Accessible Version

Figure 1. Historical and stressed tier 1 common ratio and common equity tier 1 ratio

Period Ratio Percent
Actual, 2010:Q1 Tier 1 common 8.52
Actual, 2011:Q1 Tier 1 common 9.98
Actual, 2012:Q1 Tier 1 common 1.09
Actual, 2013:Q1 Tier 1 common 1.10
Actual, 2013:Q4 Tier 1 common 1.16
Actual, 2014:Q3 Tier 1 common 1.19
Actual, 2015:Q4 Actual CET1 1.23
Actual, 2016:Q4 Actual CET1 1.25
Stressed, 2019:Q1 Stressed CET1 9.20

Source: FR Y-9C, FR Y-14A, and supervisory estimates under the severely adverse scenario.

Return to text

Figure 2. Unemployment rate in the severely adverse and adverse scenarios, 2012:Q1-2020:Q1

Percent

Period Actual Severely Adverse Adverse
2012:Q1 8.3 ND ND
2012:Q2 8.2 ND ND
2012:Q3 8.0 ND ND
2012:Q4 7.8 ND ND
2013:Q1 7.7 ND ND
2013:Q2 7.5 ND ND
2013:Q3 7.3 ND ND
2013:Q4 6.9 ND ND
2014:Q1 6.7 ND ND
2014:Q2 6.2 ND ND
2014:Q3 6.1 ND ND
2014:Q4 5.7 ND ND
2015:Q1 5.6 ND ND
2015:Q2 5.4 ND ND
2015:Q3 5.2 ND ND
2015:Q4 5.0 ND ND
2016:Q1 4.9 ND ND
2016:Q2 4.9 ND ND
2016:Q3 4.9 ND ND
2016:Q4 4.7 ND ND
2017:Q1 ND 5.6 5.2
2017:Q2 ND 6.9 5.8
2017:Q3 ND 8.0 6.3
2017:Q4 ND 8.9 6.8
2018:Q1 ND 9.6 7.1
2018:Q2 ND 9.8 7.3
2018:Q3 ND 10.0 7.4
2018:Q4 ND 9.9 7.3
2019:Q1 ND 9.8 7.2
2019:Q2 ND 9.6 7.1
2019:Q3 ND 9.4 7.0
2019:Q4 ND 9.1 6.9
2020:Q1 ND 8.9 6.8

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics and Federal Reserve assumptions in the supervisory scenarios.

Return to text

Figure 3. Real GDP growth rate in the severely adverse and adverse scenarios, 2012:Q1-2020:Q1

Percent

Period Actual Severely Adverse Adverse
2012:Q1 2.7 ND ND
2012:Q2 1.9 ND ND
2012:Q3 0.5 ND ND
2012:Q4 0.1 ND ND
2013:Q1 2.8 ND ND
2013:Q2 0.8 ND ND
2013:Q3 3.1 ND ND
2013:Q4 4.0 ND ND
2014:Q1 -1.2 ND ND
2014:Q2 4.0 ND ND
2014:Q3 5.0 ND ND
2014:Q4 2.3 ND ND
2015:Q1 2.0 ND ND
2015:Q2 2.6 ND ND
2015:Q3 2.0 ND ND
2015:Q4 0.9 ND ND
2016:Q1 0.8 ND ND
2016:Q2 1.4 ND ND
2016:Q3 3.5 ND ND
2016:Q4 ND 3.1 3.1
2017:Q1 ND -5.1 -1.5
2017:Q2 ND -7.5 -2.8
2017:Q3 ND -5.9 -2.0
2017:Q4 ND -5.1 -1.5
2018:Q1 ND -3.0 -0.5
2018:Q2 ND 0.0 1.0
2018:Q3 ND 0.7 1.4
2018:Q4 ND 3.0 2.6
2019:Q1 ND 3.0 2.6
2019:Q2 ND 3.9 3.0
2019:Q3 ND 3.9 3.0
2019:Q4 ND 3.9 3.0
2020:Q1 ND 3.9 3.0

Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis and Federal Reserve assumptions in the supervisory scenarios.

