 3.23 3.43
2008:Q3 ND ND ND 4.81 3.34 3.34
2008:Q4 ND ND ND 4.14 3.36 3.51
2009:Q1 ND ND ND 3.95 3.45 3.43
2009:Q2 ND ND ND 4.01 3.47 3.53
2009:Q3 ND ND ND 4.05 3.44 3.47
2009:Q4 ND ND ND 4.11 3.42 3.42

Bottom-right panel
Unit Labor Costs*

Percent change, Q4/Q4
Actual Trend
2006 4.2 2.9
2007 1.4 2.3
2008p 2.3 2.1
2009p 2.0 2.1

* Nonfarm business sector.  Return to text


Exhibit 13
Inflation Projection

Top-left panel
Short-Run Inflation Expectations

Reuters/Michigan Survey*
Period Percent
January 2004 2.7
February 2004 2.6
March 2004 2.9
April 2004 3.2
May 2004 3.3
June 2004 3.3
July 2004 3.0
August 2004 2.8
September 2004 2.8
October 2004 3.1
November 2004 2.8
December 2004 3.0
January 2005 2.9
February 2005 2.9
March 2005 3.2
April 2005 3.3
May 2005 3.2
June 2005 3.2
July 2005 3.0
August 2005 3.1
September 2005 4.3
October 2005 4.6
November 2005 3.3
December 2005 3.1
January 2006 3.0
February 2006 3.0
March 2006 3.0
April 2006 3.3
May 2006 4.0
June 2006 3.3
July 2006 3.2
August 2006 3.8
September 2006 3.1
October 2006 3.1
November 2006 3.0
December 2006 2.9
January 2007 3.0
February 2007 3.0
March 2007 3.0
April 2007 3.3
May 2007 3.3
June 2007 3.4
July 2007 3.4
August 2007 3.2
September 2007 3.1
October 2007 3.1
November 2007 3.4
December 2007 3.4
January 2008 3.4
February 2008 3.6
March 2008 4.3
April 2008 4.8
May 2008 5.2
June 2008 5.1

* Next 12 months.  Return to table

Survey of Professional Forecasters*
Period Percent
2004:Q1 1.63
2004:Q2 2.13
2004:Q3 2.30
2004:Q4 2.26
2005:Q1 2.25
2005:Q2 2.37
2005:Q3 2.44
2005:Q4 2.39
2006:Q1 2.43
2006:Q2 2.39
2006:Q3 2.63
2006:Q4 2.62
2007:Q1 2.46
2007:Q2 2.43
2007:Q3 2.23
2007:Q4 2.44
2008:Q1 2.38
2008:Q2 2.67

* Next 12 months.  Return to table

Top-right panel
Long-Run Inflation Expectations

Reuters/Michigan Survey*
Period Percent
January 2004 2.8
February 2004 2.9
March 2004 2.9
April 2004 2.7
May 2004 2.8
June 2004 2.9
July 2004 2.8
August 2004 2.7
September 2004 2.8
October 2004 2.8
November 2004 2.7
December 2004 2.8
January 2005 2.7
February 2005 2.8
March 2005 2.9
April 2005 3.0
May 2005 2.9
June 2005 2.8
July 2005 2.9
August 2005 2.8
September 2005 3.1
October 2005 3.2
November 2005 3.0
December 2005 3.1
January 2006 2.9
February 2006 2.9
March 2006 2.9
April 2006 3.1
May 2006 3.2
June 2006 2.9
July 2006 2.9
August 2006 3.2
September 2006 3.0
October 2006 3.1
November 2006 3.0
December 2006 3.0
January 2007 3.0
February 2007 2.9
March 2007 2.9
April 2007 3.1
May 2007 3.1
June 2007 2.9
July 2007 3.1
August 2007 2.9
September 2007 2.9
October 2007 2.8
November 2007 2.9
December 2007 3.1
January 2008 3.0
February 2008 3.0
March 2008 2.9
April 2008 3.2
May 2008 3.4
June 2008 3.4

* Five-to-ten years ahead.  Return to table

Survey of Professional Forecasters**
Period Percent
2004:Q1 2.50
2004:Q2 2.50
2004:Q3 2.50
2004:Q4 2.50
2005:Q1 2.45
2005:Q2 2.50
2005:Q3 2.50
2005:Q4 2.50
2006:Q1 2.50
2006:Q2 2.50
2006:Q3 2.50
2006:Q4 2.50
2007:Q1 2.35
2007:Q2 2.40
2007:Q3 2.40
2007:Q4 2.40
2008:Q1 2.50
2008:Q2 2.50