Return to text

Figure 4. Dow Jones Total Stock Market Index, end of quarter in the severely adverse and adverse scenarios, 2012:Q1-2020:Q1

Index level

Period Actual Severely Adverse Adverse
2012:Q1 14627.5 ND ND
2012:Q2 14100.2 ND ND
2012:Q3 14894.7 ND ND
2012:Q4 14834.9 ND ND
2013:Q1 16396.2 ND ND
2013:Q2 16771.3 ND ND
2013:Q3 17718.3 ND ND
2013:Q4 19413.2 ND ND
2014:Q1 19711.2 ND ND
2014:Q2 20568.7 ND ND
2014:Q3 20458.8 ND ND
2014:Q4 21424.6 ND ND
2015:Q1 21707.6 ND ND
2015:Q2 21630.9 ND ND
2015:Q3 19959.3 ND ND
2015:Q4 21100.9 ND ND
2016:Q1 21179.4 ND ND
2016:Q2 21621.5 ND ND
2016:Q3 22468.6 ND ND
2016:Q4 23276.7 ND ND
2017:Q1 ND 15373.6 15959.6
2017:Q2 ND 13537.6 15042.3
2017:Q3 ND 12294.8 14289.9
2017:Q4 ND 11704.3 13982.2
2018:Q1 ND 12337.7 14367.4
2018:Q2 ND 13325.5 15001.0
2018:Q3 ND 14348.1 15692.9
2018:Q4 ND 15625.0 16603.2
2019:Q1 ND 17069.7 17519.5
2019:Q2 ND 18738.7 18513.7
2019:Q3 ND 19908.7 19242.6
2019:Q4 ND 21185.7 20025.4
2020:Q1 ND 22577.4 20867.0

Source: Dow Jones and Federal Reserve assumptions in the supervisory scenarios.

Return to text

Figure 5. National House Price Index in the severely adverse and adverse scenarios, 2012:Q1-2020:Q1

Index level

Period Actual Severely Adverse Adverse
2012:Q1 133.8 ND ND
2012:Q2 137.2 ND ND
2012:Q3 139.9 ND ND
2012:Q4 142.9 ND ND
2013:Q1 146.6 ND ND
2013:Q2 150.6 ND ND
2013:Q3 154.4 ND ND
2013:Q4 157.5 ND ND
2014:Q1 159.6 ND ND
2014:Q2 160.8 ND ND
2014:Q3 162.9 ND ND
2014:Q4 165.4 ND ND
2015:Q1 167.8 ND ND
2015:Q2 169.9 ND ND
2015:Q3 172.1 ND ND
2015:Q4 174.2 ND ND
2016:Q1 176.6 ND ND
2016:Q2 178.8 ND ND
2016:Q3 182.0 ND ND
2016:Q4 183.3 ND ND
2017:Q1 ND 179.2 181.4
2017:Q2 ND 174.0 179.0
2017:Q3 ND 168.0 176.1
2017:Q4 ND 161.7 173.0
2018:Q1 ND 155.7 170.1
2018:Q2 ND 148.3 166.3
2018:Q3 ND 142.1 163.1
2018:Q4 ND 138.0 160.9
2019:Q1 ND 137.5 160.6
2019:Q2 ND 138.2 161.0
2019:Q3 ND 139.6 161.8
2019:Q4 ND 141.8 162.9
2020:Q1 ND 144.6 164.5

Source: CoreLogic (seasonally adjusted by Federal Reserve) and Federal Reserve assumptions in the supervisory scenarios.

Return to text

Figure 6. U.S. BBB corporate yield, quarterly average in the severely adverse and adverse scenarios, 2012:Q1-2020:Q1

Percentage yield

Period Actual Severely Adverse Adverse
2012:Q1 4.7 ND ND
2012:Q2 4.5 ND ND
2012:Q3 4.2 ND ND
2012:Q4 3.9 ND ND
2013:Q1 4.0 ND ND
2013:Q2 4.1 ND ND
2013:Q3 4.9 ND ND
2013:Q4 4.8 ND ND
2014:Q1 4.6 ND ND
2014:Q2 4.3 ND ND
2014:Q3 4.2 ND ND
2014:Q4 4.2 ND ND
2015:Q1 4.0 ND ND
2015:Q2 4.2 ND ND
2015:Q3 4.5 ND ND
2015:Q4 4.6 ND ND
2016:Q1 4.6 ND ND
2016:Q2 4.1 ND ND
2016:Q3 3.7 ND ND
2016:Q4 4.1 ND ND
2017:Q1 ND 5.5 5.6
2017:Q2 ND 6.0 5.9
2017:Q3 ND 6.3 6.1
2017:Q4 ND 6.4 6.2
2018:Q1 ND 6.1 6.0
2018:Q2 ND 5.7 5.8
2018:Q3 ND 5.4 5.6
2018:Q4 ND 5.0 5.4
2019:Q1 ND 4.7 5.2
2019:Q2 ND 4.3 5.0
2019:Q3 ND 4.0 4.8
2019:Q4 ND 3.8 4.7
2020:Q1 ND 3.6 4.5

Source: Merrill Lynch (adjusted by Federal Reserve using a Nelson-Siegel smoothed yield curve model) and Federal Reserve assumptions in the supervisory scenarios.