** Next ten years.  Return to table

TIPS inflation compensation*
Date Percent
2 January 2004 3.07
5 January 2004 3.10
6 January 2004 3.05
7 January 2004 3.03
8 January 2004 3.04
9 January 2004 2.96
12 January 2004 2.94
13 January 2004 2.94
14 January 2004 2.82
15 January 2004 2.77
16 January 2004 2.84
19 January 2004 ND
20 January 2004 2.85
21 January 2004 2.88
22 January 2004 2.85
23 January 2004 2.88
26 January 2004 2.90
27 January 2004 2.91
28 January 2004 2.90
29 January 2004 2.94
30 January 2004 2.89
2 February 2004 2.90
3 February 2004 2.90
4 February 2004 2.91
5 February 2004 2.88
6 February 2004 2.89
9 February 2004 2.90
10 February 2004 2.89
11 February 2004 2.86
12 February 2004 2.88
13 February 2004 2.83
16 February 2004 ND
17 February 2004 2.81
18 February 2004 2.83
19 February 2004 2.79
20 February 2004 2.79
23 February 2004 2.78
24 February 2004 2.79
25 February 2004 2.82
26 February 2004 2.87
27 February 2004 2.84
1 March 2004 2.91
2 March 2004 2.94
3 March 2004 2.98
4 March 2004 2.97
5 March 2004 2.89
8 March 2004 2.87
9 March 2004 2.85
10 March 2004 2.82
11 March 2004 2.80
12 March 2004 2.79
15 March 2004 2.81
16 March 2004 2.81
17 March 2004 2.83
18 March 2004 2.84
19 March 2004 2.82
22 March 2004 2.79
23 March 2004 2.79
24 March 2004 2.82
25 March 2004 2.86
26 March 2004 2.92
29 March 2004 2.98
30 March 2004 2.98
31 March 2004 2.94
1 April 2004 2.98
2 April 2004 3.05
5 April 2004 3.08
6 April 2004 3.05
7 April 2004 2.99
8 April 2004 3.01
9 April 2004 ND
12 April 2004 3.05
13 April 2004 3.09
14 April 2004 3.09
15 April 2004 3.07
16 April 2004 3.10
19 April 2004 3.10
20 April 2004 3.06
21 April 2004 3.03
22 April 2004 2.97
23 April 2004 2.95
26 April 2004 2.99
27 April 2004 3.00
28 April 2004 2.94
29 April 2004 2.91
30 April 2004 2.93
3 May 2004 2.94
4 May 2004 2.98
5 May 2004 3.00
6 May 2004 3.00
7 May 2004 3.09
10 May 2004 3.13
11 May 2004 3.15
12 May 2004 3.22
13 May 2004 3.27
14 May 2004 3.23
17 May 2004 3.24
18 May 2004 3.28
19 May 2004 3.36
20 May 2004 3.34
21 May 2004 3.31
24 May 2004 3.30
25 May 2004 3.28
26 May 2004 3.24
27 May 2004 3.22
28 May 2004 3.23
31 May 2004 ND
1 June 2004 3.32
2 June 2004 3.28
3 June 2004 3.23
4 June 2004 3.24
7 June 2004 3.24
8 June 2004 3.18
9 June 2004 3.18
10 June 2004 3.16
11 June 2004 ND
14 June 2004 3.14
15 June 2004 3.01
16 June 2004 3.04
17 June 2004 3.03
18 June 2004 3.05
21 June 2004 3.03
22 June 2004 3.04
23 June 2004 3.03
24 June 2004 3.02
25 June 2004 3.02
28 June 2004 3.03
29 June 2004 3.03
30 June 2004 3.06
1 July 2004 3.10
2 July 2004 3.09
5 July 2004 ND
6 July 2004 3.05
7 July 2004 3.03
8 July 2004 2.98
9 July 2004 2.98
12 July 2004 2.96
13 July 2004 2.96
14 July 2004 2.97
15 July 2004 2.97
16 July 2004 2.91
19 July 2004 2.90
20 July 2004 2.90
21 July 2004 2.94
22 July 2004 2.94
23 July 2004 2.92
26 July 2004 2.94
27 July 2004 2.97
28 July 2004 3.02
29 July 2004 3.03
30 July 2004 2.96
2 August 2004 2.97
3 August 2004 2.96
4 August 2004 2.92
5 August 2004 2.93
6 August 2004 2.89
9 August 2004 2.90
10 August 2004 2.89
11 August 2004 2.91
12 August 2004 2.96
13 August 2004 2.92
16 August 2004 2.93
17 August 2004 2.88
18 August 2004 2.90
19 August 2004 2.95
20 August 2004 2.94
23 August 2004 2.95
24 August 2004 2.95
25 August 2004 2.93
26 August 2004 2.91
27 August 2004 2.90
30 August 2004 2.87
31 August 2004 2.89
1 September 2004 2.87
2 September 2004 2.89
3 September 2004 2.89
6 September 2004 ND
7 September 2004 2.88
8 September 2004 2.85
9 September 2004 2.88
10 September 2004 2.86
13 September 2004 2.83
14 September 2004 2.83
15 September 2004 2.82
16 September 2004 2.78
17 September 2004 2.78
20 September 2004 2.78
21 September 2004 2.73
22 September 2004 2.72
23 September 2004 2.69
24 September 2004 2.69
27 September 2004 2.70
28 September 2004 2.74
29 September 2004 2.74
30 September 2004 2.77
1 October 2004 2.76
4 October 2004 2.72
5 October 2004 2.74
6 October 2004 2.72
7 October 2004 2.80
8 October 2004 2.79
11 October 2004 ND
12 October 2004 2.80
13 October 2004 2.79
14 October 2004 2.77
15 October 2004 2.77
18 October 2004 2.76
19 October 2004 2.75
20 October 2004 2.70
21 October 2004 2.68
22 October 2004 2.65
25 October 2004 2.64
26 October 2004 2.63
27 October 2004 2.63
28 October 2004 2.71
29 October 2004 2.70
1 November 2004 2.72
2 November 2004 2.76
3 November 2004 2.78
4 November 2004 2.73
5 November 2004 2.76
8 November 2004 2.80
9 November 2004 2.79
10 November 2004 2.82
11 November 2004 ND
12 November 2004 2.77
15 November 2004 2.81
16 November 2004 2.76
17 November 2004 2.73
18 November 2004 2.76
19 November 2004 2.79
22 November 2004 2.83
23 November 2004 2.78
24 November 2004 2.78
25 November 2004 ND
26 November 2004 2.83
29 November 2004 2.82
30 November 2004 2.84
1 December 2004 2.84
2 December 2004 2.86
3 December 2004 2.85
6 December 2004 2.82
7 December 2004 2.81
8 December 2004 2.78
9 December 2004 2.81
10 December 2004 2.77
13 December 2004 2.78
14 December 2004 2.79
15 December 2004 2.79
16 December 2004 2.84
17 December 2004 2.86
20 December 2004 2.87
21 December 2004 2.92
22 December 2004 2.91
23 December 2004 2.94
24 December 2004 ND
27 December 2004 2.98
28 December 2004 2.96
29 December 2004 2.93
30 December 2004 2.91
31 December 2004 2.87
3 January 2005 2.77
4 January 2005 2.79
5 January 2005 2.75
6 January 2005 2.77
7 January 2005 2.73
10 January 2005 2.71
11 January 2005 2.67
12 January 2005 2.68
13 January 2005 2.67
14 January 2005 2.70
17 January 2005 ND
18 January 2005 2.69
19 January 2005 2.70
20 January 2005 2.72
21 January 2005 2.70
24 January 2005 2.67
25 January 2005 2.64
26 January 2005 2.66
27 January 2005 2.68
28 January 2005 2.68
31 January 2005 2.67
1 February 2005 2.67
2 February 2005 2.59
3 February 2005 2.56
4 February 2005 2.54
7 February 2005 2.52
8 February 2005 2.53
9 February 2005 2.57
10 February 2005 2.56
11 February 2005 2.59
14 February 2005 2.58
15 February 2005 2.56
16 February 2005 2.56
17 February 2005 2.60
18 February 2005 2.66
21 February 2005 ND
22 February 2005 2.65
23 February 2005 2.66
24 February 2005 2.68
25 February 2005 2.66
28 February 2005 2.69
1 March 2005 2.73
2 March 2005 2.76
3 March 2005 2.77
4 March 2005 2.71
7 March 2005 2.72
8 March 2005 2.75
9 March 2005 2.81
10 March 2005 2.77
11 March 2005 2.80
14 March 2005 2.78
15 March 2005 2.83
16 March 2005 2.81
17 March 2005 2.83
18 March 2005 2.83
21 March 2005 2.83
22 March 2005 2.81
23 March 2005 2.78
24 March 2005 2.80
25 March 2005 ND
28 March 2005 2.78
29 March 2005 2.77
30 March 2005 2.73
31 March 2005 2.75
1 April 2005 2.76
4 April 2005 2.75
5 April 2005 2.73
6 April 2005 2.73
7 April 2005 2.72
8 April 2005 2.70
11 April 2005 2.69
12 April 2005 2.71
13 April 2005 2.76
14 April 2005 2.79
15 April 2005 2.76
18 April 2005 2.74
19 April 2005 2.70
20 April 2005 2.73
21 April 2005 2.74
22 April 2005 2.70
25 April 2005 2.64
26 April 2005 2.66
27 April 2005 2.62
28 April 2005 2.65
29 April 2005 2.64
2 May 2005 2.64
3 May 2005 2.63
4 May 2005 2.65
5 May 2005 2.65
6 May 2005 2.66
9 May 2005 2.67
10 May 2005 2.64
11 May 2005 2.63
12 May 2005 2.63
13 May 2005 2.60
16 May 2005 2.61
17 May 2005 2.60
18 May 2005 2.54
19 May 2005 2.52
20 May 2005 2.56
23 May 2005 2.54
24 May 2005 2.53
25 May 2005 2.54
26 May 2005 2.51
27 May 2005 2.53
30 May 2005 ND
31 May 2005 2.47
1 June 2005 2.47
2 June 2005 2.45
3 June 2005 2.50
6 June 2005 2.47
7 June 2005 2.44
8 June 2005 2.45
9 June 2005 2.44
10 June 2005 2.44
13 June 2005 2.45
14 June 2005 2.47
15 June 2005 2.49
16 June 2005 2.48
17 June 2005 2.46
20 June 2005 2.47
21 June 2005 2.43
22 June 2005 2.37
23 June 2005 2.37
24 June 2005 2.36
27 June 2005 2.36
28 June 2005 2.38
29 June 2005 2.40
30 June 2005 2.34
1 July 2005 2.39
4 July 2005 ND
5 July 2005 2.41
6 July 2005 2.38
7 July 2005 2.35
8 July 2005 2.35
11 July 2005 2.37
12 July 2005 2.39
13 July 2005 2.37
14 July 2005 2.35
15 July 2005 2.34
18 July 2005 2.37
19 July 2005 2.42
20 July 2005 2.41
21 July 2005 2.47
22 July 2005 2.46
25 July 2005 2.42
26 July 2005 2.43
27 July 2005 2.47
28 July 2005 2.44
29 July 2005 2.50
1 August 2005 2.47
2 August 2005 2.46
3 August 2005 2.47
4 August 2005 2.49
5 August 2005 2.48
8 August 2005 2.49
9 August 2005 2.47
10 August 2005 2.51
11 August 2005 2.48
12 August 2005 2.43
15 August 2005 2.47
16 August 2005 2.46
17 August 2005 2.52
18 August 2005 2.48
19 August 2005 2.50
22 August 2005 2.47
23 August 2005 2.49
24 August 2005 2.51
25 August 2005 2.46
26 August 2005 2.47
29 August 2005 2.48
30 August 2005 2.50
31 August 2005 2.40
1 September 2005 2.45
2 September 2005 2.49
5 September 2005 ND
6 September 2005 2.51
7 September 2005 2.54
8 September 2005 2.51
9 September 2005 2.48
12 September 2005 2.51
13 September 2005 2.50
14 September 2005 2.53
15 September 2005 2.56
16 September 2005 2.59
19 September 2005 2.61
20 September 2005 2.58
21 September 2005 2.52
22 September 2005 2.55
23 September 2005 2.57
26 September 2005 2.60
27 September 2005 2.60
28 September 2005 2.61
29 September 2005 2.62
30 September 2005 2.61
3 October 2005 2.59
4 October 2005 2.58
5 October 2005 2.58
6 October 2005 2.55
7 October 2005 2.54
10 October 2005 ND
11 October 2005 2.49
12 October 2005 2.50
13 October 2005 2.58
14 October 2005 2.56
17 October 2005 2.60
18 October 2005 2.63
19 October 2005 2.62
20 October 2005 2.61
21 October 2005 2.56
24 October 2005 2.58
25 October 2005 2.61
26 October 2005 2.66
27 October 2005 2.66
28 October 2005 2.68
31 October 2005 2.69
1 November 2005 2.73
2 November 2005 2.75
3 November 2005 2.79
4 November 2005 2.80
7 November 2005 2.76
8 November 2005 2.71
9 November 2005 2.74
10 November 2005 2.68
11 November 2005 ND
14 November 2005 2.64
15 November 2005 2.62
16 November 2005 2.61
17 November 2005 2.61
18 November 2005 2.59
21 November 2005 2.57
22 November 2005 2.57
23 November 2005 2.56
24 November 2005 ND
25 November 2005 2.51
28 November 2005 2.54
29 November 2005 2.56
30 November 2005 2.60
1 December 2005 2.57
2 December 2005 2.56
5 December 2005 2.57
6 December 2005 2.53
7 December 2005 2.54
8 December 2005 2.53
9 December 2005 2.54
12 December 2005 2.58
13 December 2005 2.59
14 December 2005 2.52
15 December 2005 2.51
16 December 2005 2.52
19 December 2005 2.53
20 December 2005 2.53
21 December 2005 2.53
22 December 2005 2.48
23 December 2005 2.48
26 December 2005 ND
27 December 2005 2.45
28 December 2005 2.45
29 December 2005 2.43
30 December 2005 2.44
2 January 2006 ND
3 January 2006 2.47
4 January 2006 2.48
5 January 2006 2.46
6 January 2006 2.44
9 January 2006 2.43
10 January 2006 2.47
11 January 2006 2.50
12 January 2006 2.52
13 January 2006 2.50
16 January 2006 ND
17 January 2006 2.51
18 January 2006 2.53
19 January 2006 2.54
20 January 2006 2.55
23 January 2006 2.51
24 January 2006 2.50
25 January 2006 2.52
26 January 2006 2.56
27 January 2006 2.58
30 January 2006 2.58
31 January 2006 2.60
1 February 2006 2.59
2 February 2006 2.58
3 February 2006 2.56
6 February 2006 2.56
7 February 2006 2.58
8 February 2006 2.56
9 February 2006 2.57
10 February 2006 2.57
13 February 2006 2.57
14 February 2006 2.57
15 February 2006 2.55
16 February 2006 2.56
17 February 2006 2.52
20 February 2006 ND
21 February 2006 2.51
22 February 2006 2.49
23 February 2006 2.50
24 February 2006 2.52
27 February 2006 2.52
28 February 2006 2.53
1 March 2006 2.54
2 March 2006 2.58
3 March 2006 2.61
6 March 2006 2.62
7 March 2006 2.61
8 March 2006 2.58
9 March 2006 2.59
10 March 2006 2.60
13 March 2006 2.59
14 March 2006 2.61
15 March 2006 2.61
16 March 2006 2.57
17 March 2006 2.59
20 March 2006 2.55