Return to text

Figure 7. U.S. Market Volatility Index (VIX) in the severely adverse and adverse scenarios, 2012:Q1-2020:Q1

Index level

Period Actual Severely Adverse Adverse
2012:Q1 23.0 ND ND
2012:Q2 26.7 ND ND
2012:Q3 20.5 ND ND
2012:Q4 22.7 ND ND
2013:Q1 19.0 ND ND
2013:Q2 20.5 ND ND
2013:Q3 17.0 ND ND
2013:Q4 20.3 ND ND
2014:Q1 21.4 ND ND
2014:Q2 17.0 ND ND
2014:Q3 17.0 ND ND
2014:Q4 26.3 ND ND
2015:Q1 22.4 ND ND
2015:Q2 18.9 ND ND
2015:Q3 40.7 ND ND
2015:Q4 24.4 ND ND
2016:Q1 28.1 ND ND
2016:Q2 25.8 ND ND
2016:Q3 18.1 ND ND
2016:Q4 22.5 ND ND
2017:Q1 ND 68.7 37.1
2017:Q2 ND 50.9 32.7
2017:Q3 ND 57.2 34.4
2017:Q4 ND 49.3 32.0
2018:Q1 ND 39.1 28.5
2018:Q2 ND 31.9 25.8
2018:Q3 ND 26.7 23.6
2018:Q4 ND 22.2 21.6
2019:Q1 ND 19.3 20.1
2019:Q2 ND 16.8 18.7
2019:Q3 ND 16.0 18.2
2019:Q4 ND 14.9 17.6
2020:Q1 ND 14.3 17.3

Source: Chicago Board Options Exchange (converted to quarterly by Federal Reserve using the maximum quarterly close-of-day value) and Federal Reserve assumptions in the supervisory scenarios.

Return to text

Figure 8. Projecting net income and regulatory capital

A flowchart with five steps, leading from one to the next.

  • Net interest income plus noninterest income, minus noninterest expense, equals pre-provision net revenue (PPNR).
    (Note: PPNR includes income from mortgage servicing rights and losses from operational-risk events and OREO costs.)
  • PPNR plus other revenue, minus provisions, minus AFS/HTM securities losses, minus HFS/FVO loan losses, minus trading and counterparty losses, equals pre-tax net income.
    (Note: Change in the allowance for loan and lease losses, plus net charge-offs, equals provisions.)
  • Pre-tax net income minus taxes, minus income attributable to minority interest, minus change in the valuation allowance, equals after-tax net income.
  • After-tax net income minus net distributions to common and preferred shareholders and other net reductions to shareholder's equity from DFAST assumptions plus other comprehensive income, equals change in equity capital.
  • Change in equity capital minus change in adjustments and deductions from regulatory capital, plus other additions to regulatory capital, equals change in regulatory capital.

Return to text

Figure A. Hypothetical revenue projections from the original and enhanced PPNR models

Revenue as % of assets

Period relative to stress event Firm A, Historical Firm B, Historical Firm A, Projected, Original model Firm B, Projected, Original model Firm A, Projected, Enhanced model Firm B, Projected, Enhanced model
-9 15.97 5.68 ND ND ND ND
-8 15.65 5.22 ND ND ND ND
-7 15.52 5.00 ND ND ND ND
-6 15.65 5.03 ND ND ND ND
-5 15.55 5.01 ND ND ND ND
-4 15.55 5.06 ND ND ND ND
-3 15.62 5.15 ND ND ND ND
-2 15.59 5.16 ND ND ND ND
-1 15.38 5.09 ND ND ND ND
0 (Stress event) 15.00 5.00 15.00 5.00 15.00 5.00
1 ND ND 10.00 2.00 11.00 1.00
2 ND ND 7.00 0.60 8.80 -1.20
3 ND ND 5.60 0.48 8.04 -1.96
4 ND ND 5.48 1.38 8.43 -1.57
5 ND ND 6.38 3.11 9.75 -0.25
6 ND ND 7.11 4.49 10.80 0.80
7 ND ND 7.69 5.59 11.64 1.64
8 ND ND 8.15 6.47 12.31 2.31
9 ND ND 8.52 7.18 12.85 2.85
10 ND ND 8.82 7.74 13.28 3.28

Return to text

Figure 9. Projected losses in the severely adverse scenario

  Billions of dollars
First-lien mortgages, domestic 27
Junior liens and HELOCs, domestic 17
Trading and counterparty losses 86
Credit cards 100
Commercial and industrial loans 100
Securities losses 5
Commercial real estate, domestic 56
Other consumer loans 41
Other loans 43
Other losses 18

Return to text

Figure 10. Change from 2016:Q4 to minimum CET1 ratio in the severely adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 2.9
American Express 1.7
BancWest 4.0
Bank of America 3.2
Bank of NY-Mellon 1.1
BB&T 2.3
BBVA 3.8
BMO 4.5
Capital One 3.1
CIT 1.1
Citigroup 5.1
Citizens 3.5
Comerica 1.7
DBTC 4.2
Discover 2.9
Fifth Third 2.4
Goldman Sachs 6.1
HSBC 5.0
Huntington 2.5
JPMorgan Chase 3.4
KeyCorp 2.8
M&T 2.8
Morgan Stanley 8.4
MUFG Americas 2.3
Northern Trust 0.9
PNC 2.5
Regions 3.0
Santander 2.1
State Street 4.3
SunTrust 2.5
TD Group 2.3
U.S. Bancorp 1.8
Wells Fargo 2.6
Zions 3.5

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of risk-weighted assets. Median = 2.8%

Return to text

Figure 11. Total loan loss rates in the severely adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 5.2
American Express 9.1
BancWest 6.4
Bank of America 4.6
Bank of NY-Mellon 2.5
BB&T 4.7
BBVA 5.9
BMO 5.7
Capital One 12.2
CIT 8.6
Citigroup 6.8
Citizens 4.8
Comerica 4.2
DBTC 3.7
Discover 13.0
Fifth Third 5.6
Goldman Sachs 8.1
HSBC 5.3
Huntington 4.6
JPMorgan Chase 5.7
KeyCorp 5.9
M&T 5.4
Morgan Stanley 3.2
MUFG Americas 4.8
Northern Trust 4.4
PNC 4.3
Regions 6.1
Santander 9.1
State Street 3.1
SunTrust 4.5
TD Group 5.5
U.S. Bancorp 6.3
Wells Fargo 5.0
Zions 6.4

Note: Estimates are for nine quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average balances. Median = 5.4%

Return to text

Figure 12. PPNR rates in the severely adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 3.0
American Express 11.4
BancWest 2.2
Bank of America 1.7
Bank of NY-Mellon 2.9
BB&T 3.4
BBVA 1.8
BMO 1.3
Capital One 7.8
CIT 2.7
Citigroup 2.6
Citizens 2.0
Comerica 2.1
DBTC 1.3
Discover 13.5
Fifth Third 2.9
Goldman Sachs 0.7
HSBC -0.5
Huntington 2.7
JPMorgan Chase 2.5
KeyCorp 2.4
M&T 3.6
Morgan Stanley 0.6
MUFG Americas 1.8
Northern Trust 2.4
PNC 3.2
Regions 2.9
Santander 4.8
State Street 1.6
SunTrust 2.6
TD Group 1.7
U.S. Bancorp 4.4
Wells Fargo 3.5
Zions 2.5

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average assets. Median = 2.6%

Return to text

Figure 13. Pre-tax net income rates in the severely adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally -1.8
American Express 2.9
BancWest -2.8
Bank of America -1.1
Bank of NY-Mellon 2.2
BB&T -0.1
BBVA -2.6
BMO -2.0
Capital One -1.6
CIT -3.3
Citigroup -0.5
Citizens -2.0
Comerica -0.5
DBTC 0.3
Discover 0.6
Fifth Third -0.9
Goldman Sachs -2.5
HSBC -1.8
Huntington -0.8
JPMorgan Chase -0.7
KeyCorp -1.9
M&T -0.7
Morgan Stanley -1.6
MUFG Americas -1.2
Northern Trust 0.9
PNC 0.5
Regions -1.4
Santander -0.1
State Street 0.8
SunTrust -1.3
TD Group -0.7
U.S. Bancorp 0.3
Wells Fargo 0.2
Zions -2.1

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average assets. Median = -0.9%