21 March 2006 2.55
22 March 2006 2.55
23 March 2006 2.57
24 March 2006 2.54
27 March 2006 2.55
28 March 2006 2.56
29 March 2006 2.56
30 March 2006 2.58
31 March 2006 2.60
3 April 2006 2.60
4 April 2006 2.59
5 April 2006 2.60
6 April 2006 2.61
7 April 2006 2.63
10 April 2006 2.64
11 April 2006 2.63
12 April 2006 2.62
13 April 2006 2.63
14 April 2006 ND
17 April 2006 2.63
18 April 2006 2.67
19 April 2006 2.72
20 April 2006 2.72
21 April 2006 2.71
24 April 2006 2.70
25 April 2006 2.73
26 April 2006 2.75
27 April 2006 2.77
28 April 2006 2.82
1 May 2006 2.83
2 May 2006 2.79
3 May 2006 2.77
4 May 2006 2.75
5 May 2006 2.75
8 May 2006 2.74
9 May 2006 2.76
10 May 2006 2.74
11 May 2006 2.80
12 May 2006 2.78
15 May 2006 2.77
16 May 2006 2.76
17 May 2006 2.79
18 May 2006 2.74
19 May 2006 2.69
22 May 2006 2.71
23 May 2006 2.70
24 May 2006 2.69
25 May 2006 2.69
26 May 2006 2.71
29 May 2006 ND
30 May 2006 2.73
31 May 2006 2.75
1 June 2006 2.74
2 June 2006 2.72
5 June 2006 2.70
6 June 2006 2.64
7 June 2006 2.61
8 June 2006 2.61
9 June 2006 2.59
12 June 2006 2.59
13 June 2006 2.60
14 June 2006 2.61
15 June 2006 2.65
16 June 2006 2.66
19 June 2006 2.64
20 June 2006 2.64
21 June 2006 2.63
22 June 2006 2.64
23 June 2006 2.65
26 June 2006 2.66
27 June 2006 2.64
28 June 2006 2.67
29 June 2006 2.68
30 June 2006 2.68
3 July 2006 2.66
4 July 2006 ND
5 July 2006 2.66
6 July 2006 2.65
7 July 2006 2.64
10 July 2006 2.64
11 July 2006 2.62
12 July 2006 2.59
13 July 2006 2.61
14 July 2006 2.63
17 July 2006 2.64
18 July 2006 2.64
19 July 2006 2.64
20 July 2006 2.65
21 July 2006 2.62
24 July 2006 2.62
25 July 2006 2.67
26 July 2006 2.68
27 July 2006 2.68
28 July 2006 2.68
31 July 2006 2.69
1 August 2006 2.68
2 August 2006 2.68
3 August 2006 2.68
4 August 2006 2.69
7 August 2006 2.68
8 August 2006 2.72
9 August 2006 2.74
10 August 2006 2.72
11 August 2006 2.71
14 August 2006 2.70
15 August 2006 2.71
16 August 2006 2.71
17 August 2006 2.71
18 August 2006 2.70
21 August 2006 2.71
22 August 2006 2.73
23 August 2006 2.73
24 August 2006 2.71
25 August 2006 2.73
28 August 2006 2.72
29 August 2006 2.68
30 August 2006 2.68
31 August 2006 2.68
1 September 2006 2.67
4 September 2006 ND
5 September 2006 2.67
6 September 2006 2.68
7 September 2006 2.66
8 September 2006 2.65
11 September 2006 2.64
12 September 2006 2.64
13 September 2006 2.65
14 September 2006 2.66
15 September 2006 2.64
18 September 2006 2.64
19 September 2006 2.61
20 September 2006 2.59
21 September 2006 2.59
22 September 2006 2.58
25 September 2006 2.57
26 September 2006 2.55
27 September 2006 2.53
28 September 2006 2.57
29 September 2006 2.57
2 October 2006 2.57
3 October 2006 2.56
4 October 2006 2.56
5 October 2006 2.57
6 October 2006 2.59
9 October 2006 ND
10 October 2006 2.57
11 October 2006 2.56
12 October 2006 2.56
13 October 2006 2.58
16 October 2006 2.59
17 October 2006 2.57
18 October 2006 2.57
19 October 2006 2.60
20 October 2006 2.61
23 October 2006 2.60
24 October 2006 2.61
25 October 2006 2.61
26 October 2006 2.64
27 October 2006 2.63
30 October 2006 2.61
31 October 2006 2.60
1 November 2006 2.59
2 November 2006 2.57
3 November 2006 2.64
6 November 2006 2.63
7 November 2006 2.65
8 November 2006 2.65
9 November 2006 2.64
10 November 2006 2.61
13 November 2006 2.63
14 November 2006 2.59
15 November 2006 2.58
16 November 2006 2.57
17 November 2006 2.57
20 November 2006 2.54
21 November 2006 2.50
22 November 2006 2.51
23 November 2006 ND
24 November 2006 2.50
27 November 2006 2.50
28 November 2006 2.50
29 November 2006 2.50
30 November 2006 2.53
1 December 2006 2.55
4 December 2006 2.54
5 December 2006 2.55
6 December 2006 2.55
7 December 2006 2.54
8 December 2006 2.57
11 December 2006 2.54
12 December 2006 2.53
13 December 2006 2.55
14 December 2006 2.54
15 December 2006 2.51
18 December 2006 2.50
19 December 2006 2.48
20 December 2006 2.48
21 December 2006 2.44
22 December 2006 2.44
25 December 2006 ND
26 December 2006 2.44
27 December 2006 2.43
28 December 2006 2.46
29 December 2006 2.47
1 January 2007 ND
2 January 2007 2.47
3 January 2007 2.47
4 January 2007 2.44
5 January 2007 2.46
8 January 2007 2.45
9 January 2007 2.42
10 January 2007 2.42
11 January 2007 2.41
12 January 2007 2.40
15 January 2007 ND
16 January 2007 2.46
17 January 2007 2.47
18 January 2007 2.48
19 January 2007 2.49
22 January 2007 2.50
23 January 2007 2.53
24 January 2007 2.55
25 January 2007 2.55
26 January 2007 2.56
29 January 2007 2.54
30 January 2007 2.55
31 January 2007 2.55
1 February 2007 2.52
2 February 2007 2.52
5 February 2007 2.51
6 February 2007 2.46
7 February 2007 2.49
8 February 2007 2.47
9 February 2007 2.49
12 February 2007 2.48
13 February 2007 2.48
14 February 2007 2.49
15 February 2007 2.48
16 February 2007 2.49
19 February 2007 ND
20 February 2007 2.49
21 February 2007 2.48
22 February 2007 2.50
23 February 2007 2.51
26 February 2007 2.49
27 February 2007 2.47
28 February 2007 2.49
1 March 2007 2.49
2 March 2007 2.48
5 March 2007 2.44
6 March 2007 2.45
7 March 2007 2.44
8 March 2007 2.44
9 March 2007 2.43
12 March 2007 2.42
13 March 2007 2.44
14 March 2007 2.46
15 March 2007 2.48
16 March 2007 2.48
19 March 2007 2.47
20 March 2007 2.46
21 March 2007 2.50
22 March 2007 2.54
23 March 2007 2.54
26 March 2007 2.55
27 March 2007 2.56
28 March 2007 2.56
29 March 2007 2.55
30 March 2007 2.55
2 April 2007 2.55
3 April 2007 2.53
4 April 2007 2.54
5 April 2007 2.57
6 April 2007 2.59
9 April 2007 2.58
10 April 2007 2.58
11 April 2007 2.56
12 April 2007 2.56
13 April 2007 2.55
16 April 2007 2.54
17 April 2007 2.53
18 April 2007 2.51
19 April 2007 2.51
20 April 2007 2.52
23 April 2007 2.51
24 April 2007 2.49
25 April 2007 2.51
26 April 2007 2.51
27 April 2007 2.53
30 April 2007 2.48
1 May 2007 2.48
2 May 2007 2.50
3 May 2007 2.49
4 May 2007 2.46
7 May 2007 2.44
8 May 2007 2.45
9 May 2007 2.45
10 May 2007 2.45
11 May 2007 2.45
14 May 2007 2.44
15 May 2007 2.42
16 May 2007 2.41
17 May 2007 2.40
18 May 2007 2.43
21 May 2007 2.44
22 May 2007 2.47
23 May 2007 2.50
24 May 2007 2.52
25 May 2007 2.52
28 May 2007 ND
29 May 2007 2.51
30 May 2007 2.53
31 May 2007 2.55
1 June 2007 2.55
4 June 2007 2.54
5 June 2007 2.55
6 June 2007 2.56
7 June 2007 2.60
8 June 2007 2.62
11 June 2007 2.63
12 June 2007 2.66
13 June 2007 2.65
14 June 2007 2.66
15 June 2007 2.64
18 June 2007 2.63
19 June 2007 2.63
20 June 2007 2.65
21 June 2007 2.68
22 June 2007 2.71
25 June 2007 2.69
26 June 2007 2.66
27 June 2007 2.65
28 June 2007 2.63
29 June 2007 2.61
2 July 2007 2.62
3 July 2007 2.62
4 July 2007 ND
5 July 2007 2.63
6 July 2007 2.64
9 July 2007 2.64
10 July 2007 2.62
11 July 2007 2.63
12 July 2007 2.62
13 July 2007 2.62
16 July 2007 2.61
17 July 2007 2.63
18 July 2007 2.63
19 July 2007 2.65
20 July 2007 2.62
23 July 2007 2.63
24 July 2007 2.67
25 July 2007 2.69
26 July 2007 2.64
27 July 2007 2.68
30 July 2007 2.69
31 July 2007 2.70
1 August 2007 2.67
2 August 2007 2.66
3 August 2007 2.62
6 August 2007 2.63
7 August 2007 2.65
8 August 2007 2.67
9 August 2007 2.67
10 August 2007 2.71
13 August 2007 2.68
14 August 2007 2.65
15 August 2007 2.67
16 August 2007 2.70
17 August 2007 2.71
20 August 2007 2.69
21 August 2007 2.70
22 August 2007 2.70
23 August 2007 2.68
24 August 2007 2.68
27 August 2007 2.69
28 August 2007 2.70
29 August 2007 2.68
30 August 2007 2.68
31 August 2007 2.66
3 September 2007 ND
4 September 2007 2.68
5 September 2007 2.69
6 September 2007 2.68
7 September 2007 2.69
10 September 2007 2.68
11 September 2007 2.70
12 September 2007 2.71
13 September 2007 2.72
14 September 2007 2.73
17 September 2007 2.75
18 September 2007 2.81
19 September 2007 2.81
20 September 2007 2.85
21 September 2007 2.81
24 September 2007 2.79
25 September 2007 2.78
26 September 2007 2.79
27 September 2007 2.81
28 September 2007 2.80
1 October 2007 2.79
2 October 2007 2.79
3 October 2007 2.78
4 October 2007 2.78
5 October 2007 2.79
8 October 2007 ND
9 October 2007 2.79
10 October 2007 2.80
11 October 2007 2.80
12 October 2007 2.79
15 October 2007 2.77
16 October 2007 2.77
17 October 2007 2.76
18 October 2007 2.74
19 October 2007 2.73
22 October 2007 2.73
23 October 2007 2.75
24 October 2007 2.74
25 October 2007 2.74
26 October 2007 2.78
29 October 2007 2.76
30 October 2007 2.77
31 October 2007 2.74
1 November 2007 2.75
2 November 2007 2.77
5 November 2007 2.79
6 November 2007 2.80
7 November 2007 2.81
8 November 2007 2.82
9 November 2007 2.80
12 November 2007 ND
13 November 2007 2.78
14 November 2007 2.75
15 November 2007 2.73
16 November 2007 2.75
19 November 2007 2.77
20 November 2007 2.77
21 November 2007 2.79
22 November 2007 ND
23 November 2007 2.77
26 November 2007 2.74
27 November 2007 2.77
28 November 2007 2.72
29 November 2007 2.75
30 November 2007 2.77
3 December 2007 2.76
4 December 2007 2.72
5 December 2007 2.67
6 December 2007 2.72
7 December 2007 2.76
10 December 2007 2.75
11 December 2007 2.71
12 December 2007 2.72
13 December 2007 2.73
14 December 2007 2.74
17 December 2007 2.74
18 December 2007 2.75
19 December 2007 2.71
20 December 2007 2.73
21 December 2007 2.77
24 December 2007 2.77
25 December 2007 ND
26 December 2007 2.78
27 December 2007 2.74
28 December 2007 2.69
31 December 2007 2.72
1 January 2008 ND
2 January 2008 2.71
3 January 2008 2.65
4 January 2008 2.67
7 January 2008 2.64
8 January 2008 2.65
9 January 2008 2.64
10 January 2008 2.70
11 January 2008 2.75
14 January 2008 2.78
15 January 2008 2.76
16 January 2008 2.75
17 January 2008 2.78
18 January 2008 2.79
21 January 2008 ND
22 January 2008 2.89
23 January 2008 2.96
24 January 2008 2.96
25 January 2008 2.93
28 January 2008 2.94
29 January 2008 3.00
30 January 2008 3.00
31 January 2008 3.00
1 February 2008 2.98
4 February 2008 2.95
5 February 2008 2.99
6 February 2008 3.01
7 February 2008 3.00
8 February 2008 3.00
11 February 2008 3.00
12 February 2008 3.00
13 February 2008 2.95
14 February 2008 2.93
15 February 2008 2.90
18 February 2008 ND
19 February 2008 2.93
20 February 2008 2.96
21 February 2008 2.90
22 February 2008 2.90
25 February 2008 2.93
26 February 2008 2.97
27 February 2008 2.95
28 February 2008 2.99
29 February 2008 2.94
3 March 2008 2.99
4 March 2008 3.10
5 March 2008 3.16
6 March 2008 3.15
7 March 2008 3.20
10 March 2008 3.19
11 March 2008 3.19
12 March 2008 3.17
13 March 2008 3.18
14 March 2008 3.15
17 March 2008 3.12
18 March 2008 3.11
19 March 2008 3.03
20 March 2008 3.01
21 March 2008 3.01
24 March 2008 3.01
25 March 2008 2.96
26 March 2008 2.97
27 March 2008 3.03
28 March 2008 3.04
31 March 2008 3.02
1 April 2008 3.07
2 April 2008 3.07
3 April 2008 3.01
4 April 2008 2.98
7 April 2008 2.97
8 April 2008 2.98
9 April 2008 2.96
10 April 2008 2.92
11 April 2008 2.95
14 April 2008 2.97
15 April 2008 2.96
16 April 2008 2.96
17 April 2008 2.91
18 April 2008 2.93
21 April 2008 2.88
22 April 2008 2.82
23 April 2008 2.83
24 April 2008 2.80
25 April 2008 2.79
28 April 2008 2.75
29 April 2008 2.77
30 April 2008 2.74
1 May 2008 2.77
2 May 2008 2.82
5 May 2008 2.82
6 May 2008 2.84
7 May 2008 2.81
8 May 2008 2.84
9 May 2008 2.84
12 May 2008 2.83
13 May 2008 2.83
14 May 2008 2.82
15 May 2008 2.81
16 May 2008 2.84
19 May 2008 2.84
20 May 2008 2.86
21 May 2008 2.86
22 May 2008 2.86
23 May 2008 2.89
26 May 2008 ND
27 May 2008 2.85
28 May 2008 2.84
29 May 2008 2.83
30 May 2008 2.89
2 June 2008 2.91
3 June 2008 2.89
4 June 2008 2.90
5 June 2008 2.92
6 June 2008 2.90
9 June 2008 2.87
10 June 2008 2.83
11 June 2008 2.81
12 June 2008 2.78
13 June 2008 2.78
16 June 2008 2.80
17 June 2008 2.82
18 June 2008 2.77
19 June 2008 2.81
20 June 2008 2.78
23 June 2008 2.72

* Five-to-ten years ahead.  Return to table

Middle-left panel
PCE Price Projections

(Percent change, annual rate)
2008 2009
H1 H2
1. Total 3.8 4.5 2.1
2. (April GB) 3.9 2.7 1.8
3. Core 2.1 2.5 2.2
4. (April GB) 2.2 2.4 2.0

Note: Annual figures are Q4/Q4 percent changes.

Middle-right panel
Alternative Simulation

Bottom-left panel
Unemployment Rate

Percent
Period Baseline Baseline Forecast Higher inflation expectations 70% confidence interval
upper bound
70% confidence interval
lower bound
2006:Q1 4.70 ND ND ND ND
2006:Q2 4.67 ND ND ND ND
2006:Q3 4.66 ND ND ND ND
2006:Q4 4.44 ND ND ND ND
2007:Q1 4.49 ND ND ND ND
2007:Q2 4.51 ND ND ND ND
2007:Q3 4.68 ND ND ND ND
2007:Q4 4.80 ND ND ND ND
2008:Q1 4.94 ND ND ND ND
2008:Q2 5.26 5.26 5.26 5.26 5.26
2008:Q3 ND 5.50 5.50 5.71 5.29
2008:Q4 ND 5.61 5.61 5.90 5.30
2009:Q1 ND 5.66 5.67 6.03 5.29
2009:Q2 ND 5.67 5.67 6.10 5.22
2009:Q3 ND 5.69 5.68 6.16 5.19
2009:Q4 ND 5.64 5.62 6.15 5.09
2010:Q1 ND 5.58 5.55 6.12 4.98
2010:Q2 ND 5.52 5.49 6.08 4.89
2010:Q3 ND 5.45 5.43 6.03 4.79
2010:Q4 ND 5.39 5.38 5.98 4.70
2011:Q1 ND 5.32 5.33 5.95 4.60
2011:Q2 ND 5.26 5.29 5.91 4.51
2011:Q3 ND 5.20 5.24 5.86 4.41
2011:Q4 ND 5.13 5.20 5.83 4.34
2012:Q1 ND 5.07 5.15 5.79 4.25
2012:Q2 ND 5.00 5.10 5.73 4.17
2012:Q3 ND 4.94 5.05 5.69 4.09
2012:Q4 ND 4.88 5.01 5.65 4.01

Bottom-center panel
Core PCE Prices

Four-quarter percent change
Period Baseline Baseline Forecast Higher inflation expectations 70% confidence interval
upper bound
70% confidence interval
lower bound
2006:Q1 2.04 ND ND ND ND
2006:Q2 2.24 ND ND ND ND
2006:Q3 2.40 ND ND ND ND
2006:Q4 2.29 ND ND ND ND
2007:Q1 2.39 ND ND ND ND
2007:Q2 2.01 ND ND ND ND
2007:Q3 1.92 ND ND ND ND
2007:Q4 2.08 ND ND ND ND
2008:Q1 2.03 ND ND ND ND
2008:Q2 2.17 2.17 2.17 2.17 2.17
2008:Q3 ND 2.29 2.27 2.48 2.11
2008:Q4 ND 2.30 2.33 2.58 2.03
2009:Q1 ND 2.34 2.48 2.72 1.98
2009:Q2 ND 2.42 2.65 2.89 1.97
2009:Q3 ND 2.33 2.68 2.88 1.81
2009:Q4 ND 2.21 2.61 2.81 1.65
2010:Q1 ND 2.12 2.53 2.76 1.53
2010:Q2 ND 2.05 2.47 2.72 1.45
2010:Q3 ND 2.00 2.44 2.71 1.38
2010:Q4 ND 1.96 2.40 2.69 1.30
2011:Q1 ND 1.92 2.35 2.69 1.22
2011:Q2 ND 1.88 2.32 2.68 1.18
2011:Q3 ND 1.85 2.28 2.66 1.14
2011:Q4 ND 1.82 2.25 2.64 1.11
2012:Q1 ND 1.79 2.23 2.63 1.07
2012:Q2 ND 1.77 2.20 2.63 1.07
2012:Q3 ND 1.76 2.18 2.62 1.05
2012:Q4 ND 1.74 2.17 2.62 1.04