Return to text

Figure 14. Projected losses in the adverse scenario

  Billions of dollars
First-lien mortgages, domestic 15
Junior liens and HELOCs, domestic 11
Trading and counterparty losses 46
Credit cards 79
Commercial and industrial loans 67
Securities losses 3
Commercial real estate, domestic 27
Other consumer loans 31
Other loans 27
Other losses 15

Return to text

Figure 15. Change from 2016:Q4 to minimum CET1 ratio in the adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 0.9
American Express 0.6
BancWest 1.3
Bank of America 1.5
Bank of NY-Mellon 1.2
BB&T 0.8
BBVA 1.4
BMO 2.2
Capital One 1.5
CIT 0.7
Citigroup 3.4
Citizens 1.5
Comerica 0.4
DBTC 3.7
Discover 1.2
Fifth Third 0.6
Goldman Sachs 3.1
HSBC 4.6
Huntington 0.9
JPMorgan Chase 1.8
KeyCorp 0.9
M&T 1.2
Morgan Stanley 4.5
MUFG Americas 0.5
Northern Trust 0.4
PNC 1.6
Regions 1.1
Santander 0.2
State Street 3.0
SunTrust 1.1
TD Group 0.4
U.S. Bancorp 0.8
Wells Fargo 1.3
Zions 1.0

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of risk-weighted assets. Median = 1.2%

Return to text

Figure 16. Total loan loss rates in the adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 3.6
American Express 6.9
BancWest 3.8
Bank of America 3.0
Bank of NY-Mellon 1.6
BB&T 2.9
BBVA 3.6
BMO 3.7
Capital One 9.2
CIT 5.2
Citigroup 4.9
Citizens 3.1
Comerica 2.5
DBTC 2.2
Discover 10.2
Fifth Third 3.5
Goldman Sachs 5.7
HSBC 3.3
Huntington 2.9
JPMorgan Chase 3.8
KeyCorp 3.6
M&T 3.3
Morgan Stanley 2.0
MUFG Americas 2.6
Northern Trust 2.5
PNC 2.6
Regions 3.9
Santander 6.2
State Street 2.1
SunTrust 2.8
TD Group 3.6
U.S. Bancorp 4.0
Wells Fargo 3.1
Zions 3.7

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average balances. Median = 3.6%

Return to text

Figure 17. PPNR Rates in the adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 3.6
American Express 12.0
BancWest 2.8
Bank of America 2.6
Bank of NY-Mellon 3.6
BB&T 4.2
BBVA 2.4
BMO 1.9
Capital One 8.5
CIT 3.2
Citigroup 3.3
Citizens 2.7
Comerica 2.8
DBTC 1.5
Discover 14.0
Fifth Third 3.8
Goldman Sachs 1.1
HSBC 0.2
Huntington 3.3
JPMorgan Chase 3.2
KeyCorp 3.2
M&T 4.2
Morgan Stanley 1.1
MUFG Americas 2.4
Northern Trust 2.9
PNC 4.0
Regions 3.5
Santander 5.4
State Street 2.3
SunTrust 3.6
TD Group 2.3
U.S. Bancorp 5.2
Wells Fargo 4.4
Zions 3.2

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average assets. Median = 3.2%

Return to text

Figure 18. Pre-tax net income in the adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 0.4
American Express 5.8
BancWest -0.1
Bank of America 0.9
Bank of NY-Mellon 3.2
BB&T 2.2
BBVA 0.0
BMO 0.0
Capital One 1.6
CIT -0.6
Citigroup 1.2
Citizens 0.2
Comerica 1.6
DBTC 0.9
Discover 3.9
Fifth Third 1.7
Goldman Sachs -0.8
HSBC -0.4
Huntington 1.2
JPMorgan Chase 1.4
KeyCorp 0.6
M&T 1.8
Morgan Stanley -0.2
MUFG Americas 0.8
Northern Trust 2.1
PNC 2.5
Regions 1.0
Santander 2.8
State Street 1.9
SunTrust 1.2
TD Group 0.8
U.S. Bancorp 2.8
Wells Fargo 2.6
Zions 0.8

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average assets. Median = 1.2%