Bottom-right panel
Federal Funds Rate

Percent
Period Baseline Baseline Forecast Higher inflation expectations 70% confidence interval
upper bound
70% confidence interval
lower bound
2006:Q1 4.46 ND ND ND ND
2006:Q2 4.91 ND ND ND ND
2006:Q3 5.25 ND ND ND ND
2006:Q4 5.25 ND ND ND ND
2007:Q1 5.26 ND ND ND ND
2007:Q2 5.25 ND ND ND ND
2007:Q3 5.07 ND ND ND ND
2007:Q4 4.50 ND ND ND ND
2008:Q1 3.18 ND ND ND ND
2008:Q2 2.10 2.10 2.10 2.10 2.10
2008:Q3 ND 2.00 2.00 2.41 1.62
2008:Q4 ND 2.00 1.98 2.67 1.35
2009:Q1 ND 2.20 2.21 3.15 1.29
2009:Q2 ND 2.50 2.63 3.64 1.39
2009:Q3 ND 2.75 3.04 4.10 1.52
2009:Q4 ND 2.75 3.20 4.23 1.43
2010:Q1 ND 2.75 3.32 4.29 1.39
2010:Q2 ND 3.00 3.64 4.60 1.62
2010:Q3 ND 3.00 3.67 4.68 1.64
2010:Q4 ND 3.25 3.92 4.97 1.88
2011:Q1 ND 3.25 3.90 4.98 1.85
2011:Q2 ND 3.25 3.87 5.00 1.89
2011:Q3 ND 3.25 3.83 5.05 1.85
2011:Q4 ND 3.50 4.04 5.40 2.06
2012:Q1 ND 3.71 4.22 5.58 2.26
2012:Q2 ND 3.90 4.37 5.77 2.40
2012:Q3 ND 4.06 4.50 5.96 2.55
2012:Q4 ND 4.19 4.60 6.07 2.67


Appendix 3: Materials used by Mr. Madigan

Material for Briefing on FOMC Participants' Economic Projections
Brian Madigan
June 24, 2008

Class I FOMC - Restricted Controlled (FR)

Table 1:
Economic Projections of Federal Reserve Governors and Reserve Bank Presidents

2008:H1 2008:H2
Central Tendencies
(percent, annual rate)
Real GDP Growth 1.2 to 1.4 0.6 to 2.1
April projections -0.4 to 0.5 1.0 to 1.9
PCE Inflation 3.7 to 4.0 3.6 to 4.6
April projections 3.5 to 4.0 2.5 to 3.1
Core PCE Inflation 2.1 to 2.2 2.3 to 2.5
April projections 2.2 to 2.4 2.2 to 2.4
Ranges
(percent, annual rate)
Real GDP Growth 1.0 to 1.5 0.4 to 2.2
April projections -0.5 to 0.6 0.4 to 2.9
PCE Inflation 3.6 to 4.6 3.2 to 4.8
April projections 3.0 to 4.4 2.3 to 3.6
Core PCE Inflation 2.0 to 2.4 2.0 to 2.6
April projections 2.0 to 2.5 1.7 to 2.7
Memo: Greenbook
(percent, annual rate)
Real GDP Growth 1.4 0.7
April Greenbook -0.5 0.9
PCE Inflation 3.8 4.5
April Greenbook 3.9 2.7
Core PCE Inflation 2.1 2.5
April Greenbook 2.2 2.4

Table 2:
Economic Projections of Federal Reserve Governors and Reserve Bank Presidents

2008 2009 2010
Central Tendencies
(percent)
Real GDP Growth 1.0 to 1.6 2.0 to 2.8 2.5 to 3.0
April projections 0.3 to 1.2 2.0 to 2.8 2.6 to 3.1
Unemployment Rate 5.5 to 5.7 5.3 to 5.8 5.0 to 5.6
April projections 5.5 to 5.7 5.2 to 5.7 4.9 to 5.5
PCE Inflation 3.8 to 4.2 2.0 to 2.3 1.8 to 2.0
April projections 3.1 to 3.4 1.9 to 2.3 1.8 to 2.0
Core PCE Inflation 2.2 to 2.4 2.0 to 2.2 1.8 to 2.0
April projections 2.2 to 2.4 1.9 to 2.1 1.7 to 1.9
Ranges
(percent)
Real GDP Growth 0.9 to 1.8 1.9 to 3.0 2.0 to 3.5
April projections 0.0 to 1.5 1.8 to 3.0 2.0 to 3.4
Unemployment Rate 5.5 to 5.8 5.2 to 6.1 5.0 to 5.8
April projections 5.3 to 6.0 5.2 to 6.3 4.8 to 5.9
PCE Inflation 3.4 to 4.6 1.7 to 3.0 1.6 to 2.1
April projections 2.8 to 3.8 1.7 to 3.0 1.5 to 2.0
Core PCE Inflation 2.0 to 2.5 1.8 to 2.3 1.5 to 2.0
April projections 1.9 to 2.5 1.7 to 2.2 1.3 to 2.0
Memo: Greenbook
(percent)
Real GDP Growth 1.0 2.4 3.1
April Greenbook 0.2 2.8 3.1
Unemployment Rate 5.6 5.6 5.4
April Greenbook 5.7 5.5 5.2
PCE Inflation 4.2 2.1 1.9
April Greenbook 3.3 1.8 1.8
Core PCE Inflation 2.3 2.2 2.0
April Greenbook 2.3 2.0 1.8

Exhibit 3
Risks and Uncertainty in Economic Projections

Top-left panel
Risk Weighting around Outlook for Real GDP Growth

Number of participants
Weighted to Downside Broadly Balanced Weighted to Upside
January 13 3 1
April 13 4 0
June 14 3 0

Top-right panel
Degree of Uncertainty about Outlook for Real GDP Growth

Number of participants
Lower Historically Normal Higher
January 0 2 15
April 0 3 14
June 0 4 13

Bottom-left panel
Risk Weighting around Outlook for Total PCE Inflation

Number of participants
Weighted to Downside Broadly Balanced Weighted to Upside
January 0 11 6
April 0 9 8
June 0 4 13

Bottom-right panel
Degree of Uncertainty about Outlook for Total PCE Inflation

Number of participants
Lower Historically Normal Higher
January 0 12 5
April 1 5 11
June 0 4 13

Exhibit 4
Consideration of Long-Term Projections

Top panel
Issue

Bottom panel
Alternative approaches

  1. Extend entire set of projections for four variables and forecast narratives out to five years.
    • a. Advantage: full, coherent presentation
    • b. Disadvantage: burden on participants
  2. Maintain three-year projection horizon for four variables but add fifth-year projections for output growth, unemployment, and total inflation
    • a. Advantage: less burden on participants
    • b. Disadvantage: less complete explanation of transition to steady state
  3. Maintain three-year projection horizon for four variables but add estimates of long-run averages of output growth, unemployment, and total inflation five to ten years ahead
    • a. Advantage: no need for participants to project fourth and fifth years for four variables
    • b. Disadvantages:
      • i. Less complete explanation of transition to steady state
      • ii. Need to forecast long-run demographic and productivity trends

Appendix 4: Materials used by Mr. Madigan

Material for FOMC Briefing on Monetary Policy Alternatives
Brian Madigan
June 24-25, 2008

Class I FOMC - Restricted Controlled (FR)

Exhibit 1

Table 1: Alternative Language for the June 2008 FOMC Announcement
Bluebook version, slightly revised
[Note: In Appendix 4, Table 1, strong emphasis (bold) has been added to indicate underlined red text in the original document. Emphasis (strike-through) indicates strike-through underlined blue text in the original document.]
April FOMC Alternative A Alternative B Alternative C
Policy Decision 1. The Federal Open Market Committee decided today to lower its target for the federal funds rate 25 basis points to 2 percent. The Federal Open Market Committee decided today to lower its target for the federal funds rate 25 basis points to 1-¾ percent. The Federal Open Market Committee decided today to keep its target for the federal funds rate at 2 percent. The Federal Open Market Committee decided today to raise its target for the federal funds rate 25 basis points to 2-¼ percent.
Rationale 2. Recent information indicates that economic activity remains weak. Household and business spending has been subdued and labor markets have softened further. Financial markets remain under considerable stress, and tight credit conditions and the deepening housing contraction are likely to weigh on economic growth over the next few quarters. Recent information indicates that economic activity has remained weak in recent months. Although consumer spending appears to have firmed somewhat, residential investment has continued to contract sharply and labor markets have softened further. Financial markets remain under considerable stress, and tight credit conditions and the deepening housing contraction are likely to weigh on economic growth over the next few quarters. Recent information indicates that overall economic activity continues to expand, partly reflecting some firming in household spending. However, labor markets have softened further and financial markets remain under considerable stress. Tight credit conditions, the ongoing housing contraction, and the rise in energy prices are likely to weigh on economic growth over the next few quarters. Recent information indicates that overall economic activity continues to expand, partly reflecting some firming in household spending. However, labor markets have softened further and financial markets remain under considerable stress. Tight credit conditions, the ongoing housing contraction, and the rise in energy prices are likely to weigh on economic growth over the next few quarters.
3. Although readings on core inflation have improved somewhat, energy and other commodity prices have increased, and some indicators of inflation expectations have risen in recent months. The Committee expects inflation to moderate in coming quarters, reflecting a projected leveling-out of energy and other commodity prices and an easing of pressures on resource utilization. Still, uncertainty about the inflation outlook remains high. It will be necessary to continue to monitor inflation developments carefully. Although energy prices have increased further and some indicators of inflation expectations have risen in recent months, core inflation has been stable of late. The Committee expects inflation to moderate later this year and next year, reflecting a projected leveling-out of energy prices and an easing of pressures on resource utilization. Still, uncertainty about the inflation outlook remains high. It will be necessary to continue to monitor inflation developments carefully. The Committee expects inflation to moderate later this year and next year. However, in light of the continued increases in the prices of energy and some other commodities and the elevated state of some indicators of inflation expectations, uncertainty about the inflation outlook remains high. Overall inflation has been elevated, energy prices have continued to increase, and some indicators of inflation expectations have risen further. The Committee expects inflation to moderate later this year and next year, partly reflecting today's policy action. Still, uncertainty about the inflation outlook remains high. It will be necessary to continue to monitor inflation developments carefully.
Assessment of Risk 4. The substantial easing of monetary policy to date, combined with ongoing measures to foster market liquidity, should help to promote moderate growth over time and to mitigate risks to economic activity. The Committee will continue to monitor economic and financial developments and will act as needed to promote sustainable economic growth and price stability. The substantial easing of monetary policy to date, combined with ongoing measures to foster market liquidity, should help to promote moderate growth over time and to mitigate risks to economic activity. The Committee will continue to monitor economic and financial developments and will act as needed to promote sustainable economic growth and price stability. The substantial easing of monetary policy to date, combined with ongoing measures to foster market liquidity, should help to promote moderate growth over time. Although downside risks to growth remain, they appear to have diminished somewhat, and the upside risks to near-term inflation and inflation expectations have increased. The Committee will continue to monitor economic and financial developments and will act as needed to promote sustainable economic growth and price stability. Future policy adjustments will depend on the evolution of the outlook for both inflation and economic growth, as implied by incoming information on the economy and financial conditions.