Return to text

Figure D.1. First-lien mortgages domestic loss rates in the severely adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 2.4
American Express 0.0
BancWest 2.3
Bank of America 2.1
Bank of NY-Mellon 2.2
BB&T 2.5
BBVA 2.9
BMO 3.2
Capital One 1.1
CIT 1.3
Citigroup 2.6
Citizens 1.2
Comerica 2.2
DBTC 2.2
Discover 2.7
Fifth Third 3.2
Goldman Sachs 52.3
HSBC 1.5
Huntington 2.8
JPMorgan Chase 1.8
KeyCorp 3.3
M&T 4.2
Morgan Stanley 1.6
MUFG Americas 1.9
Northern Trust 1.7
PNC 1.7
Regions 3.2
Santander 2.7
State Street 0.0
SunTrust 2.9
TD Group 2.7
U.S. Bancorp 1.7
Wells Fargo 1.8
Zions 0.6

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average balances. Median = 2.2.%

Return to text

Figure D.2. Junior liens and HELOCs domestic loss rates in the severely adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 6.3
American Express 0.0
BancWest 3.9
Bank of America 5.1
Bank of NY-Mellon 5.0
BB&T 3.2
BBVA 4.8
BMO 10.4
Capital One 7.0
CIT 2.6
Citigroup 6.9
Citizens 4.5
Comerica 3.1
DBTC 4.7
Discover 9.4
Fifth Third 4.9
Goldman Sachs 4.5
HSBC 3.7
Huntington 3.4
JPMorgan Chase 4.4
KeyCorp 3.9
M&T 4.3
Morgan Stanley 4.5
MUFG Americas 3.4
Northern Trust 7.2
PNC 2.0
Regions 4.9
Santander 3.7
State Street 0.0
SunTrust 4.4
TD Group 5.1
U.S. Bancorp 4.6
Wells Fargo 4.3
Zions 2.6

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average balances. Median = 4.5%

Return to text

Figure D.3. Commercial and industrial loss rates in the severely adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 4.3
American Express 10.2
BancWest 8.8
Bank of America 4.7
Bank of NY-Mellon 3.4
BB&T 5.2
BBVA 7.1
BMO 5.9
Capital One 10.2
CIT 10.3
Citigroup 5.1
Citizens 5.5
Comerica 3.5
DBTC 4.9
Discover 13.8
Fifth Third 5.5
Goldman Sachs 11.1
HSBC 7.6
Huntington 4.8
JPMorgan Chase 9.7
KeyCorp 6.0
M&T 4.2
Morgan Stanley 10.4
MUFG Americas 7.2
Northern Trust 4.2
PNC 5.8
Regions 7.2
Santander 4.0
State Street 6.2
SunTrust 4.7
TD Group 5.8
U.S. Bancorp 7.9
Wells Fargo 6.4
Zions 8.6

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average balances. Losses are calculated based on the exposure at default, which includes both outstanding balances and any additional drawdown of the credit line that occurs prior to default, while loss rates are calculated as a percent of outstanding balances. Median = 6.0%

Return to text

Figure D.4. Commercial real estate domestic loss rates in the severely adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 2.2
American Express 0.0
BancWest 7.6
Bank of America 8.0
Bank of NY-Mellon 7.9
BB&T 6.0
BBVA 8.2
BMO 7.9
Capital One 5.3
CIT 10.9
Citigroup 7.8
Citizens 7.9
Comerica 6.0
DBTC 7.4
Discover 15.5
Fifth Third 11.8
Goldman Sachs 8.9
HSBC 5.9
Huntington 7.0
JPMorgan Chase 3.8
KeyCorp 9.8
M&T 7.1
Morgan Stanley 5.0
MUFG Americas 7.5
Northern Trust 7.3
PNC 6.1
Regions 10.4
Santander 5.7
State Street 6.6
SunTrust 6.9
TD Group 6.7
U.S. Bancorp 9.7
Wells Fargo 7.7
Zions 7.3

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average balances. Median = 7.4%

Return to text

Figure D.5. Credit card loss rates in the severely adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 0.0
American Express 8.6
BancWest 13.0
Bank of America 12.2
Bank of NY-Mellon 0.0
BB&T 13.2
BBVA 16.9
BMO 11.7
Capital One 20.3
CIT 0.0
Citigroup 13.7
Citizens 11.9
Comerica 0.0
DBTC 0.0
Discover 13.5
Fifth Third 16.6
Goldman Sachs 0.0
HSBC 13.5
Huntington 13.5
JPMorgan Chase 11.5
KeyCorp 12.8
M&T 13.5
Morgan Stanley 0.0
MUFG Americas 13.5
Northern Trust 0.0
PNC 12.6
Regions 15.2
Santander 13.2
State Street 0.0
SunTrust 14.1
TD Group 18.9
U.S. Bancorp 15.2
Wells Fargo 15.3
Zions 13.5