Exhibit 2
Optimal Policy Under Alternative Inflation Goals

1½ Percent Inflation Goal

Top-left panel
Federal funds rate
Percent
Period Current Bluebook April Bluebook
2008:Q2 2.10 2.99
2008:Q3 2.34 2.81
2008:Q4 2.51 2.62
2009:Q1 2.62 2.44
2009:Q2 2.69 2.28
2009:Q3 2.74 2.17
2009:Q4 2.79 2.10
2010:Q1 2.83 2.09
2010:Q2 2.88 2.12
2010:Q3 2.93 2.19
2010:Q4 3.01 2.31
2011:Q1 3.10 2.46
2011:Q2 3.20 2.64
2011:Q3 3.32 2.83
2011:Q4 3.45 3.04
2012:Q1 3.58 3.26
2012:Q2 3.71 3.46
2012:Q3 3.84 3.66
2012:Q4 3.96 3.83
Middle-left panel
Civilian unemployment rate
Percent
Period Current Bluebook April Bluebook
2008:Q2 5.26 5.20
2008:Q3 5.50 5.48
2008:Q4 5.61 5.73
2009:Q1 5.68 5.78
2009:Q2 5.69 5.74
2009:Q3 5.72 5.71
2009:Q4 5.68 5.60
2010:Q1 5.62 5.49
2010:Q2 5.56 5.39
2010:Q3 5.50 5.29
2010:Q4 5.43 5.20
2011:Q1 5.37 5.11
2011:Q2 5.31 5.03
2011:Q3 5.25 4.96
2011:Q4 5.18 4.88
2012:Q1 5.12 4.81
2012:Q2 5.06 4.76
2012:Q3 5.00 4.71
2012:Q4 4.94 4.67
Bottom-left panel
Core PCE inflation
Four-quarter average
Percent
Period Current Bluebook April Bluebook
2008:Q2 2.17 2.16
2008:Q3 2.28 2.24
2008:Q4 2.28 2.20
2009:Q1 2.32 2.21
2009:Q2 2.39 2.17
2009:Q3 2.30 2.04
2009:Q4 2.18 1.90
2010:Q1 2.09 1.80
2010:Q2 2.02 1.74
2010:Q3 1.97 1.70
2010:Q4 1.92 1.66
2011:Q1 1.88 1.63
2011:Q2 1.84 1.60
2011:Q3 1.81 1.59
2011:Q4 1.78 1.59
2012:Q1 1.75 1.59
2012:Q2 1.73 1.59
2012:Q3 1.71 1.58
2012:Q4 1.70 1.58

2 Percent Inflation Goal

Top-right panel
Federal funds rate
Percent
Period Current Bluebook April Bluebook
2008:Q2 2.10 2.64
2008:Q3 1.99 2.20
2008:Q4 1.90 1.82
2009:Q1 1.82 1.52
2009:Q2 1.77 1.31
2009:Q3 1.77 1.19
2009:Q4 1.80 1.17
2010:Q1 1.89 1.23
2010:Q2 2.02 1.36
2010:Q3 2.18 1.56
2010:Q4 2.38 1.81
2011:Q1 2.61 2.10
2011:Q2 2.85 2.42
2011:Q3 3.11 2.76
2011:Q4 3.38 3.10
2012:Q1 3.64 3.43
2012:Q2 3.88 3.75
2012:Q3 4.12 4.04
2012:Q4 4.33 4.29
Middle-right panel
Civilian unemployment rate
Percent
Period Current Bluebook April Bluebook
2008:Q2 5.26 5.20
2008:Q3 5.50 5.46
2008:Q4 5.59 5.67
2009:Q1 5.61 5.67
2009:Q2 5.58 5.58
2009:Q3 5.56 5.50
2009:Q4 5.47 5.35
2010:Q1 5.37 5.21
2010:Q2 5.27 5.07
2010:Q3 5.18 4.95
2010:Q4 5.09 4.85
2011:Q1 5.01 4.75
2011:Q2 4.94 4.67
2011:Q3 4.88 4.59
2011:Q4 4.82 4.53
2012:Q1 4.77 4.48
2012:Q2 4.73 4.44
2012:Q3 4.69 4.42
2012:Q4 4.65 4.41
Bottom-right panel
Core PCE inflation
Four-quarter average
Percent
Period Current Bluebook April Bluebook
2008:Q2 2.17 2.20
2008:Q3 2.33 2.30
2008:Q4 2.35 2.29
2009:Q1 2.41 2.32
2009:Q2 2.50 2.28
2009:Q3 2.41 2.16
2009:Q4 2.30 2.04
2010:Q1 2.22 1.96
2010:Q2 2.18 1.92
2010:Q3 2.15 1.90
2010:Q4 2.13 1.88
2011:Q1 2.11 1.87
2011:Q2 2.09 1.86
2011:Q3 2.08 1.87
2011:Q4 2.07 1.88
2012:Q1 2.06 1.89
2012:Q2 2.05 1.90
2012:Q3 2.04 1.91
2012:Q4 2.04 1.92

Exhibit 3
Equilibrium Real Federal Funds Rate

Top panel
Short-Run Estimates with Confidence Intervals

Percent
Period Lower bound of 90% confidence interval Lower bound of 70% confidence interval Lower bound of range of model based estimates The actual real funds rate based on lagged core inflation Greenbook-consistent measure Upper bound of range of model based estimates Upper bound of 70% confidence interval Upper bound of 90% confidence interval
1990:Q1 0.17 1.13 2.23 4.51 ND 3.93 4.51 5.47
1990:Q2 0.12 1.09 2.00 4.03 ND 3.61 4.31 5.23
1990:Q3 -0.61 0.32 1.21 3.73 ND 3.06 3.70 4.65
1990:Q4 -0.97 -0.03 1.09 3.45 ND 2.74 3.32 4.28
1991:Q1 -1.11 -0.17 0.81 2.18 ND 2.38 3.07 4.00
1991:Q2 -0.86 0.08 1.18 2.16 ND 2.76 3.39 4.33
1991:Q3 -0.83 0.17 1.12 1.99 ND 2.94 3.53 4.44
1991:Q4 -0.77 0.23 1.10 1.07 ND 2.87 3.51 4.44
1992:Q1 -0.46 0.52 1.42 0.44 ND 3.20 3.81 4.74
1992:Q2 -0.38 0.65 1.54 0.25 ND 3.32 3.96 4.87
1992:Q3 -0.44 0.50 1.61 -0.02 ND 3.20 3.80 4.76
1992:Q4 -0.28 0.67 1.79 0.00 ND 2.99 3.77 4.64
1993:Q1 -0.48 0.50 1.38 0.38 ND 2.92 3.69 4.59
1993:Q2 -0.65 0.33 1.30 0.29 ND 2.70 3.45 4.35
1993:Q3 -0.67 0.24 1.35 0.59 ND 2.19 3.25 4.08
1993:Q4 -0.39 0.51 1.71 0.72 ND 2.35 3.48 4.33
1994:Q1 -0.24 0.69 1.86 1.03 ND 2.87 3.75 4.61
1994:Q2 -0.10 0.80 2.00 1.84 ND 2.49 3.71 4.55
1994:Q3 -0.33 0.56 1.80 2.06 ND 2.39 3.50 4.37
1994:Q4 -0.36 0.53 1.54 2.74 ND 2.64 3.59 4.47
1995:Q1 -0.18 0.77 1.75 3.37 ND 2.86 3.82 4.66
1995:Q2 -0.45 0.50 1.50 3.69 ND 2.53 3.52 4.35
1995:Q3 -0.18 0.81 1.69 3.76 ND 2.81 3.85 4.69
1995:Q4 -0.14 0.83 1.79 3.68 ND 2.77 3.84 4.69
1996:Q1 -0.17 0.75 1.79 3.38 ND 2.82 3.75 4.59
1996:Q2 0.34 1.24 2.28 3.39 ND 3.16 4.23 5.10
1996:Q3 0.35 1.34 2.20 3.53 ND 3.73 4.49 5.36
1996:Q4 0.42 1.37 2.30 3.46 ND 3.60 4.47 5.32
1997:Q1 0.36 1.33 2.25 3.54 ND 3.78 4.52 5.43
1997:Q2 0.71 1.62 2.57 3.76 ND 3.44 4.62 5.47
1997:Q3 0.96 1.93 2.72 3.97 4.11 4.25 5.07 5.95
1997:Q4 0.80 1.81 2.56 4.16 4.30 4.94 5.43 6.42
1998:Q1 0.80 1.80 2.65 4.20 4.33 3.97 4.90 5.76
1998:Q2 0.75 1.73 2.53 4.34 4.16 4.01 4.91 5.78
1998:Q3 0.65 1.59 2.67 4.23 4.30 4.36 4.94 5.90
1998:Q4 0.79 1.71 2.65 3.44 3.47 4.12 4.86 5.78
1999:Q1 0.93 1.90 2.97 3.36 3.90 4.81 5.32 6.34
1999:Q2 1.01 2.04 2.79 3.23 4.08 4.92 5.48 6.48
1999:Q3 1.13 2.15 2.93 3.59 4.29 5.09 5.61 6.58
1999:Q4 1.52 2.53 3.30 3.77 4.37 4.60 5.68 6.52
2000:Q1 1.16 2.28 2.87 3.84 5.26 4.60 5.59 6.47
2000:Q2 1.33 2.23 3.17 4.54 5.63 4.04 5.23 6.08
2000:Q3 0.92 1.99 2.61 4.92 5.24 4.80 5.42 6.34
2000:Q4 0.66 1.62 2.48 4.96 4.55 3.95 4.78 5.65
2001:Q1 0.09 1.07 2.19 3.99 3.10 3.88 4.45 5.40
2001:Q2 0.11 0.98 2.22 2.52 1.94 2.97 3.95 4.83
2001:Q3 -0.55 0.39 1.34 1.57 1.72 2.75 3.56 4.46
2001:Q4 -0.70 0.18 1.14 -0.07 0.51 2.06 3.19 4.09
2002:Q1 -0.37 0.49 1.53 -0.09 0.66 2.37 3.47 4.34
2002:Q2 -0.72 0.18 1.08 -0.02 0.54 2.25 3.25 4.15
2002:Q3 -1.69 -0.68 -0.25 -0.13 0.29 1.86 2.90 3.86
2002:Q4 -1.90 -0.90 -0.40 -0.10 -0.01 1.87 2.79 3.74
2003:Q1 -1.73 -0.73 -0.21 -0.25 0.33 2.61 3.22 4.18
2003:Q2 -1.04 -0.09 0.66 -0.11 0.44 2.61 3.31 4.26
2003:Q3 -0.39 0.51 1.41 -0.32 0.03 2.61 3.61 4.51
2003:Q4 -0.17 0.71 1.95 -0.44 0.18 2.61 3.67 4.53
2004:Q1 -0.29 0.59 1.73 -0.75 0.48 2.59 3.60 4.48
2004:Q2 -0.20 0.68 1.70 -1.08 0.67 2.82 3.74 4.65
2004:Q3 -0.39 0.53 1.37 -0.65 0.90 2.58 3.63 4.55
2004:Q4 -0.39 0.48 1.62 -0.26 1.29 2.16 3.42 4.31
2005:Q1 -0.24 0.62 1.67 0.22 1.88 2.51 3.58 4.45
2005:Q2 -0.34 0.52 1.44 0.84 1.44 2.53 3.56 4.47
2005:Q3 -0.19 0.66 1.74 1.37 1.78 2.37 3.63 4.53
2005:Q4 -0.26 0.62 1.55 1.83 2.16 2.72 3.68 4.60
2006:Q1 -0.13 0.73 1.89 2.44 2.61 2.40 3.69 4.58
2006:Q2 -0.11 0.82 1.79 2.69 2.57 2.93 3.91 4.77
2006:Q3 -0.23 0.70 1.75 2.87 2.61 2.74 3.72 4.59
2006:Q4 -0.29 0.56 1.78 2.98 2.80 2.16 3.48 4.37
2007:Q1 -0.53 0.32 1.56 2.90 2.96 1.99 3.22 4.12
2007:Q2 -0.50 0.34 1.53 3.27 3.22 2.22 3.28 4.19
2007:Q3 -0.15 0.73 1.60 3.17 3.08 2.74 3.84 4.73
2007:Q4 -0.86 0.17 0.68 2.44 2.52 3.24 3.94 4.89
2008:Q1 -2.31 -1.16 -0.94 1.18 0.17 2.73 3.53 4.51
2008:Q2 -2.20 -1.24 -0.64 -0.15 -0.07 2.19 2.61 3.84

Bottom panel
Short-Run and Medium-Run Measures

Current Estimate Previous Bluebook
Short-Run Measures
1. Single-equation model 2.2 2.1
2. Small structural model -0.6 -0.8
3. Large model (FRB/US) 0.4 0.3
Confidence intervals for three model-based estimates
4a. 70 percent confidence interval -1.2 - 2.6
4b. 90 percent confidence interval -2.2 - 3.8
5. Greenbook-consistent measure -0.1 -0.5
Medium-Run Measures
6. Single-equation model 2.2 2.2
7. Small structural model 1.8 1.7
Confidence intervals for two model-based estimates
8a. 70 percent confidence interval 1.1 - 2.9
8b. 90 percent confidence interval 0.5 - 3.7
9. TIPS-based factor model 2.0 2.0
Measures of Actual Real Federal Funds Rate
10. Based on lagged core inflation -0.2 0.1
11. Based on lagged headline inflation -1.3 -1.1*
12. Based on Greenbook projection of headline inflation -1.3 -0.7*

* This measure was not reported in the April Bluebook.  Return to table

Note: Appendix A provides background information regarding the construction of these measures and confidence intervals.



Appendix 5: Materials used by Messrs. Angulo, Alvarez, and Parkinson

Material for Supervisory Report Concerning Investment Banks and Related Policy Issues
June 25, 2008

Class I FOMC - Restricted Controlled (FR)

Primary Dealer Monitoring Update

June 25, 2008
Federal Reserve Bank of New York

Page 2
Presentation Overview

Page 3
Objectives

Page 4
Approach

Page 5
Leverage Trend as Reported by the Firms

Gross Leverage

A line chart plots gross leverage data for Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, Merrill Lynch, and Lehman Brothers on a quarterly basis from 2003:Q4 through 2008:Q2. Unit is percent.

The Goldman Sachs series begins at about 5.4% in 2003:Q4, decreases fairly steadily to about 3.8 by 2006:Q1, increases to about 4.2 by 2006:Q3, then fluctuates but generally decreases to about 3.6 by 2008:Q1. The curve then increases to end at about 4.1% in 2008:Q2.

The Morgan Stanley series begins at about 4.4% in 2003:Q4, decreases fairly steadily to about 3.2 by 2006:Q2, then fluctuates between about 3.1 and 3.4 through 2007:Q4. The curve then increases to end at about 4.0% in 2008:Q2.

The Merrill Lynch series begins at about 6.4% in 2003:Q4, decreases to about 5.4 by 2004:Q3, fluctuates around 5.5 through 2006:Q1, then decreases and fluctuates around 5.0 through 2006:Q4. The curve then decreases fairly steadily to about 3.6 by 2007:Q4, and increases to end at about 4.0% in 2008:Q1.

The Lehman Brothers series begins at about 4.2% in 2003:Q4, decreases to just over 4.0 by 2004:Q2, generally increases to about 4.3 by 2005:Q1, then gradually decreases to about 3.9 by 2006:Q3. The curve dips to about 3.3 by 2006:Q4, increases to about 3.6 by 2007:Q2, decreases to about 3.3 by 2008:Q1, then increases quickly to end at about 4.1% in 2008:Q2.

Page 6
Capital - Current View

Left panel
Tier 1 Capital Ratios: 4 Largest Securities Firms

A bar chart. Approximate values are as follows.

Percent
March 2008 April 2008 Est. May 2008
Goldman Sachs 9.70 10.20 10.80
Lehman Brothers* 10.00 10.70 10.50
Merrill Lynch 6.65 7.05 ND
Morgan Stanley 12.20 12.10 11.75

* Note: For May this ratio would be 12.5% with June capital raise included  Return to table

Right panel
Comparison of FRBNY Adjusted Leverage Ratios*

A bar chart. Approximate values are as follows.

Percent
2007:Q1 2008:Q1
GS 5.4 4.8
LEH 5.2 5.0
MER 6.7 4.6
MS 4.8 4.2
 
BAC 5.1 4.8
C 5.0 3.9
JPM 6.1 5.9
WFC 7.6 6.1
WB 4.4 4.3

* Note: FRBNY Leverage Ratio = Tangible Equity / Total Assets less Secured Financing Assets and Intangible Assets  Return to text

Page 7
Recent Trend in Parent Company Liquidity Pools

Top-left panel
Goldman Liquidity Pool Trend

A line chart plots the Goldman Sachs liquidity pool trend from March 14 through June 18, 2008. The curve begins at about $77 billion, decreases to about 65 by March 27, increases to about 108 by May 12, decreases to about 90 by May 19, then generally increases to end at about $100 billion.

Top-right panel
Morgan Liquidity Pool Trend

A line chart plots the Morgan Stanley liquidity pool trend from March 14 through June 19, 2008. The curve begins at about $77 billion, decreases to about 47 by March 25, increases to about 79 by April 11, fluctuates around 75 through May 7, and fluctuates around 80 for the remainder of the period, ending at about $78 billion.

Bottom-left panel
Merrill Liquidity Pool Trend

A line chart plots the Merrill Lynch liquidity pool trend from March 17 through June 19, 2008. The curve begins at about $39 billion, dips to about 33 by March 19, increases to about 60 by March 28, fluctuates around 55 through April 28, fluctuates around 61 through May 23, and fluctuates around 67 for the remainder of the period, ending at about $66 billion.

Bottom-right panel
Lehman Liquidity Pool Trend

A line chart plots the Lehman Brothers liquidity pool trend from March 14 through June 18, 2008. The curve begins at about $30 billion, remains around that level through April 28, generally increases to about 45 by June 3, then fluctuates around that level and ends at about $42 billion.