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average balances. Median = 13.5%

Return to text

Figure D.6. Other consumer loss rates in the severely adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 6.6
American Express 0.0
BancWest 5.6
Bank of America 2.2
Bank of NY-Mellon 9.3
BB&T 6.3
BBVA 7.0
BMO 2.4
Capital One 8.1
CIT 12.9
Citigroup 12.1
Citizens 4.9
Comerica 8.4
DBTC 3.7
Discover 11.0
Fifth Third 3.7
Goldman Sachs 5.5
HSBC 7.0
Huntington 4.2
JPMorgan Chase 4.3
KeyCorp 6.9
M&T 6.0
Morgan Stanley 0.6
MUFG Americas 12.9
Northern Trust 13.8
PNC 3.2
Regions 7.1
Santander 17.5
State Street 0.6
SunTrust 4.9
TD Group 2.5
U.S. Bancorp 3.6
Wells Fargo 6.9
Zions 9.5

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average balances. Median = 6.3%

Return to text

Figure D.7. Other loans loss rates in the severely adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 7.5
American Express 0.0
BancWest 6.6
Bank of America 3.0
Bank of NY-Mellon 1.6
BB&T 3.4
BBVA 2.5
BMO 4.9
Capital One 4.3
CIT 11.1
Citigroup 3.5
Citizens 3.3
Comerica 4.8
DBTC 1.8
Discover 5.1
Fifth Third 3.4
Goldman Sachs 4.7
HSBC 3.9
Huntington 3.9
JPMorgan Chase 4.7
KeyCorp 2.8
M&T 3.6
Morgan Stanley 3.0
MUFG Americas 3.5
Northern Trust 4.2
PNC 1.8
Regions 2.7
Santander 10.0
State Street 2.5
SunTrust 2.1
TD Group 3.2
U.S. Bancorp 4.9
Wells Fargo 3.4
Zions 7.5

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average balances. Median = 3.5%

Return to text

Figure D.8. First-lien mortgages domestic loss rates in the adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 1.4
American Express 0.0
BancWest 1.2
Bank of America 1.0
Bank of NY-Mellon 1.4
BB&T 1.5
BBVA 1.6
BMO 2.1
Capital One 0.8
CIT 0.6
Citigroup 1.3
Citizens 0.6
Comerica 1.2
DBTC 1.5
Discover 1.7
Fifth Third 2.3
Goldman Sachs 49.8
HSBC 0.6
Huntington 1.7
JPMorgan Chase 0.9
KeyCorp 2.3
M&T 3.0
Morgan Stanley 0.9
MUFG Americas 0.8
Northern Trust 0.9
PNC 0.9
Regions 2.0
Santander 1.7
State Street 0.0
SunTrust 1.7
TD Group 1.8
U.S. Bancorp 0.9
Wells Fargo 0.8
Zions 0.3

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average balances. Median = 1.4%

Return to text

Figure D.9. Junior liens and HELOCs domestic loss rates in the adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 4.0
American Express 0.0
BancWest 2.2
Bank of America 3.1
Bank of NY-Mellon 3.6
BB&T 2.1
BBVA 3.3
BMO 8.6
Capital One 5.5
CIT 1.9
Citigroup 3.8
Citizens 3.2
Comerica 1.7
DBTC 3.4
Discover 7.6
Fifth Third 3.7
Goldman Sachs 3.2
HSBC 2.3
Huntington 2.4
JPMorgan Chase 2.7
KeyCorp 2.9
M&T 3.2
Morgan Stanley 3.2
MUFG Americas 1.5
Northern Trust 4.7
PNC 1.1
Regions 3.6
Santander 2.6
State Street 0.0
SunTrust 3.1
TD Group 3.9
U.S. Bancorp 3.0
Wells Fargo 2.3
Zions 1.4

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average balances. Median = 3.1%

Return to text

Figure D.10. Commercial and industrial loss rates in the adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 2.9
American Express 7.4
BancWest 5.7
Bank of America 3.0
Bank of NY-Mellon 2.2
BB&T 3.7
BBVA 4.9
BMO 3.9
Capital One 7.1
CIT 7.0
Citigroup 3.7
Citizens 3.5
Comerica 2.3
DBTC 3.4
Discover 10.3
Fifth Third 3.5
Goldman Sachs 7.0
HSBC 5.3
Huntington 3.1
JPMorgan Chase 6.5
KeyCorp 3.7
M&T 3.0
Morgan Stanley 6.9
MUFG Americas 4.5
Northern Trust 2.6
PNC 3.8
Regions 4.7
Santander 2.7
State Street 3.7
SunTrust 2.9
TD Group 3.7
U.S. Bancorp 5.3
Wells Fargo 4.2
Zions 5.8

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average balances. Losses are calculated based on the exposure at default, which includes both outstanding balances and any additional drawdown of the credit line that occurs prior to default, while loss rates are calculated as a percent of outstanding balances. Median = 3.8%

Return to text

Figure D.11. Commercial real estate domestic loss rates in the adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 1.2
American Express 0.0
BancWest 3.9
Bank of America 3.8
Bank of NY-Mellon 3.7
BB&T 3.0
BBVA 4.0
BMO 3.9
Capital One 2.4
CIT 5.0
Citigroup 3.5
Citizens 3.9
Comerica 2.8
DBTC 3.3
Discover 7.0
Fifth Third 5.6
Goldman Sachs 4.0
HSBC 2.5
Huntington 3.7
JPMorgan Chase 1.9
KeyCorp 4.8
M&T 3.5
Morgan Stanley 2.1
MUFG Americas 3.5
Northern Trust 3.4
PNC 2.8
Regions 5.5
Santander 2.8
State Street 2.9
SunTrust 3.3
TD Group 3.3
U.S. Bancorp 4.7
Wells Fargo 3.5
Zions 3.6

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average balances. Median = 3.5%

Return to text

Figure D.12. Credit card loss rates in the adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 0.0
American Express 6.6
BancWest 10.3
Bank of America 9.4
Bank of NY-Mellon 0.0
BB&T 10.0
BBVA 13.4
BMO 9.0
Capital One 16.2
CIT 0.0
Citigroup 10.8
Citizens 9.3
Comerica 0.0
DBTC 0.0
Discover 10.5
Fifth Third 12.2
Goldman Sachs 0.0
HSBC 10.5
Huntington 10.5
JPMorgan Chase 8.8
KeyCorp 10.0
M&T 10.5
Morgan Stanley 0.0
MUFG Americas 10.5
Northern Trust 0.0
PNC 9.5
Regions 11.5
Santander 10.5
State Street 0.0
SunTrust 10.5
TD Group 15.2
U.S. Bancorp 11.9
Wells Fargo 12.0
Zions 10.5

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average balances. Median = 10.5%

Return to text

Figure D.13. Other consumer loss rates in the adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 4.6
American Express 0.0
BancWest 3.5
Bank of America 1.6
Bank of NY-Mellon 7.3
BB&T 4.3
BBVA 5.4
BMO 1.7
Capital One 5.8
CIT 10.2
Citigroup 9.9
Citizens 3.9
Comerica 7.1
DBTC 3.0
Discover 9.3
Fifth Third 2.7
Goldman Sachs 4.4
HSBC 5.7
Huntington 2.8
JPMorgan Chase 3.3
KeyCorp 5.5
M&T 4.1
Morgan Stanley 0.6
MUFG Americas 10.2
Northern Trust 11.1
PNC 2.5
Regions 5.6
Santander 12.6
State Street 0.6
SunTrust 3.7
TD Group 1.7
U.S. Bancorp 2.6
Wells Fargo 5.2
Zions 7.3

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average balances. Median = 4.4%

Return to text

Figure D.14. Other loans loss rates in the adverse scenario

Bank Holding Company Percent
Ally 4.6
American Express 0.0
BancWest 4.4
Bank of America 1.9
Bank of NY-Mellon 1.1
BB&T 2.1
BBVA 1.7
BMO 3.1
Capital One 2.5
CIT 7.4
Citigroup 2.2
Citizens 2.0
Comerica 2.9
DBTC 1.2
Discover 3.1
Fifth Third 2.1
Goldman Sachs 3.1
HSBC 2.4
Huntington 2.4
JPMorgan Chase 2.9
KeyCorp 1.8
M&T 2.2
Morgan Stanley 1.9
MUFG Americas 2.1
Northern Trust 2.6
PNC 1.1
Regions 1.7
Santander 6.7
State Street 1.8
SunTrust 1.3
TD Group 2.0
U.S. Bancorp 3.2
Wells Fargo 2.1
Zions 4.6

Note: Estimates are for the nine-quarter period from 2017:Q1-2019:Q1 as a percent of average balances. Median = 2.2%

Return to text

Back to Top
Last Update: September 07, 2017