Page 8
Liquidity Stress Approach

Left panel
As of dates: 5/22/08 - 6/10/08 Severity Assumption
UNSECURED FUNDING - Percent not rolling
Total Unsecured Funding 100%
SECURED FUNDING - Percent not rolling
Fixed Income Finance
OMO Eligible 0%
Liquid 20%
Less Liquid 50%
Illiquid 100%
Equity Finance
Liquid 20%
Less Liquid 50%
ON-BOARDING AND OTHER COMMITMENTS
Off-Balance Sheet Assets On-Boarded Institution Specific
Loan Commitments/Other Contractual Uses Institution Specific
Other Liabilities/Commitments Institution Specific
OPERATING CASH FLOWS
Prime Brokerage, Withdrawal of Free Credits 50%
Customer Shorts with Liquidity Risk 11%
Release of Lockup Cash Flows 90% - 100%
Collateral and Margin Calls: Payments / Receipts 100% / 90%
Derivatives / Margin Mismatches: Payments / Receipts 100% / 90%
ADDITIONAL FUNDING
Affiliated Banks / Unaffiliated Bank Lines / Other Institution Specific
Right panel

Page 9
PDCF Usage

Page 10
TSLF Usage - Schedule 1

Dealer Evolution of Top 5* Schedule 1 Awards: Total Amounts Outstanding

A line chart plots total amounts outstanding on total Schedule 1 Term Securities Lending Facility awards for Deutsche, BNP Paribas, Citigroup, Merrill Lynch, and Barclays Capital, and the Average excluding these top five, on a biweekly basis from April 3 through June 12, 2008. Unit is billions of dollars.

The Deutsche curve begins at about $10 billion on April 17, and stays at that level for the remainder of the period.

The BNP Paribas curve begins at about $5 billion, increases to about 10 by April 17, decreases fairly steadily to zero by May 29, then increases to end at about $4.3 billion.

The Citigroup curve begins at about $4.6 billion, increases to about 5.2 by May 1, decreases to about 5 by May 15, remains at that level until May 29, then increases to end at about $5.9 billion.

The Merrill Lynch curve begins at about $4.0 billion, increases to about 6.1 by May 1, decreases to about 5 by May 15, then decreases to zero by May 29 and stays at that level for the remainder of the period.

The Barclays Capital curve begins at about $0.5 billion, increases to about 2.6 by April 17, increases further to about 3.5 by May 1, decreases to about 2.3 by May 15, increases to about 4.2 by May 29, and decreases to end at about $3.5 billion.

The Average curve begins at about $0.5 billion, increases to about 1.2 by April 17, remains at that level through May 1, decreases to about 0.5 by May 15, decreases slightly further to about 0.3 by May 29, and increases to end at about $1.3 billion on June 12, 2008.

* Based on total Schedule 1 TSLF awards  Return to text

Page 11
TSLF Usage - Schedule 2

Dealer Evolution of Top 5* Schedule 2 Awards: Total Amounts Outstanding

A line chart plots total amounts outstanding on total Schedule 2 Term Securities Lending Facility awards for UBS, Lehman Brothers, Merrill Lynch, Deutsche, Citigroup, Goldman Sachs, and the Average excluding these "top five", on a biweekly basis from March 27 through June 19, 2008. Unit is billions of dollars.

The UBS curve begins at about $15 billion, remains at that level through April 24, increases to about 19 by May 8, then decreases to end at about $4 billion.

The Lehman Brothers curve begins at about $8 billion, increases to about 11 by April 10, remains at that level through April 24, then gradually decreases to end at about $8 billion.

The Merrill Lynch curve begins at about $10 billion, increases to about 13 by April 10, decreases to about 8 by April 24, increases to about 9 by May 8, then decreases to about $8 billion by May 22 and stays at that level for the remainder of the period.

The Deutsche curve begins at about $6 billion, increases to about 10.5 by April 24, decreases to about 7 by May 22, then increases to end at about $9 billion.

The Citigroup curve begins at about $1 billion, increases to about 11 by April 24, stays at that level until May 8, decreases to about $7.5 billion by June 5, and stays at the level for the remainder of the period.

The Goldman Sachs curve begins at about $7 billion, increases to about 11 by April 10, decreases to about 8 by April 24, decreases further to about 6 by May 22, stays at that level through June 5, then increases to end at about $7 billion.

The Average curve begins at about $2 billion, increases to slightly more than 3 by April 10, gradually decreases to about $1.5 billion by May 22, and stays at about that level for the remainder of the period.

* Based on total Schedule 2 TSLF awards; Citigroup and Goldman are tied for fifth  Return to text

Page 12
Near-Term Issues

Page 13
Primary Dealers

Dealer (in billions of dollars) Regulators
Total Assets1
Legal
Entity
(1)
Consolidated

(2)
Tri-party Repo
Collateral2
(3)
Legal
Entity
(4)
Consolidated

(5)
1. Goldman Sachs 705 1,189   117 SEC CSE/SEC
2. Deutsche Bank Securities 574 3,642   366 SEC FHC/FRS
3. Morgan Stanley 568 1,091   129 SEC CSE/SEC
4. Lehman Brothers 488 786   147 SEC CSE/SEC
5. UBS Securities 458 2,244   159 SEC FHC/FRS
6. Barclays Capital 439 2,4513 237 SEC FHC/FRS
7. Citigroup Global Markets 354 2,200   154 SEC FHC/FRS
8. Credit Suisse Securities 336 1,215   170 SEC FHC/FRS
9. JP Morgan Securities 280 1,643   90 SEC FHC/FRS
10. Banc of America Securities 272 1,737   311 SEC FHC/FRS
11. BNP Paribas Securities 245 2,496   102 SEC FHC/FRS
12. Merrill Lynch Govt
      Securities
170 1,042   141 Treasury/SEC CSE/SEC
13. Greenwich Capital Mkts 150 3,7953 58 SEC FHC/FRS
14. Bear Stearns 131 399   20 SEC CSE/SEC
15. HSBC Securities USA 75 2,3543 34 SEC FHC/FRS
16. Dresdner Kleinwort
      Wasserstein Securities
62 1,780   14 SEC FHC/FRS
17. Cantor Fitzgerald 31 293 NA SEC None
18. Daiwa Securities America 29 174   5 SEC Japan FSA
19. Countrywide Securities 24 199   12 SEC THC/OTS
20. Mizuho Securities USA 23 1,3743 12 SEC FHC/FRS

1 As of Q1 2008, except where noted.  Return to table

2 Average for May 27 through June 6. In some cases includes collateral financed by affiliates of the primary dealer.  Return to table

3 Q4 2007.  Return to table

Pages 14-15
Liquidity Facilities and the Prudential Supervision of
Investment Banks1 and Other Primary Dealers
Key Issues for Discussion

Liquidity Facilities
  1. When and under what circumstances should we decide to extend, modify, or eliminate our current credit facilities for primary dealers (PDCF and TSLF)? Should the timing and circumstances differ for the two facilities?
  2. If we decide to eliminate one or both credit facilities, how should that be done? How much notice should be provided? Should the terms of credit extension be gradually tightened prior to closing the facility, or should the facility be closed in one step? When notice is given, should we give assurances that the closing of the facilities will be delayed if conditions in financial markets warrant?
  3. Should we seek legislation that would permit us to provide some type of liquidity backstop to primary dealers in the longer term? Under what conditions should a primary dealer be permitted to draw on such a backstop? What is the rationale for any such backstop?
Prudential Supervision
  1. How do we limit the moral hazard risk that our current credit facilities undermine the incentives for primary dealers and the holding companies that own them to manage liquidity and capital to appropriately conservative levels?
    • a. On what principles should supervisory expectations for investment banks' capital, liquidity, and risk management be based? Should these expectations be codified in a formal document? How?
    • b. To what liquidity standard should the SEC-regulated investment banks be held? Is it appropriate to expect the firms to maintain liquidity sufficient to withstand a Bear Stearns-type scenario? Should bank-affiliated primary dealers (and their parent companies) be held to the same liquidity standard as investment banks?2
    • c. Should investment banks be held to the same capital standards as bank holding companies? What about the leverage ratio?
  2. In the longer term, can we rely on an MOU with the SEC to provide the prudential supervision that is necessary to limit moral hazard? Or is legislation needed to enhance the effectiveness of prudential supervision of primary dealers? Is there a need for legislation only if we provide primary dealers with an ongoing liquidity backstop or is legislation needed even if their access is only in unusual and exigent circumstances?
  3. If legislation is needed, what type of legislation? Legislation requiring consolidated supervision of investment banks? By whom? Should the securities laws be amended to provide the SEC with explicit authority to conduct consolidated supervision of investment banks? Should all primary dealers and their affiliates be regulated as FHCs? Are changes to the functional regulation provisions of Gramm-Leach-Bliley needed to make effective consolidated supervision of primary dealers that are part of FHCs?
  4. If we provide primary dealers with an ongoing liquidity backstop, do we need to alter the criteria for becoming a primary dealer (which have worked well to define appropriate counterparties for desk transactions) to require a primary dealer and its consolidated organization to be subject to effective prudential supervision?

1 For purposes of this discussion an investment bank is a primary dealer whose consolidated supervisor is the SEC. Of the twenty primary dealers, four (including Bear Stearns) are subsidiaries of investment bank holding companies subject to consolidated supervision by the SEC, thirteen are subsidiaries of Financial Holding Companies (FHCs), one (Countrywide) is a subsidiary of a thrift holding company, and one (Cantor Fitzgerald) is not subject to consolidated supervision.  Return to text

2 Under the SEC's program for consolidated supervision, investment banks are required to maintain liquidity pools at the parent company sufficient to meet expected cash outflows in specified stress scenarios. Those scenarios include the loss of access to unsecured funding for an entire year.  Return to text


Return to topReturn to top



Home | Monetary policy | FOMC | FOMC transcripts
Accessibility | Contact Us
Last update: February 21, 2014